Just when you think Latter-day Saints have lightened up on rigid gender roles, it’s Mother’s Day and here come the all-too-common platitudes about “angel mothers” who never raised their voices.
No matter what is said over the pulpit (or what symbolic gift is handed out), though, some women in the pews continue to experience feelings of angst, guilt, dismissal, denial and outright anger at what they hear as unrealistic or irrelevant expectations.
Despite contemporary economic, regional and practical realities for American couples, the issue of women working and motherhood remains as fraught as ever in a faith as committed to home and family as Mormonism.
Indeed, these days debates about it seem to be magnified and exacerbated by social media.
Case in point: A recent posting on The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints’ Instagram account tells the story of Nate, a member from Arizona, whose wife got into medical school in California, leading the couple to move.
“Stepping into her dream together was an easy choice. I wanted to support her the way she has always supported me. And honestly, watching her work and sacrifice and love people like she does has strengthened my faith more than anything else,” writes Nate, who said his path is less clear. “...Supporting her doesn’t shrink my purpose — it expands it. Our callings from God can look different, and that’s beautiful. I’m building my future too, but I’m grateful that right now, part of my purpose is cheering for the person I love most as she steps into hers.”
He concludes: “There’s not one ‘right way’ to build a family or a future. For us, this is ours. And it’s sacred.”
The piece, especially that last line, triggered a tsunami of negative reactions.
“Marriages where the man is not the breadwinner are 70% more likely to end in divorce,” writes one. “Nobody should be cheering this on. It’s cool that she’s a doctor, it’s not cool that he’s talking himself into being OK with being a soy boy stay-at-home caretaker.”
Another faults the church for presenting an unbalanced perspective.
“Could the church P.R. department please balance this out with a woman who gave up a lucrative career to be a homemaker?” he asks. “We need to value homemakers more than career women in our society.”
Several suggest that Nate’s choices contradict the church’s official stance on gender roles.
The church offers “clear guidance on the ideal outcomes for a family,” writes still another commenter, declaring that “the family proclamation is doctrine.”
Is it? Is every couple who chooses a nontraditional gender path considered disobedient or less righteous?
And why is this still a question for millennials who came of age in an internet era and a global faith?
Generational differences
In the early 20th century, “stay-at-home mom” wasn’t an “an expression that was commonly used,” Robin Ritch writes in “Using Friction to Grow: Stories of Strength and Resilience, LDS Women 1968-1976,” a new book about “pioneering” Latter-day Saint women.
From 1900 to the 1940s, women worked on farms, in industries and in the community, she explains. “Anybody who could work, worked.”
By the ‘50s and ‘60s, women in certain demographics could stay home, Ritch writes, and by the 1970s, that was available to all demographics.
That latter era was “the decade of the woman,” she reports, yet women “still couldn’t have a credit card or buy a house with a mortgage. … Educational equality was nonexistent, as many colleges and universities had admissions policies that limited or excluded women from programs or prevented their admission altogether.”
And Latter-day Saint presidents repeatedly warned women that if they worked outside the home, the personal and societal consequences could be calamitous.
“Between 1850 and 1960, the word ‘motherhood’ was mentioned 74 times in General Conference,” Ritch writes. “But between 1960 and 2020, church leaders spoke about motherhood 184 times, more than doubling the number of mentions in a little more than half the time.”
(The Salt Lake Tribune) Ezra Taft Benson urged Latter-day Saint mothers to return home.
In a 1987 speech, “To the Mothers in Zion,” then-President Ezra Taft Benson declared, “Contrary to conventional wisdom, a mother’s place is in the home, not the workplace.”
The aging church president linked working mothers “to a litany of common social ills associated with the liberalism of modern America,” writes Latter-day Saint historian Andrea Radke-Moss, “including declining marriage and childbirth, access to birth control and abortion, spiraling numbers of divorces, and the rise of juvenile delinquency.”
Around that time, about 51% of Latter-day Saint women were either working or looking for work, Radke-Moss explains in an essay on women and gender in a volume about Benson. And, trying to be obedient to the prophet, a portion of those women abandoned their work and returned to hearth and home.
What about his directives for men?
“It is not difficult to trace a connection between Benson’s early language on male authority in the home,” concludes Radke-Moss, and the church’s subsequent statements about gender in the forthcoming "The Family: A Proclamation to the World."
