facebook-pixel

Commentary: I’m thankful this Thanksgiving for the women in the pews, including a Utah dynamo who lived to 105

“Women leave an indelible mark on faith communities. Without them, my 2,000-year-old patriarchal church may not have lasted even a century.”

(Leah Hogsten  |  The Salt Lake Tribune)
Commentator Michael O'Brien says women, like these attending a Mass at the Cathedral of the Madeleine, leave an indelible mark on their faith communities.

(Leah Hogsten | The Salt Lake Tribune) Commentator Michael O'Brien says women, like these attending a Mass at the Cathedral of the Madeleine, leave an indelible mark on their faith communities.

Although the Greek word for church — “ekklesia” — means a gathering of people, Catholic historians fill tomes with tales of patriarchs, popes and priests. Few focus on the people in the pews, let alone on the amazing women there.

The recent death of Utah’s Catherine “Kay” Murphy Schubach — after a remarkable 105 years of life in the American West — reminds me of the importance of these women.

Kay was born Dec. 12, 1920, in Rawlins, Wyoming. Like other Irish descendants at the time, her father, George Murphy, herded livestock as a boy and worked for the railroad.

George also learned the banking business. His fellow Rawlins Irishman — stockman James Cosgriff — brought George to Salt Lake City in 1929 to help run the Continental National Bank and Trust Co.

Then-8-year-old Kay came along. Soon her family’s story intertwined with interesting moments of Utah history.

During a run on Utah financial institutions during the Great Depression, Cosgriff and Murphy offered other bankers zero interest loans to help them survive. They did and then repaid Continental Bank.

(Schubach family) Catherine “Kay” Murphy Schubach, who died Nov. 1, 2026, at age 105, was a prominent force in Salt Lake City's diocese and Catholic schools.

Catholic roots

Kay grew up in a Catholic community flourishing in the heart of a Latter-day Saint city that Brigham Young started. She attended St. Mary of the Wasatch school and went to Mass at “new” churches like the Cathedral of the Madeleine and Our Lady of Lourdes.

She met and married Don Johnson, who died heroically while flying a secret World War II mission, according to the family’s obituary. In 1948, Kay married former Army Capt. Richard (“Dick”) Schubach at Our Lady of Lourdes.

The happy union lasted more than 50 years, produced six children and generated more family moments overlapping with Utah history. Their daughter Mary married a grandson of Utah Sen. Thomas Kearns and his philanthropist wife, Jennie Judge Kearns.

While Dick ran Standard Optical — the family business — Kay took care of the family. Her obituary says she did it with devotion to “the tenets that led her life: positive thinking, kind insight, comfort, quiet faith and full-hearted laughter.”

Kay was the backbone of her church and her children’s schools — J.E. Cosgriff, Judge Memorial and St. Mary. She was a room mother, worked with youth groups, taught etiquette, and was active in the altar society that cared for the church sanctuary and sacred items used during Catholic worship.

(Schubach family) Catherine “Kay” Murphy Schubach, who died Nov. 1, 2026, at age 105, was a prominent force in Salt Lake City's diocese and Catholic schools.

“I will miss her smile and laughter; she found joy in everything,” her daughter Mary told me. “She taught me to have strength and be forgiving.”

Another daughter, Tricia Bennett, praised her mother’s resiliency, determination and grace.

The oldest St. Mary alum, Kay lived long enough to witness the election of Pope Leo XIV, the U.S.-born who had a mother much like Kay. Leo’s mother was a librarian, active in the church choir and wholeheartedly supported his priestly vocation.

Our shared ties

I’m surprised that I never met Kay Schubach. The Holy Cross Sisters taught both of us. I even got my first eyeglasses at Standard Optical.

My first daughter was baptized at her parish: St. Ambrose Catholic Church. For years, I’ve done legal work for The Salt Lake Tribune, including when Kay’s son-in-law Tom McCarthey was part of the management team.

I served on Judge Memorial’s school board with her granddaughter Dominique McCarthey Aragon. I’ve worked for four decades on Salt Lake City’s Main Street, which Kay’s husband Dick worked tirelessly to improve and preserve.

Although I did not know Kay, I have known many Utah Catholic women just like her.

Women who make a difference

One of them, Mary Evans, the mother of one of my classmates, likely did every volunteer job available at the St. Joseph schools in Ogden that her daughter Patty and I attended. Mary was instrumental in the restoration of the Salt Lake City cathedral and helped start a new parish in South Ogden and a health clinic in Haiti.

I did not know Grace Mary Ivers Gallivan, a civic leader and devoted volunteer at the old Holy Cross Hospital and the cathedral. I do know her daughter Gay Gallivan McDonough, who supports the arts and brought to Utah The Ulster Project, an international program seeking to bridge the differences between Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland.

Nancy Richards Essary left a successful career in the oil and gas industry to follow her dream of being an educator. While raising a family, she taught and was a principal in Utah’s Catholic schools for almost three decades. She hosted a homecoming book talk at my old Ogden school when I published my 2021 memoir, “Monastery Mornings.”

My friend Mary Sullivan Jones was a fixture in the classrooms of St. Vincent de Paul Parish School in Holladay when our children went there together. Women like Mary, my wife, Vicki, and my sister Karen Taylor tirelessly and creatively organized social and fundraising events for students and parents alike.

I doubt our St. Thomas More Parish in Cottonwood Heights could function without longtime pastoral assistant Nora Kennedy. For 25 years — while six pastors came and left — Nora has done everything from supervising construction of a building to ensuring we have enough altar wine and Communion wafers for Mass.

I asked Google to explain the importance of women to the Catholic Church. It told me: “Without the work of women in the pews, most Catholic parishes would struggle to function day to day, facing severe drops in attendance, religious education and charitable outreach. While the ordained priesthood is reserved for men, laywomen form the operational, spiritual and social backbone of local church communities.”

Even artificial intelligence gets it. Women leave an indelible mark on faith communities. Without them, my 2,000-year-old patriarchal church may not have lasted even a century.

This Thanksgiving, before I take that first bite of turkey or potatoes covered with delicious homemade gravy, I plan to pause and say a little prayer of gratitude for the women in the pews.

One of them will be Kay Schubach. Eternal rest grant unto her, O Lord, and may the perpetual light shine upon her.

(Michael O'Brien) Writer, attorney and Tribune guest columnist Michael Patrick O'Brien.

Note to readers • Michael Patrick O’Brien is a writer and attorney living in Salt Lake City who frequently represents The Salt Lake Tribune in legal matters. He is the author of “Monastery Mornings: My Unusual Boyhood Among the Saints and Monks.” His new holiday novel, tentatively titled “The Merry Matchmaker Monks of Shamrock Valley,” will be published in time for a future Christmas. He blogs at theboymonk.com.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.