For the past week, Herriman police Sgt. Greg Shaver has been dealing with a closed domestic violence case and the fallout of a reality television scandal.
The department has been inundated with phone calls and requests for public documents involving influencer Taylor Frankie Paul and her ex-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen, as a global spotlight shines on Utah.
And Shaver wants to make one thing clear: The video that ignited this media storm did not come from the Herriman Police Department.
“When TMZ initially started all this frenzy … how they obtained that original video, we don’t know,” Shaver told The Salt Lake Tribune. “We didn’t provide that.”
It’s a video Mortensen recorded of a 2023 argument between him and Paul. The video shows Paul hitting and kicking Mortensen and throwing metal chairs. One of them hits her daughter, who is sitting nearby.
Paul agreed to a plea in abeyance to resolve her aggravated assault case, which gives her the chance to have the third-degree felony reduced to a Class A misdemeanor later this year.
Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill said his office could not comment on the video or whether it was evidence in Paul’s 2023 case.
TMZ shared the video on March 19 and it sent shockwaves through the entertainment world, prompting speculation about who “leaked” the video.
On social media, fellow MomTok creator Miranda McWhorter said the video didn’t come from any of the other mom influencers, but she added that she had “theories” on who leaked it.
After the video’s release, Paul’s season of “The Bachelorette” was canceled. Fans and MomTok moms reacted. News of another investigation involving Paul and Mortensen — this one stemming from a February domestic violence call to Draper police — led to a pause in filming of the fifth season of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.”
Gill said the Draper prosecutor is evaluating the recent allegation, but his office requested the investigative material because any new charge filed against Paul could be affect her existing plea deal. A new charge could also be enhanced — or more serious — if she is accused of a new domestic violence charge so soon after her first case.
On Tuesday morning, TMZ posted another video from 2023. The footage, captured by a police officer’s body camera, shows a follow-up visit officers made to Paul about a week after the argument. This time, the video did come from the Herriman Police Department after TMZ obtained it through a public records request, Shaver said.
Such requests are allowed under Utah’s Government Records Access Management Act, or GRAMA.
Since the first video was shared by TMZ, Shaver said his department has received 18 GRAMA requests from media outlets, including two from TMZ. Herriman police have fulfilled these requests as required by the law, Shaver said.
“It’s definitely hindered us in our daily operations [because] of trying to answer these within the timely manner,” he said.
Shaver added that his department has had no other involvement with Paul or Mortensen since 2023.
“We handled this case in 2023. It went through the court process. It went through the judicial system, done what it’s supposed to do, and we’re just doing our daily operations for the citizens of our city,” Shaver said.
Ryan Ficklin, Paul’s attorney, works at Eric M. Swinyard and Associates. A representative at the firm stated that Ficklin declined to comment for this story.
R. Christian Hansen, Mortensen’s attorney, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Correction, March 26, 2026, at 10:23 a.m.: After publication of this story, Herriman police said they had the 2023 video that Mortensen recorded in evidence. But the department did not provide the video to TMZ before the news outlet published it on March 19.

Palak Jayswal
Jordan Miller
