A Tooele County butcher‘s animal-cruelty case will be dismissed, a judge ordered last week, as long as the butcher follows the rules outlined in a plea agreement.
The owner of Tooele Valley Meat was facing a misdemeanor-level aggravated animal cruelty charge after a U.S. Department of Agriculture inspector saw him sever a conscious steer’s hoof when the animal became stuck and injured in a fence in November.
On Friday, 3rd District Judge L. Douglas Hogan approved a diversion agreement, which requires the butcher continue to run his shop in compliance with federal and state standards, and not commit any crimes outside of minor traffic violations for six months. He must also pay a $500 fee.
In exchange, the owner’s case will be dismissed and could be expunged at the end of the agreement, according to the order.
The Salt Lake Tribune is not identifying the man because The Tribune does not typically cover low-level criminal charges.
Tooele County prosecutors and the man’s defense attorney wrote in court papers filed last month that they agreed to the diversion plea because the USDA had already closed its case after the man submitted satisfactory written corrective and preventive action plans and was in “compliance with regulatory and statutory requirements.”
Attorneys also noted in the order that the butcher had submitted two letters to the court from licensed veterinarians who agreed his actions were “justified, humane, and alleviated undue pain and stress the animal would have endured if it was left to hang for an indeterminate period of time.”
The charges stem from a Nov. 5 incident, when a black steer in line to be killed at Tooele Valley Meat became stuck between a gate post and gate after it tried to escape the queue and jump the fence, according to a USDA notice of suspension letter.
The animal broke its leg at the ankle and laid against the gate, the notice said.
The owner decided to free the animal by amputating its hoof, according to the notice. Inspectors warned employees twice that the steer needed to be stunned — and therefore unconscious — before that happened, but about 15 minutes after the animal became trapped, the owner sliced off its hoof and corralled it into the slaughterhouse.
The butcher’s attorney declined to comment this week.
The man’s shop had previously issued a statement that read: “We sincerely apologize for our actions and the distress this incident caused. While our intent was to act quickly to relieve an animal in distress, we recognize that our response did not meet federal humane handling standards or our own expectations.”
County prosecutors has investigated Tooele Valley Meat before, in May 2018, for allegations that an employee used a 9mm pistol to kill a hog over the course of 15 minutes.
“It took the employee four attempts to kill the animal and at one point they ran out of ammunition,” The Associated Press reported at the time. The report mentioned the USDA had “documented a similar incident in March.”

Paighten Harkins