Democratic congressional candidates in historically crimson Utah captured more votes, overall, than their Republican opponents.
In election results finalized by the state’s 29 counties earlier this week, Democrats came out with nearly 6,000 more votes than the GOP — 491,225 to 485,346.
But three of Utah’s four congressional representatives will still be Republicans. Only the 1st Congressional District, centered in Salt Lake County, voted majority-Democrat.
The election results starkly contrast with President Donald Trump’s 2024 victory in Utah. He won 883,818 votes, while former Vice President Kamala Harris received 562,566 votes.
And in Utah, where Trump’s popularity lagged among Latter-day Saint Republicans, GOP congressional candidates outperformed the president in 2024.
Republicans running for the U.S. House saw 909,332 ballots cast for them — nearly double the 471,051 cast for Democratic challengers.
Democrats’ gains in congressional races came after a state district court ordered lawmakers to adopt new congressional maps in an ongoing legal battle over redistricting.
The new maps, drawn to comply with a 2018 ballot initiative creating an independent redistricting commission and barring partisan gerrymandering, effectively guaranteed Democrats would flip one of Utah’s four GOP-held congressional seats.
The Utah Democratic Party celebrated the ruling, with Chair Brian King calling it “a major victory for voters and a major blow to extreme, out-of-touch politicians.”
But in the wake of Utah’s seismic shift to the left, some politicos are wondering whether the new map ultimately hurt Democrats by keeping them from winning a second — or even third —district.
A few hours after polls closed, outgoing state Sen. Dan McCay, a Republican, posted on social media: “The irony of the results tonight is if Better Boundaries kept the legislatively drawn congressional maps, I think there would be two Democrats elected from Utah to Congress not just one.”
The party’s strong showing extended beyond its Salt Lake County stronghold, within which is the blue 1st congressional district.
Democrats improved their margins in all of Utah’s 29 counties and won five overall. Two of those counties — San Juan and Weber — had previously been reliably red.
A drop in Republicans’ popularity in Utah trickled down the ballot. Democrats and unaffiliated candidates turned over 18 state legislative seats, making next year the first since 1998 that the GOP won’t hold a dual-chamber supermajority.
An analysis by Brigham Young University’s Center for the Study of Elections and Democracy published Wednesday attributed the change to a number of factors, including a smaller proportion of Republicans participating in the election.
In 2024, 63% of voters in U.S. House races were registered Republicans. Only 52% were registered Republicans this year. The voters who were most likely to pivot were those with political ideologies closer to the center.
“Independents and Republicans with looser party ties moved toward Democrats in their voting behavior,” political science professor Quin Monson noted in the brief.
Utahns with strong party loyalties didn’t vote differently than in 2024, Monson added, and “virtually no Republican who identified with the MAGA movement voted for a Democrat for Congress.”
Emily R. Anderson