facebook-pixel

Did BYU waste AJ Dybantsa’s lone season in Provo? The architects of the Cougars’ roster give their take.

Kevin and Justin Young explain where BYU’s season went wrong, and what could have been.

(Craig Mitchelldyer | AP) BYU guard Kennard Davis Jr. (30), forward AJ Dybantsa (3) and forward Khadim Mboup (7) react after losing in the first round of the NCAA college basketball tournament against Texas, Thursday, March 19, 2026, in Portland, Ore.

(Craig Mitchelldyer | AP) BYU guard Kennard Davis Jr. (30), forward AJ Dybantsa (3) and forward Khadim Mboup (7) react after losing in the first round of the NCAA college basketball tournament against Texas, Thursday, March 19, 2026, in Portland, Ore.

Portland, Ore. • There were times during BYU’s season from hell when Kevin Young couldn’t bring himself to watch the film.

“I couldn’t bear to, honestly,” the Cougars’ head coach said, shaking his head. “Just stuff I was not comfortable with.”

Night after night, BYU trotted out a roster that was a shell of the one supposed to contend for a Final Four, supposed to make school history, supposed to be a high-powered buzzsaw showcasing the No. 1 NBA Draft pick.

Young painstakingly put it together last summer and envisioned all of it. He saw AJ Dybansta as the center of a 3-point-shooting orchestra. Young outfitted it with defensive specialists, rebounding help and a touch of playmaking. To him, it was a perfect basketball concoction.

But then injuries hit and the losses compounded. Four in a row in January. Then three in a row to knock the Cougars out of the top 25. And to end the season, two more.

By the end, it was just painful.

“It’s disappointing not to have the team that we put together around AJ be able to showcase what they could do,” Young lamented. “But you’re trying your best to do it with what you got.”

The best BYU could do, in the end, was a first-round exit in the NCAA Tournament after a 79-71 loss to 11-seed Texas on Thursday night.

(Craig Mitchelldyer | AP) BYU forward AJ Dybantsa, right, goes to the basket past Texas forward Dailyn Swain (3) during the first half in the first round of the NCAA college basketball tournament Thursday, March 19, 2026, in Portland, Ore.

It will go down as a wasted season in Provo — one during which the Cougars couldn’t capitalize on the most talented player to ever walk through the Marriott Center.

Young knows that. Everyone knows that.

“Extremely disappointing,” Young said.

His brother, BYU general manager Justin Young, added, “When they look at it from the outside, they’re probably like, ‘Oh, man, what were they doing?’”

But to the Young brothers, it’s the injuries that inspire the most regret. Because to them, this team was ready to optimize Dybantsa’s talent. They just weren’t given the chance.

“I think it’s unfair in a lot of ways to judge the roster construction of this team just because it was literally five season-ending injuries, right?” Kevin Young said. “It wasn’t one. It wasn’t two, right? And four of those five [guys] were all guys that could knock shots down. … One guy can only do so much.”

(Charlie Riedel | AP) BYU head coach Kevin Young is seen on the sidelines during the first half of an NCAA college basketball game against Houston in the quarterfinal round of the Big 12 Conference tournament Thursday, March 12, 2026, in Kansas City, Mo.

When the Young brothers went to work on BYU’s roster, they told Dybantsa they’d bring in each player with a specific role tailored to his superstar specifications.

BYU re-signed Richie Saunders, an All-American candidate who could hit threes and pour in 20 points a game. It pried Rob Wright III from Baylor to get a point guard, allowing Dybantsa to play off the ball.

Around that core, Young added shooting and defense. Nate Pickens, Kennard Davis, Dawson Baker were all ready to slide into that spot.

“We brought them in for very specific roles,” Justin Young said. “It’s that backup point guard. It’s that 3-point shooting. It’s that leadership experience.”

At first, it worked. BYU raced out to a 17-1 start and rose to sixth in the country. It went on the road to Boston and nearly beat UConn, justifying the hefty price tag this roster came with. It looked like BYU was right to dream.

But Pickens underwent season-ending surgery. Then Baker went down at Thanksgiving. Saunders tore his ACL in February. Two other players, Brody Kozlowski and Xavion Staton, also were sidelined.

“In the NBA, if you have an injury, you can account for that with roster stuff. In college, you’re kind of baked,” Justin Young said. “To outsiders, [the losses] may not move the needle in a big way statistically, but that was critical for us.”

The Baker injury, in particular, put BYU on its heels. He gave BYU shooting off the bench and complimented Saunders and Dybantsa on the floor together. Without him, BYU’s offense showed signs of cracking.

At times after Baker exited, Dybantsa and Saunders were an awkward fit, with Dybantsa almost deferring to the senior.

“Timid isn’t the right word,” Justin Young said. “There’s nothing about AJ that’s timid. But you know what I mean? Like, I respect this guy [Saunders] enough that I want to make sure that I take care of him.”

Still, BYU could paper over any issues with the Saunders-Dybantsa dynamic. It beat Baylor and the bottom of the Big 12 rather easily. But when Saunders went down, the puzzle lost too many pieces. They brought in freshman Aleksej Kostic to play big minutes. Dominique Diomande, who didn’t play for most of the season, was all of a sudden the first man off the bench.

“We had a very specific build around those guys, and it never really got the chance to materialize itself,” Justin Young said.

It led to BYU’s demise in the last gasp of March. Against Texas, Dybantsa had 35 points but no help in sight. BYU went 4-of-22 shooting and gave up 16 offensive rebounds. Seven-footer Matas Vokietaitis pounded BYU inside for 23 points and 16 rebounds.

“Shooting is the holy grail. Bottom line, you got to be able to make shots at a high level. And we didn’t have enough guys that could do that this year,” Kevin Young said. “Those guys [like Dybantsa] need shooting around. Period. End of story.”

BYU forward AJ Dybantsa (3) shoots as Texas forward Dailyn Swain (3) defends during the second half in the first round of the NCAA college basketball tournament Thursday, March 19, 2026, in Portland, Ore. (AP Photo/Craig Mitchelldyer)

In the future, Justin Young can build a more versatile roster. That was a flaw of this team.

“We were looking for somebody that just to fit into this box A [this year]. We need somebody to fit in box A, B and a little bit of C now. So I think about the versatility piece of it,” he said.

But none of it will take away the sting of wasting Dybantsa’s lone season at BYU.

“He’s a unicorn,” Justin Young said. “This year’s build was different.”

“It has been rocky,” Dybantsa admitted. “Injuries before the season, injuries during the season. We lost key components to our team. I kind of had to step up in places I’m not used to.”

Kevin Young saw it flash before him in Portland in Dybansta’s final game. He spun and juked his way to yet another 35-point outburst.

“The Trail Blazers court should have been down on the floor. The guy looked like a stone-cold NBA All-Star out there,” Kevin Young said. “But again, you got to have other guys contribute.”

Too often this season, BYU couldn’t get that.

And a potential NBA All-Star bowed out without an NCAA Tournament win.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.