Jaime Andre tuned into Utah influencer Taylor Frankie Paul’s life long before she was set to become the next “Bachelorette.”
“She’s the whole reason I even downloaded TikTok,” Andre, who lives in Indiana and is part of a Facebook fan group for “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” said.
Andre was intrigued by Paul’s satirical content and found a connection to her sense of humor and as a former member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
When Paul, the founder of MomTok, helped get the content creator hub a Hulu television series, Andre started watching that, too.
“I feel like I watched the show because I’ve watched all the drama unroll online first,” Andre said.
And there has been a lot of drama.
For the past five years, the drama of MomTok and its creators has drawn in millions of viewers, and fueled the influencers overall success. But this week, it reached a breaking point.
On Thursday, Paul’s upcoming season of “The Bachelorette” was canceled by ABC after a video of a 2023 domestic violence incident between her and her ex-boyfriend Dakota Mortensen emerged. In it, Paul is seen attacking Mortensen and throwing metal chairs, one of which strikes her daughter who is sitting on the couch.
Back then, Paul entered a plea in abeyance to a third-degree felony count of aggravated assault. But earlier this week, news of another, separate domestic incident between Mortensen and Paul in February broke. Paul has responded to the headlines and to the cancellation of her “Bachelorette” season.
This new allegation led the other moms of MomTok to decide to stop filming season five of their show. Miranda McWhorter and Layla Taylor have both issued statements about the recent headlines.
“Domestic violence and abuse of any kind is something I take very seriously. As a human, and especially as a mother, I cannot support that kind of behavior,” McWhorter wrote.
“My personal history as a survivor makes it impossible for me to stay silent … I stand firmly against domestic violence in any form,” Taylor wrote.
Both mothers expressed empathy and care for Paul’s children.
For fans of the creator, the surfaced video has prompted a range of reactions.
“I’m so sad for her, because behind all the headlines, there’s a human being who’s very hurt,” Andre said.
Local fans, like Kika VilaNova, feel similarly.
VilaNova moved to Utah 25 years ago from Brazil and lives in Sandy. She doesn’t watch much reality television, but likes to tune into Utah-centric shows to see how the culture and people of the state are being portrayed and perceived.
“One thing that I have come to realize about these shows is that we only know so little about what’s really happening behind closed doors,” she said. “I feel horrible for [Paul] as a woman and as a divorced woman. … That’s not to say that I think she’s innocent in everything. She needs a lot of help and hopefully she will get it.”
Chelsey Olson, who lives in Minnesota, said she’s been a “number one Taylor fan” and would consider the content creator her favorite.
“Now it’s like, OK, I don’t know about all that anymore,” Olson said on Thursday afternoon.
Olson said the release of the 2023 video was “terrifying” and that even though the altercation has been public knowledge for a while — it paused filming of season one of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” and police footage was featured in the show — she felt the show was vague on details, like the metal chairs, and Paul’s daughter being there.
Olson, who contributes regularly to the Facebook fan group, is “rooting” for Paul to get mental health help, and hopes she will return to the Hulu show.
For some, the reality television series has helped them understand their new home, like West Valley City resident Sierra Gaynor, who moved to Utah just after it started airing, especially because she lived in Utah County for some time.
“It was just a way [for] me [to feel] more connected to the place where I lived,” she said. “Even though there was drama, you kind of relate to it and see all the different points of view. It made me feel closer to Utah.”
But, after watching the last season of the show, which released just over a week ago, Gaynor said she feels “misled” by Paul.
“After seeing that video … I have a hard time separating her from that now … I don’t know who I was watching on screen or if it was just for the camera,” she said.
If Paul were ever to return to the show, Gaynor said she would wish for a way to watch and skip over Paul’s screen time. “It sucks because I don’t think it’s a true reflection of the state or the culture here,” she said.
For now, fans wonder what the future of MomTok and “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” will be without its founder.
Andre, who downloaded TikTok because of Paul, said, “I definitely think MomTok could survive this; it would just be a bumpy road to get there.”

Palak Jayswal