Before deputies searched the home of the man who shot and killed Patrick Hayes during a road-rage confrontation, their sheriff gave them an instruction: No matter what they found, they shouldn’t arrest him.
That directive from Wasatch County Sheriff Jared Rigby, later documented by an outside reviewer, is among the decisions Hayes’ family has questioned since Hayes’ death in September 2024.
Hayes’ fiancee, Sue Ann Kern, said she and his family sometimes worried during the investigation that it was being mishandled. But they doubted themselves.
“We’re just the victim’s family,” she said. “What do we know? We don’t know anything about the law.”
Now, Rigby has been indicted in connection with another case — accused of using the high-profile murder trial of Kouri Richins to discredit his political rival. In the wake of the charges, Rigby has been on paid leave since late October. He’ll leave office in January, after losing a Republican primary election earlier this year.
For Kern, the indictment reinforced her concerns about how the sheriff handled the investigation of Hayes’ death.
“Seeing what he’s done with other cases and the way he’s behaved,” she said, “and the way he’s managed the sheriff’s office, it just makes it clear to us that he did not handle our case properly.”
In light of the indictment, she and Hayes’ family are calling on authorities — including the Utah Attorney General’s Office — to take a new look at the case.
The attorney general’s office declined to comment, saying it does not confirm or deny investigations. Jon Woodard, the incoming Wasatch County attorney, told The Salt Lake Tribune that he had no plans to reexamine the case.
“While we respect the Hayes family’s perspective,” he said, “the recent indictment does not change the basis for the charging decisions that were made.”
Rigby’s defense attorney did not respond to a request for comment for this story.
Hayes was shot and killed near Jordanelle State Park in what authorities have described as a road rage confrontation. The other driver, Greg DeBoer, drove away after firing a single shot — never calling police, court records allege, and later burying the gun in his backyard. A passing driver found Hayes dead outside his car hours later.
DeBoer told investigators he did shoot Hayes, but that he fired in self-defense. Hayes’ family believes he should face a homicide charge, but the sheriff’s office and Wasatch County prosecutors said there wasn’t enough evidence to disprove his self-defense claim. Prosecutors instead charged him with obstruction of justice.
(Clayton Steward/Park Record/Pool) Greg DeBoer appears in court in April 2025.
DeBoer’s defense attorney, Andrew Deesing, noted that the charging decision was not made by Rigby alone — the case was reviewed by a task force which included several police departments, the attorney general’s office, the medical examiner’s office and the crime lab.
“The suggestion that the indictment of Sheriff Rigby changes the facts of this case or an investigation conducted by seven different government agencies, strains credulity,” Deesing said. “Mr. DeBoer continues to maintain his innocence of the single charge of obstruction of justice in this case.”
An ‘absentee sheriff’
Allegations of misconduct have dogged Rigby long before he was charged in September with obstruction of justice and a misdemeanor count of making a false statement in connection with the Richins case.
Last year, Rigby was supposed to be sworn in as the director of the police regulatory body which certifies and disciplines law enforcement. That unraveled, and state officials rescinded their offer in January 2025, after Fox 13 published a video that showed Rigby talking with an officer who had reported that a chief used excessive force. Rigby told the officer that his “perception is wrong” and that pursuing his complaint could affect the officer’s future in policing.
(Fox 13) Wasatch County Sheriff Jared Rigby in an undated photo.
Then, two months later, county officials stepped in after the Wasatch County Sheriff’s Office was roiled by misconduct allegations — this time, that Rigby was interfering in investigations and retaliating against employees. They hired Richard McKelvie, a retired judge, to look into what was happening in the office.
The Wasatch County Council couldn’t remove Rigby from office or punish him because voters elected him to the role.
McKelvie released his report in September 2025, finding that employees perceived Rigby as showing favoritism, and sometimes didn’t apply for promotions because they felt the process was “rigged in favor” of those who Rigby and his undersheriff wanted in the job. Many of those who McKelvie spoke with said they feared retaliation, he wrote in his report.
