St. George • In a Republican primary debate Thursday shaped by Washington County’s rapid growth, incumbent commissioner Gil Almquist and challenger Bill Hoster clashed over taxes, transparency, tourism and spending.
Almquist, who is seeking a third term, and Hoster, the former Leeds mayor who is vying to unseat the incumbent in the Seat A commission race, renewed their rivalry from the Washington County Republican Convention in April, where the challenger bested the commissioner by a 301-298 margin.
Both candidates agreed the county is at an inflection point, but often differed about if the county is prepared for what’s ahead and on how open leaders have been with voters about the county’s finances.
On taxes, both candidates pledged to keep property taxes among the lowest in Utah, but outlined different approaches. The county has not raised property taxes for 16 years.
Almquist credited increased sales taxes from a strong local economy and the commission’s careful spending for enabling the county to maintain low tax rates while absorbing inflation and the area’s rapid population growth.
Hoster, in turn, called for more frugality to avoid tax hikes. “The role of government is to protect property, life, and liberty, and that’s it,” he said. “Quality of life is important for sure, but it’s a luxury that we try to do after we have protected property, life, and liberty.”
(Chris Caldwell | Special to The Tribune) Candidate Bill Hoster speaks during a Washington County Commission Seat A GOP primary debate on Thursday, June 4, 2026, in St. George.
He touted his role in working with state lawmakers to pass legislation in 2025 that rolled back a 52% property tax hike the Hurricane Valley Fire Special Service District approved the year before, which implemented a sales-tax increase that shifted that much of the financial burden from local homeowners to tourists.
Asked about the county’s status as a tourist destination, Almquist and Hoster lauded tourism as a key driver of sales and lodging taxes that save local households roughly $1,500 a year in property taxes.
Hoster argued, though, that state lawmakers exercise too much control over tourism tax revenues and how the county can spend them, singling out the St. George’s airport and the Dixie Convention Center as local priorities where the revenues could be spent instead of on marketing.
“We have to actually go to the Legislature and get that stopped,” he said. “Salt Lake City doesn’t know us, so let’s keep [the money] down here in Washington County.”
Almquist agreed more flexibility is needed, but noted state law defines the split between marketing the county and using the revenue for “bricks and mortar” ventures like parks and trails. He added the county has used the tourism dollars it receives to invest in projects like the Wheels Park skateboarding facility in Washington City and the $9 million upgrade to historic Dixie Sunbowl in St. George.
(Chris Caldwell | Special to The Tribune) Washington County Commissioner Gil Almquist speaks with attendees before a Washington County Commission Seat A GOP primary debate on Thursday, June 4, 2026, in St. George.
Almquist joined his colleagues in March to approve a multifamily zoning ordinance for affordable housing along the I-15 corridor between Hurricane and Toquerville. However, he cautioned in the debate that most high-density housing projects belong in municipalities with full services rather than deep in rural, unincorporated areas.
Hoster opposed the new county zone, arguing high-density projects in unincorporated areas are unfair to neighboring cities that bear the impacts without receiving tax benefits. Cities, not the county, should “steer the ship” on high-density housing, he added.
Pressed by the moderator about budget transparency, Almquist argued the county is transparent with taxpayers and simply needs to make information about the county’s finances easier to find.
“The budget needs to be on our front page when you go to the Washington County website,” he said.
Hoster said the budget is too difficult to find, and that he had to access the information from state government sources to find out more about how the county’s tax dollars are being spent. He said the county should use technology to put that information out front and center.
“It hasn’t happened up to this point, and I’ll make sure it does,” he added.
Almquist turned to boating to ask for the audience’s vote.
“Washington County is not leaking. We have our sails out. This is a county that’s moving. We have momentum,” he said. “This ship, if you go with the metaphor, is fully loaded. It is a battleship that will take on every challenge.”
Hoster countered it was more important to look through the windshield at the challenges ahead, rather than peer through the rearview mirror on what has been done in the past.
“We need to have accountability,” he said. “We need to have transparency. We need to have fiscal responsibility. These are all things that are going to get us through the critical times.”
The winner of the June 23 primary for commission Seat A will face Democratic challenger Gail Koske in the November general election.
Mark Eddington