facebook-pixel

Can you split Salt Lake County? See if your boundaries would qualify under lawmaker’s proposal.

The clock stopped HB212 from becoming law, but the idea isn’t likely to go away.

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Salt Lake County Government Center pictured in 2022.

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Salt Lake County Government Center pictured in 2022.

How realistic would it be to split Salt Lake County into two?

It’s the idea at the center of the ill-fated HB212, sponsored by Rep. Jordan Teuscher, R-South Jordan. You may remember that as the bill that Utah Republican leaders tried to push through right before the Legislative session’s midnight buzzer last month. They weren’t able to — as Utah Democrats pointed out, the final votes came a few seconds after the metaphorical horn sounded, and so the bill didn’t go to Gov. Spencer Cox’s desk for a signature.

Let’s turn back the clock, though. What would have happened if lawmakers had, well, turned back the clock?

It’s not just a hypothetical: Teuscher told City Cast Salt Lake he’ll likely bring the bill back in the next session; he’s been trying to get similar legislation through for a few years. Given that it garnered enough support this session to pass, it certainly wouldn’t surprise anyone to see it on Utah’s books in the future.

But then what?

The bill only applied to counties with a population greater than 1 million, so only Salt Lake County qualifies right now. (Utah County has approximately 750,000 residents.)

In order for the county to split, the cities totalling at least one-third of the county’s population would have to adopt triggering resolutions. Then, those cities would have to band together to conduct a feasibility study, examining the costs of seceding.

If the feasibility study passed muster, then the question would be passed on to the voters at the next general election. A majority of voters from both the remnants of Salt Lake County and the proposed new county would have to approve the measure. (This last clause is actually in the Utah Constitution, not just HB212.) Two Januaries after the vote, the new county would officially exist.

So in order to answer the question of whether or not splitting Salt Lake County is realistic under these terms, we have to understand how difficult it would be to get a majority of voters on board from a group of cities representing at least one-third of the county’s population — plus a majority of the remnants.

I wanted to see: Is there a likely coalition of cities that would qualify?

Our interactive map

To try to find out, I used Codex to help me create a tool that would let me visually explore coalitions — and I figured I’d share it so you could do the same.

Below is a map of Salt Lake County’s 23 municipalities and their boundaries. Click on the map or the scrolling list to select groups of cities to put together your potential new county.

The tool will then tell you if your proposed county has enough residents (and has contiguous boundaries) to qualify.

My big takeaway from this: It’s hard to get enough residents together to form a new county under the proposed terms of HB212!

First, I was curious about the cities represented by Teuscher and the bill’s Senate sponsor, Dan McCay. Teuscher represents parts of South Jordan, while McCay’s district includes parts of Herriman, Riverton, Bluffdale, and Draper.

But even if all of these cities decided to secede, the county would be 140,000 residents short of qualifying. Adding West Jordan or Sandy alone wouldn’t do it either; you’d need both cities to join the effort. That would be a massive undertaking.

Another idea: What if Salt Lake City wanted to secede, creating a more Democratic county under which to operate? If the city merged with blue-leaning voters in South Salt Lake, Millcreek, Holladay, and Cottonwood Heights, could they form a new county?

Nope! They’d still need relatively independent Murray, Midvale, or Sandy to come along for the ride.

The next step: Were there possible coalitions of cities I hadn’t yet considered? To investigate, I wanted to look at how voters in various cities weighed in on various county-wide issues in the last decade. I picked three: the 2024 vote about the Zoo, Arts, and Parks sales tax, the 2024 vote about the property tax hike to increase jail capacity, and the 2015 Proposition 1 that would have increased sales tax for transportation funding.

Those are also represented in the tool above. Click on any of the three buttons to explore how voters from each city decided on each ballot measure — or click “Coalition” to return to the standard view.

You begin to see potential coalitions forming, but also notice challenges. Voters in Salt Lake County’s two biggest cities, Salt Lake City and West Valley City, voted quite differently on each of the three referendums. Voters in South Jordan might have more in common with those in Sandy and Draper than they do with those in West Jordan. And so on.

I don’t think this is impossible, but under these rules, it’s just hard to find a configuration of voters that would overall support secession.

That’s probably good, because it sure doesn’t seem like the city mayors are interested in leaving Salt Lake County, either.

Local reactions

City Cast’s Emily Means asked the 23 mayors in Salt Lake County about Teuscher’s bill — and there wasn’t a single one who was willing to go on the record in support of the idea. Not in Teuscher’s or McCay’s district (Riverton Mayor Tish Buroker said she did “not support, and would not consider” leaving Salt Lake County, while South Jordan mayor Dawn Ramsey said Teuscher hadn’t contacted them about it), nor anywhere else.

Indeed, several mayors who would be pretty important for most realistic coalitions you can make on the map denounced the plan. Millcreek Mayor Cheri Jackson, for example, said, “Given our geographical position in SL County, I don’t think it is something we would consider. It wouldn’t make sense for us.”

Midvale Mayor Dustin Gettel was perhaps strongest: “The practical realities of such a move would make it extremely difficult to justify. Standing up a new county would come with significant costs to taxpayers, require rebuilding services and infrastructure that the county already provides effectively, and demand years of time and staff resources that our city would much rather invest in serving our residents.”

Given all of this, HB212 is a pretty confusing piece of almost-legislation.

Creating an eligible coalition of cities appears difficult. The city representatives, who largely say they weren’t consulted by Teuscher, don’t appear to want to leave Salt Lake County. So … who was this for, exactly?

This bill demonstrated more strongly than any other that time is limited in the Legislature.

Let’s use it more wisely.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.