Your recent editorial and op-ed about kids’ reading are timely and important, but you’ve missed a few key points.
Several weeks ago, George Pyle opened by saying that a huge percentage of Utah kids are below grade level in reading by the beginning of 3rd grade. That’s true.
His tongue-in-cheek remedy is to ban lots more books and reading, so that kids, with their natural desire to “cut the apron strings,” will, with reverse psychology, start reading more.
Book bans and low reading scores don’t have anything to do with each other. Pyle’s op-ed seemed to come from the idea that the reason kids’ reading scores are low is that they’re discouraged from reading.
It’s actually the total opposite. If kids can’t read well, they won’t be able to read the banned books well, even if they want to.
The nation is still trying to pull itself out of the “Reading Wars” of the past 75 years. Scientific neurological research, popularly called “The Science of Reading,” has proven that kids need several things in order to become good readers:
1. Being read to every day, starting at birth, and adult reading being modeled.
2. Being exposed to lots of vocabulary.
3. Developing “phonemic awareness” during toddler and preschool years.
4. Comprehension of what’s being read to them.
5. Direct, explicit, sequential teaching of phonics, starting before kindergarten, or at beginning of kindergarten at the latest.
The Aug. 2 editorial got No. 1 right; in fact, that No. 1 concept is the most important of all.
But it missed the other four imperative steps. Utah public schools are trying to do a better job of incorporating these skills, but it’s very difficult if they haven’t been done for many years before a child even enters school. Parents need to make sure, from toddlerhood, that their kids are getting steps 2-5.
Any public school reading coach or the internet can help parents know what to do for those.
Julie N. McDonald, Murray
