facebook-pixel

Some LDS have ‘pope envy,’ wonder why their leaders aren’t speaking out against these wars

Latter-day Saint leaders certainly have urged peacemaking, but the sometimes frank directness and blunt rhetoric of the past have softened.

(Photo illustration by Christopher Cherrington  |  The Salt Lake Tribune) Photos from Salt Lake Tribune archives.

(Photo illustration by Christopher Cherrington | The Salt Lake Tribune) Photos from Salt Lake Tribune archives.

The Latter-day Saint prophet had a bold warning for all members of his church: “We are a warlike people, easily distracted from our assignment of preparing for the coming of the Lord.”

The aging leader was just getting started.

“When enemies rise up, we commit vast resources to the fabrication of gods of stone and steel — ships, planes, missiles, fortifications — and depend on them for protection and deliverance. When threatened, we become antienemy instead of pro-kingdom of God; we train a man in the art of war and call him a patriot, thus, in the manner of Satan’s counterfeit of true patriotism, perverting the Savior’s teaching: ‘Love your enemies.’”

No, this unflinching anti-war rhetoric wasn’t unleashed by Dallin H. Oaks, the current president of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, as the U.S. and Israel launched their war with Iran. Nor did it come from his predecessors Russell M. Nelson, Thomas S. Monson or Gordon B. Hinckley amid armed conflicts that erupted during their presidencies.

It was a 1976 First Presidency message from the Yoda-like leader Spencer W. Kimball titled “The False Gods We Worship,” published in the church’s magazine after the Vietnam War and as America prepared for its bicentennial celebration.

In the five decades since Kimball’s broadside, top Latter-day Saint leaders have rarely addressed the topic of war with such directness and eloquence.

Today, as a number of nations face headline-grabbing assaults from their neighbors or within their own borders, and after U.S. President Donald Trump threatened Iran with annihilation, prominent religious leaders — most notably Pope Leo XIV — have spoken out against these wars.

(Andrew Medichini | AP) Pope Leo XIV, during his recent journey to Africa, has drawn the wrath of President Donald Trump for his opposition to the U.S.-Israeli war with Iran.

“God does not bless any conflict,” the American-born Leo wrote on social media on April 10. “Anyone who is a disciple of Christ, the Prince of Peace, is never on the side of those who once wielded the sword and today drop bombs. Military action will not create space for freedom or times of peace, which comes only from the patient promotion of coexistence and dialogue among peoples.”

Amid this clash between pontiff and president, Latter-day Saint apostle Dieter F. Uchtdorf, during a recent media tour of the church’s new Temple Square Visitors’ Center, offered a simple and abbreviated response to a Salt Lake Tribune question about the Catholic leader: “We love the pope.”

In February, the church issued a statement about the missile strikes on Iran, saying it was “monitoring the evolving situation,” and expressed “profound concern and heartfelt compassion for all those living in harm’s way,” which included thousands of members in the region.

Then, on Easter, in his first General Conference as church president, Oaks addressed the importance of peace building, but it was mostly focused on interpersonal relations and culture wars.

Some members yearn for stronger condemnation of the wars, asking why a church president, revered as a “prophet, seer and revelator” for modern times is so cautious?

Others see wisdom in restraint.

‘Negative peace’

“No one can ever estimate the terrible suffering incident to these wars across the globe. Lives numbered in the millions have been lost. The terrible wounds of war have left bodies maimed and minds destroyed. Families have been left without fathers and mothers. Young people who have been recruited to fight have, in many instances, died while those yet alive have had woven into the very fabric of their natures elements of hatred which will never leave them. The treasure of nations has been wasted and will never be recovered. The devastation of war seems so unnecessary and such a terrible waste of human life and national resources. We ask, will this terrible, destructive way of handling disagreements among the sons and daughters of God ever end?”

— Gordon B. Hinckley, in a 2007 First Presidency message.

Studying conflict management and resolution at the Kroc School of Peace Studies, within the Catholic-led University of San Diego, Utahn Holly Burton is impressed with that faith’s tradition of opposing injustice, mistreatment of the poor and neglect of the Earth.

