Six judges, three prosecutors and three lawyers in private practice make up the dozen finalists — three of whom are women — that Gov. Spencer Cox will have to choose from to fill two vacancies on the Utah Supreme Court.
The vacancies were created by the resignation of Justice Diana Hagen, who left the court amid an ethics investigation spearheaded by the House of Representatives, and the retirement of Chief Justice Matthew Durrant, who stepped down due to health issues.
After the two spots are filled, Cox will have appointed six of the justices on the Supreme Court that Republican lawmakers expanded to seven seats after suffering a series of defeats in front of the high court.
The finalists for the positions are:
• Cherise Bacalski, founder and appellate attorney at Lotus Appellate Law and adjunct professor of writing at Brigham Young University’s law school;
• Christopher Ballard, general counsel and chief of staff at the Utah County Attorney’s Office;
• Christopher Bates, lawyer and shareholder at Kirton McConkie;
• Matthew Bates, Third District Court judge;
• Matthew Bell, Fifth District Court judge;
• Samuel Chiara, Eighth District Court judge;
• Michele Christiansen Forster, Utah Court of Appeals judge;
• William Hains, deputy director of the criminal appeals division at the Utah Attorney General’s office;
• Michael Menssen, lawyer and partner at Mayer Brown LLP;
• Amy Oliver, Utah Court of Appeals judge;
• Stanford Purser, solicitor general at the Utah Attorney General’s office;
• Ryan Tenney, Utah Court of Appeals judge.
During his first term in office, Cox selected Hagen and Justice Jill Pohlman to fill his first two vacancies on the court. After that, the Legislature changed the makeup of the Appellate Nominating Commission, which vets judges.
Since that time, there had not been a woman among the 19 finalists for the last three open spots on the high court. But the governor said earlier this year that any suggestion that women weren’t being given fair consideration is an “insane narrative.”
“It doesn’t fit,” he said. “I don’t go into this looking at your chromosomes when I’m making an appointment. I’m trying to find the best legal minds who will represent the state of Utah.”
Eight of the 12 finalists — Ballard, both Bateses, Bell, Chiara, Hains, Purser and Tenney — were also on the list the nominating commission sent to the governor for the last two vacancies.
The two nominees Cox chose from the list, Justices Stephen Dent and Jay Jorgensen, were criticized by Democratic senators for not having previously served as a judge at any level, but they were easily confirmed by the Republican-led Senate.
Ballard recently was held in contempt of court by the judge in the case of Tyler Robinson, who is accused of killing conservative commentator Charlie Kirk. The judge said that Ballard improperly discussed the case in media interviews.

Robert Gehrke