Days after a midnight vote that would’ve cleared a path to split the state’s largest — and most liberal — county in two, Senate President Stuart Adams said the tally came too late to count.
On paper, HB212, sponsored by Rep. Jordan Teuscher, R-South Jordan, would’ve allowed cities in a county of a million residents or more to split off if they account for at least a third of the county’s total population and pass required resolutions. Meeting those requirements would get a measure on the ballot.
In reality, it would have only affected Salt Lake County immediately.
As the clock struck midnight on Saturday — signaling the end of the 2026 legislative session — senators were still voting on the measure.
Sen. Nate Blouin, D-Salt Lake City, shouted, “Point of order!” from the Senate floor.
“It was after midnight!” he yelled as voting ended.
But Blouin said Saturday that his objection was “basically ignored.” He added that Sen. Kathleen Riebe, D-Cottonwood Heights, also tried to raise a concern but was not recognized by Adams as lawmakers “rushed” to present the bill and take the vote before the session ended.
Final votes were late
On Monday, Adams, a Layton Republican, said in a statement that the bill “did not pass within the constitutionally required timeframe.” All legislation, he added, is reviewed to ensure constitutional and statutory compliance once the session is over.
“The way the rules are written, the way the Constitution is written, there is not a 5-second or 10-second grace period,” Blouin said. “Midnight means midnight — not midnight in 5 or 10 seconds.”
Residents already have the power to split counties, but it’s hard to do. Petitioners must gather signatures from at least a quarter of a county’s population to get a measure on the ballot.
In Salt Lake County, that’s over 300,000 people — a bar so high, Teuscher called it “nearly impossible.”
The current path also doesn’t provide a way for voters to understand the consequences of a potential county split, Teuscher said in a Feb. 20 committee hearing, so residents would not be able to make an informed decision at the ballot box. His bill, he argued, made the process more transparent.
County Council sought influence
Teuscher said the bill has resurfaced in the Legislature for the past six or seven years. The Salt Lake County Council initially opposed the bill, but ultimately planned to work with the sponsor since the legislation has repeatedly returned to Capitol Hill.
Council Republicans were hesitant to support the measure in a Jan. 27 meeting because of what breaking up Salt Lake County would cost taxpayers, but felt the best way to move forward on the bill was to negotiate the terms of what a split would look like.
Council Democrats still opposed the effort due to the potential increase in property taxes such a breakup would cause. Salt Lake County Mayor Jenny Wilson, also a Democrat, added in the Jan. 27 meeting that the bill dies every year “for a reason.”
“I think if we were talking specifically about, ‘do we want the next step,’ I think there’s at least five of you that would be, ‘hell no,’” Wilson said at the meeting. “So this, to me, seems like you put your toe in the water, pretty soon you’re swimming.”
In its Feb. 3 meeting, the council voted on the bill again, and moved to take a neutral position in a 4-3 party line vote, with Republicans making up the majority. Republican council member Carlos Moreno and Democratic council member Jiro Johnson were absent from the meeting.
Council Chair Aimee Winder Newton said Teuscher incorporated all of Salt Lake County’s recommendations on the bill — including a provision that a group of cities wanting to secede would have to pay for a feasibility study on a potential shift.
“We recognize if anybody wanted to split, it would be expensive,” Winder Newton said. “We’re grateful that there’s a feasibility study in there and that all county residents will get a chance to vote. We don’t anticipate that this will ever happen, but understand that it’s always good to have tools ready for things that may happen in the future.”

Samantha Moilanen
Jordan Miller