“Catholics,” Burton says, “speak up.”

The Latter-day Saint graduate student has appreciated the pope’s statements, urging “those who have weapons” to “lay them down.”

(Jack Burton) Latter-day Saint Holly Burton, a graduate student at the Kroc School of Peace Studies at the University of San Diego, supports Pope Leo's call for combatants in the Iran war to lay down their arms.

Leo is not just speaking to Catholics, she says, but to all people of goodwill.

She was glad to hear Oaks’ conference sermon on peace, as well as Nelson’s repeated calls for members to be “peacemakers,” Burton says. “It’s so needed.”

She wanted them both to go further, though, to describe what that looks like.

“We are really good at ‘niceness,’” she says. “Our leaders in the 1950s and ’60s developed a distaste for getting involved in any politics, settling into a position of neutrality.”

Extreme neutrality “makes us lukewarm,” Burton says. “To stay neutral is to maintain the status quo — and it is definitely not what Jesus would say.”

In peace studies, “negative peace” is the absence of conflict and violence, she explains, while positive peace is the “presence of justice.”

So many Latter-day Saints look to their leaders for moral authority, Burton says. “Those who are silent allow horrific things to happen. If we say nothing, we are part of it.”

The work of building peace is “messy,” she acknowledges. “It requires time, effort and imagination to transform conflict into something both productive and, ultimately, beautiful.”

(The Salt Lake Tribune) The First Presidency of N. Eldon Tanner, left, Spencer W. Kimball and Marion G. Romney spoke out forcefully against the MX missile.

(J. Willard Marriott Library, University of Utah) MX missile protesters at Utah's Capitol.

Kimball and his counselors in the First Presidency similarly decried weapons of war 45 years ago when it opposed U.S. plans to base MX nuclear missiles in Utah’s West Desert.

“We repeat our warnings against the terrifying arms race in which the nations of the Earth are presently engaged,” they wrote in 1981. “We deplore in particular the building of vast arsenals of nuclear weaponry.”

Latter-day Saint leaders feared the MX — labeled a Peacekeeper and one of the most lethal nuclear weapons in history — would become a peace breaker, noting that “men have seldom created armaments that eventually were not put to use.”

The faith’s forceful opposition helped turn the tide of public opinion in Utah against the Cold War-era proposal, and the U.S. eventually abandoned the MX.

Risky business

(Tyler Hicks | The New York Times) Damage from Russian shelling in Siversk, in eastern Ukraine, in October 2024.

“I have been to Ukraine and Russia many times. I love those lands, the people and their languages. I weep and pray for all who are affected by this conflict. As a church, we’re doing all we can to help those who are suffering and struggling to survive. We invite everyone to continue to fast and pray for all the people being hurt by this calamity. Any war is a horrifying violation of everything the Lord Jesus Christ stands for and teaches.”

— Russell M. Nelson, in a 2022 General Conference.

(The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) President Russell M. Nelson speaks at General Conference in April 2022.

The Utah-based faith did not condemn Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 but rather pleaded for a speedy peace without naming either warring nation.

One reason for the guarded comments may have been that thousands of Latter-day Saints can be found in Russia and Ukraine. The February 2022 news release even noted that the church “has members in each of the affected areas.”

Nelson’s “emotional call for peace,” says Latter-day Saint diplomat John Dinkelman, “really tugged at my heart.”

The church leader “reaffirmed his strong love for both Russians and Ukrainians — whom he had visited often over his long ministry,” says Dinkelman, a veteran envoy with the U.S. State Department. “As a father, I suspect the emotion he felt was more akin to watching one’s own children/family fight with one another — pleading for them to behave and make peace.”

The diplomat, who has lived and worked all over the world, applauds his church leaders for making “general statements against war — of course.”

But specific statements about “a singular war,” Dinkelman cautions, could “adversely” affect some members’ lives and faith, and result in “ramifications coming back to them as retribution.”

Church leadership must consider “the well-being of its members,” he says, “in nations with governments that are less averse to using tools of power against their adversaries (like vulnerable small Latter-day Saint congregations).”

