facebook-pixel

Gordon Monson: BYU football kicks pressure to the curb and cradles victory

Arizona had its moments Saturday in Provo. BYU, though, had the last word.

(Trent Nelson  |  The Salt Lake Tribune) BYU Cougars wide receiver Reggie Frischknecht (18) runs for a touchdown as BYU hosts Arizona, NCAA football in Provo on Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026.

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) BYU Cougars wide receiver Reggie Frischknecht (18) runs for a touchdown as BYU hosts Arizona, NCAA football in Provo on Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026.

Provo • On a sun-drenched Saturday afternoon at LaVell Edwards Stadium, Kalani Sitake squinted across an expanse of green at a team, his team, that, in proportion on this occasion, against a rock-solid Big 12 opponent, had more to lose than it had to gain.

There’s no other way to say it.

He knew that’s the way it would be, the way it would be against Arizona here and the way it likely will be against every conference foe everywhere all season.

Expectations do that sort of thing to a team. They put darn near everything everywhere into a press, a squeeze, a slam-bam challenge. Remember, last year the Cougars won four one-score games and managed to come from behind in those and others.

Didn’t matter then, doesn’t matter now. None of those wins were easy, and neither was Saturday’s 28-17 victory.

“It’s not going to be an easy thing,” Sitake said afterward. It’s just … “let’s get back to who we are.”

That last part was precisely what BYU did against the Wildcats, eventually — and in doing so, it met the aforementioned expectations with a win. It might have been sloppy at times, but nobody said perfection was the goal. Just a W, a lot of Ws.

If and as the Cougars earn those, they take another step forward in a game-by-game march toward a league championship and a playoff spot. Just one misstep — or maybe two — and their reasons for playing drastically change. Indeed, this iteration of BYU football personifies and exemplifies the cliché that hangs over them: Losing feels worse than winning feels good.

And it would have, but it didn’t.

Win and win and win again keeps hope and spirits alive.

Lose, and that hope, those spirits get blown to bits.

That’s called pressure. And Sitake’s not the only Cougar who carried — and carries, still — that burden; they all do. That’s what teams aspiring to greatness do. It’s part of the ongoing test.

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) BYU Cougars linebacker Cade Uluave (4) celebrates an interception as BYU hosts Arizona, NCAA football in Provo on Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026.

1 / 43

BYU went ahead and passed a fraction of it on this occasion against a team with its own aspirations, a team that clearly said in the run-up that it had specific intentions of avenging its double-overtime loss to the Cougars last season. This time, its loss came in regulation.

It was a close encounter that kept elements of contortion on Sitake’s face long after the result was in and the sun was descending. As he walked off the field, he seemed to be inhaling and exhaling relief as much as air.

“It was tough,” Sitake said. “We had to make some adjustments and change some things; that’s because Arizona was putting us on our heels.”

Some observers might fall on one feeling about this game, one word: unconvincing.

“We’ve got to be better,” said Sitake. Over time, quarter by quarter, they were.

The Cougars certainly had their troubles, especially in the first half. What took place then and there was mostly a letdown.

Plainly spoken, through large portions of the initial two quarters, Arizona was the superior team; it looked that way at least. The Wildcats used intentional runs and efficient spacing in their short passing game to cause BYU great difficulty, often going wide to gain substantial pieces of yardage, enough to manage their way down the field for a couple of touchdowns. A wide-open Shane King caught a 16-yard score with 2:03 on the clock in the second quarter, giving Arizona the halftime lead, 17-14.

The center of UA’s success — and this was no big surprise — was quarterback Noah Fifita, who used both an accurate arm and nimble feet to punish the BYU defense. What might have been a surprise, at least at first, was how soft the Cougar resistance was.

The defense had its early moments, such as when linebacker Cade Uluave picked off Fifita, and a minute later, BYU scored its first touchdown on a Bear Bachmeier run.

All told, though, over that first half, Arizona gave the Cougars as much, if not more, than they could handle. Fifita completed 16 of 20 passes for 141 yards, one touchdown pass and one touchdown run. And all that talk from the Wildcats about exacting revenge appeared anything but far-fetched.

Said Sitake: “[Fifita] knew exactly where to put the ball.”

BYU’s attack had its moments, too, including a 75-yard TD drive, punctuated by a 25-yard scoring throw from Bachmeier to Reggie Frischknecht, a success that saw the receiver break open and then jog into the end zone.

But that kind of offensive efficiency wasn’t on point on time on average, not enough to keep the Cougars ahead. And BYU’s defense … well, you had to wonder how much money BYU would have to find to lure Jay Hill back from Michigan.

And then …

And then.

In the second half, nobody cared about Hill, not with the way Kelly Poppinga awakened and adjusted his defense. Not sure what he said in the locker room at the break, but whatever it was, it should be bottled, sold and regularly imbibed. Sitake put it like this: “Let’s figure out what we’re good at and do that.”

All right, then.

BYU shut down and shut out the Wildcats in the crucial quarters. And its offense did enough.

The Cougars stirred a sweet drive that featured what folks expected that attack to present all along — nine plays, 75 yards that seemed easy, finishing with a Bachmeier pass to Kyler Kasper for a favorable 21-17 BYU lead.

There were mistakes committed, dropped balls and blown tackles suffered, even by some of BYU’s best players. Perhaps those errors will hurt the Cougars down the road, if they persist — against some opponent, but not against this one on this Saturday.

An example: With BYU clinging to a four-point lead midway through the fourth quarter, a blown coverage kept Arizona alive on a drive deep into BYU territory, a drive that led to a fourth-and-4 call at the BYU 21-yard line. UA went for it, and that play initially was ruled a first down at the 17 — it was a call that could have rearranged this outcome — but after review, it was the call itself that was rearranged.

The Cougars were awarded the ball.

And, man, did they take advantage of that — with a 61-yard pass from Bachmeier to Legend Glasker that flipped the field and the game. A subsequent Bachmeier-to-Kasper, 12-yard TD throw jacked the count to 28-17 and slammed the door on the guys reaching for but unable to quite grasp their revenge.

Bottom line is this: If BYU can make pressure its friend, can get comfortable with it and embrace it and run and pass with it, the Cougars just might, in spite of their needed awakenings and adjustments and also their imperfections, be what they aim to be — unconvincing or not.

Losing? Ppfffwww.

Winning, turns out, feels pretty darn good, come as it may.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.