Utah does not have to choose between embracing AI in schools and protecting students.
Framing this as innovation versus safety creates a false divide. AI is not the boogeyman we sometimes make it out to be. The real responsibility before us is to build clear guardrails that help students learn to navigate AI wisely, not fear it.
As a former English teacher and now a digital learning specialist, I approach AI the way I approach literacy. Students need to learn how to read the world around them. AI is now part of that world.
In classrooms across the Jordan School District, AI is not a shortcut machine. It is a thinking partner, used with intention.
In history classes, students might enter an AI simulation with a historical figure. They question the responses, compare them to primary sources and look for bias or oversimplification. The conversation does not end on the screen. It continues with classmates and teachers. The goal is not to let AI deliver answers. The goal is to sharpen students’ ability to analyze evidence and perspective. That is not passive screen time. That is active historical thinking.
In English, teachers are rethinking what strong writing instruction looks like in the age of AI. Students can generate counterarguments, then evaluate which ideas are weak, which are compelling and how to strengthen their own reasoning. The thinking remains human. The tool simply gives them the opportunity to dive deeper.
I tell teachers and students that not all screen time is created equal. Doom scrolling and deliberate learning are not the same. What matters is what students are doing on those screens and whether it advances a clear learning goal.
That is why we use a simple stoplight framework. Green light means go. AI can help brainstorm ideas, model examples or provide feedback. Yellow light means proceed carefully. Students might use it to revise, but they must explain their thinking and show their process. Red light means stop. We do not enter student data into AI tools, and we do not outsource final assessment or essential thinking to a machine.
The framework is simple enough for a second grader to understand and practical enough for a high school classroom. More importantly, it keeps human judgment at the center. We also draw on the HUMAN Framework developed with the Utah Education Network, which prompts teachers and students to hone the learning goal, understand AI’s limitations, mitigate risk, apply a critical eye and nurture human connection beyond the screen. Together, these guardrails ensure the technology supports learning rather than replaces it.
Safety cannot rest on restriction alone. Students will encounter AI outside of school, often without adult guidance. If we ban it during the day but never teach students how to question its outputs, protect their privacy or recognize bias, we leave them less prepared. Real protection comes from preparation.
Utah has always cared deeply about family, local control and strong academic standards. AI should strengthen those commitments, not undermine them. With clear guardrails and human judgment at the center, we can protect students while preparing them for the world they’re entering.
Our state has already shown it can lead responsibly in AI and education. The next step is ensuring that leadership remains grounded in clear guardrails, privacy protections and professional judgment.
(Kiera Beddes) Kiera Beddes is a Digital Teaching and Learning Specialist at Jordan School District.
Kiera Beddes is a Digital Teaching and Learning Specialist at Jordan School District and President of the Utah Coalition for Educational Technology. She previously taught high school English and history for 13 years.
The Salt Lake Tribune is committed to creating a space where Utahns can share ideas, perspectives and solutions that move our state forward. We rely on your insight to do this. Find out how to share your opinion here, and email us at voices@sltrib.com.