Employees described Rigby as an “absentee sheriff,” according to the report, who was rarely in the office. At that time, Rigby had a second, full-time job as a police officer for Brigham Young University. McKelvie found that Rigby was driving his Wasatch County police car to the Provo campus for his shifts — and that the gas was paid for by the county.
When the retired judge asked Rigby about this, McKelvie wrote that the sheriff “expressed the importance of being available at a moment’s notice to return to Wasatch County quickly in the event of an emergency that needed his immediate attention.”
Despite employees saying he wasn’t often at work, McKelvie also documented concerns that Rigby and his undersheriff immersed themselves in investigations at times, “and in a manner that frustrated detectives and deputies pursuing the investigation.”
That included Hayes’ case.
Frustrated investigators
Once Wasatch County investigators zeroed in on DeBoer as the potential shooter, McKelvie wrote in his report, they were preparing to search his home for evidence in November 2024. But Rigby and his undersheriff instructed them not to arrest DeBoer, McKelvie wrote, “regardless of what was found in the search.”
DeBoer allegedly directed investigators to the buried gun — but McKelvie wrote that Rigby’s instruction cost them a potential post-arrest interrogation. Investigators closest to the case believed DeBoer should face a homicide charge, according to McKelvie’s report, and felt the sheriff’s “unnecessary intervention” had limited their ability to gather more evidence.
Hayes’ family also told McKelvie that Rigby acted dismissive toward them and distracted, and seemed convinced there was compelling evidence of self-defense.
The Wasatch County Attorney’s Office has defended charging DeBoer only with obstruction of justice, saying prosecutors did not believe there was a likelihood they could disprove DeBoar’s self-defense claim. (The second-degree felony charge he faces carries a potential of up to 15 years in prison, if he’s convicted. His trial is scheduled for January.)
In a 2024 statement, prosecutors said Hayes was under the influence of alcohol that night. DeBoer told investigators he tried to pass Hayes on Highway 40 after seeing him drive erratically, but Hayes tried to block him. Both drove aggressively, DeBoer said, and he followed Hayes to confront him about his driving.
Surveillance video shows Hayes pull off the road at the gatehouse entrance to a day-use area of Jordanelle State Park and get out with a polymer baton in one hand and a knife in the other. Prosecutors said the video shows DeBoer drive toward Hayes in a “lunging” motion as Hayes approaches and begins hitting DeBoer’s passenger-side window and yelling obscenities.
DeBoer told investigators he worried Hayes would break the window, so he rolled it down. Fearing Hayes would beat him with what he described as a pipe, DeBoer said, he fired through the open window.
Kern said she feels law enforcement overlooked key facts when they made their charging decision, such as that DeBoer followed Hayes to the Jordanelle gatehouse, and then lunged his car toward her fiance. She said the shooting, and how the investigation was handled, is “still just a big cloud sitting over our community.”
“This has been so traumatic for our community, especially those of us that live right by the gatehouse,” she said. “We see it every day. … And we know that our friend was killed there."
Criminal charges
For Hayes’ family, the recent criminal case against Rigby has given new weight to the concerns that McKelvie documented. The retired judge himself has a role in that prosecution: he’s among the team of state attorneys who recently sought the criminal indictment against Rigby.
They allege in court documents that Rigby sent Summit County prosecutors an anonymous letter weeks before Richins’ February trial, questioning the lead detective’s ethics and credibility. That detective, Eric Mainord, was running against Rigby for the sheriff job at that time.
Prosecutors allege the letter was “crafted to discredit Detective Mainord as a candidate.” They say Rigby sought to use the publicity surrounding Richins’ case to pressure Mainord to leave the sheriff’s race or to publicly discredit him during the trial.
Richins, a Kamas mother, was later convicted of poisoning her husband. She was sentenced in May to spend the rest of her life in prison.
(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) Kouri Richins at her sentencing hearing in May.
Mainord dropped out of the race in May, and Jeremy Hales, the man who defeated Rigby in the primary, also won the general election and will be sworn in as sheriff in January.
Charging documents mention that Rigby allegedly tried to target Hales, too. He allegedly emailed an “anonymous letter” about Hales — that prosecutors say he wrote — to the attorney general’s office and asked it to investigate. It declined.

Jessica Schreifels