A set of official expectations
In 1995, the Utah-based faith produced a document that would soon be hung on members’ walls and distributed to believers worldwide. It carried a reverence largely reserved for scripture
The proclamation, as it was called, declared that men were to preside, protect and provide for the family, while women were to nurture the children. Though it allowed for some circumstantial “adaptation,” those were laid out as ideal gender roles.
These days, many more American couples are embracing unconventional roles as perfectly permissible, even desirable. Meanwhile, some older women feel betrayed that they followed the old rules (giving up careers to stay home), while others like Relief Society General President Camille Johnson did not.
There were more than 2,000 comments on social media about Johnson’s address last year at Brigham Young University’s Women’s Conference, where she shared her story of going to law school while having babies.
(The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) Relief Society General President Camille N. Johnson speaks about education and work as a lawyer during BYU Women's Conference in Provo in 2024.
Many noted the difference between her path and the one others followed, believing they were taking the more church-approved course.
“I’m grateful for this message and example,” replied one commenter. “However, I’m 25, and this is the very first time I’ve EVER heard a church leader suggest it’s acceptable for [mothers] to work outside the home.”
Kristine Haglund, former editor of Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, believes the proclamation should be a guide, not a set of rules.
“The wording is vague enough to allow a lot of adaptation, and therefore also too vague for [church leaders] to explicitly disavow it. They never will,” Haglund writes on social media. “And official announcements are just not how doctrine changes in the church.”
There was never a formal “policy about women working,” just “more and less emphatic discourse,” the former editor says. “I am glad not to have things officially codified. The flexibility and scope for personal revelation created by this patchwork is a feature, not a bug.”
(The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) "The Family: A Proclamation to the World" was unveiled in September 1995.
Is it religious whiplash?
That brings us to the church’s story about Nate, who let his wife’s career dominate.
The church’s post doesn’t “seem to contradict,” writes a woman from Logan, “it outright contradicts previous statements made by church leaders.”
And in the case of men, the church has been “no kinder to at-home fathers than it was to mothers who worked outside the home,” she writes. “Everyone seems to have forgotten just how harsh the [previous statements] were and exactly how specific they were.”
A lot of families and “individuals in the church, myself included, would have liked to have been publicly notified when exactly those rules had changed, as a professional courtesy. Good people made life-limiting and life-altering decisions based on that harsh counsel,” the woman writes. “If that counsel was incorrect, they should admit it. I think that when their opinions were that harsh for that long, I don’t think they can expect to do a complete 180-degree turn without getting asked a few questions.”
Lately, says Lisa Torcasso Downing, a Latter-day Saint in Dallas, “church behavior has been a mixed bag.”
Nate’s story and the proclamation “are too opposite one another for both to be considered one true perspective,” Downing says. “The proclamation seems to represent the perspective of those in power while the story seems to represent the perspective of most members, including those who are fully active. That’s a schism, and it can’t bode well. If this is a real shift in the attitude of the brethren, they should openly address their decision to lighten up.”
When Downing’s husband was in dental school decades ago, there was a Latter-day Saint woman in his class, who was constantly harassed about being there.
The woman confided to Downing that many people — including female Relief Society presidents and local male leaders at church — had “pulled her aside to tell her she shouldn’t be in dental school,” the Texas writer recalls, “that the place belonged to a man.”
But the woman felt being there was “an answer to her prayers,” Downing recalls her saying. “And her husband was a nurturing man who supported her completely.”
For her part, Downing says, “I made the decision to stay home to follow the advice of leaders.”
But it’s impossible for her “not to feel like I’ve been gaslighted,” she says. “I could have had a life as a paid writer.”
A universal ideal in a global faith?
The tug-of-war between mothers working or staying home is a particularly American conflict — one that makes little sense to church members in far-flung regions.
There is no clear distinction between home and work, for example, for many Latter-day Saint women in South America, Asia and Africa.
In Hong Kong, thousands of Latter-day Saint women from the Philippines toil as “domestic workers” caring for Chinese children, sending money to their husbands and children back home.
There is no judgment of them as being “bad mothers,” say church members in that bustling city.
Even in the United States, it is increasingly difficult for families — especially those with more children than the national average — to survive on just one income. “Adaptations” have almost become the rule.
That makes the embrace of traditional Latter-day Saint teachings on men and women, well, complicated.
Not every woman wants or needs a “Nate” to relocate to support her education and career, Haglund says. “But every family needs to be led by partners who are thoughtful and creative about using all of their talents.”
Tolstoy was wrong, she says. Happy families are not all alike.

Peggy Fletcher Stack