Such retribution could happen even in the United States, observers say, such as blocking missionary visas or yanking the church’s nonprofit status.

Case in point: the Trump administration’s cancellation of a grant to Miami’s Catholic Charities after the president’s heated exchange with the pope.

Individual vs. institutional

(Sgt. Joseph Chenelly | U.S. Marines) Marines walk to a security position after seizing a Taliban base in 2001 in southern Afghanistan.

“Now we are at war. Great forces have been mobilized and will continue to be. Political alliances are being forged. We do not know how long this conflict will last. We do not know what it will cost in lives and treasure. We do not know the manner in which it will be carried out. … We are people of peace. We are followers of Christ, who was and is the Prince of Peace. But there are times when we must stand up for right and decency, for freedom and civilization.… Now, brothers and sisters, we must do our duty, whatever that duty might be. Peace may be denied for a season. Some of our liberties may be curtailed. We may be inconvenienced. We may even be called on to suffer in one way or another. But God our Eternal Father will watch over this nation and all of the civilized world who look to him.”

— Gordon B. Hinckley, in a 2001 General Conference.

(The Salt Lake Tribune) President Gordon B. Hinckley announces the U.S military action in Afghanistan at General Conference in October 2001.

On the Sunday morning session of the church’s October 2001 General Conference, Hinckley stood at the pulpit and dramatically announced he had just gotten a note that “U.S. missile attack is underway” in retaliation for the 9/11 terrorist attacks — without naming Afghanistan.

His audience could hear him weigh the morality of war — when it might be appropriate, even necessary, says religious studies professor Chad Ford, or when it betrays God’s commands to love their enemies.

(Chris Samuels | The Salt Lake Tribune) Chad Ford, an associate professor of religious studies at Utah State University, says individuals need not wait for faith leaders before taking stands on issues of war and peace.

Ford, who teaches classes on violence and peace at Utah State University, admires the pope’s outspokenness and courage, he says, and the Catholic leader’s efforts to reclaim Jesus from those who would use the Christian Savior to defend violence.

All institutions, including religious groups, have to assess their place in the world, the professor says, while individuals can choose for themselves “what it means to them to be disciples.”

They shouldn’t wait for leaders, he says, to tell them what to do.

Preserving the church’s “religious freedom to do the things it needs to do could be at the top of President Oaks’ mind right now,” Ford says. “But that doesn’t release us from wrestling with the issue and making moral decisions ourselves.”

Any close observer of the global faith in the past few years, he says, would have to recognize that its leaders have repeatedly urged members toward “the personal practice of peace.”

That, Ford says, is the “most impactful thing we can do.”

Hinckley returned to the topic later in his closing remarks at that 2001 conference.

“When I went home for lunch, I turned on the television, looked at the news for a moment, and paraphrased in my mind the words of the Psalms: ‘Why do the nations so furiously rage together?’ I’ve lived through all of the wars of the 20th century. My eldest brother lies buried in the soil of France, a victim of the First World War. I have lived through the Second World War, the Korean War, the Vietnam War, the Gulf War, and lesser conflicts. We have been a very quarrelsome and difficult people in our conflicts one with another. We so need to turn to the Lord and look to him.”

•••••••

(Virginia Mayo | AP) A D-Day veteran salutes the grave of a fallen comrade at the American cemetery in Normandy, France.

“As those chosen and ordained to stand at the head of the Savior’s church, as followers of the lowly Jesus trying to live his gospel and to obey his commandments, we must call upon the leaders of nations to abandon the fiendishly inspired slaughter of the manhood of the world now carrying on and further planned….We renew our declaration that international disputes can and should be settled by peaceful means. This is the way of the Lord. We call upon the statesmen of the world to assume their rightful control of the affairs of nations and to bring this war to an end, honorable and just to all. Animated and led by the spirit of Christ, they can do it."

— J. Reuben Clark, reading a 1942 First Presidency message.

(Utah Historical Society) President Heber J. Grant, center, walks with the other members of the First Presidency, J. Reuben Clark, left, and David O. McKay.

Note to readers • This story is available to Salt Lake Tribune subscribers only. Thank you for supporting local journalism.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.