Utah has invested millions to try and improve reading scores for kids in kindergarten through third grade, but that money hasn’t seemed to move the needle much, a new state audit found.
The efforts aren’t a total failure, auditors told lawmakers during a June 16 meeting. Overall, though, outcomes were “mixed.”
The 126-page report comes months after legislators asked auditors to evaluate the effectiveness of Utah’s K-3 early literacy programs.
The bulk of those programs were funded in 2022 under SB127, which was called “early literacy outcomes improvement.” At the time, lawmakers allocated about $18.5 million (a mix of one-time and ongoing funding) to stretch across 20 projects.
The law also required all schools and school districts to adopt “science of reading” curriculum — evidence-based methods for teaching children how to read — along with intervention programs. It also set a statewide goal of 70% third graders reading at grade level by 2027.
The good news: The state has already hit that goal, according to the report.
The bad news? That goalpost has since been moved under a new literacy law that takes effect July 1.
Under the new law, SB241, the state hopes to have 80% of third graders reading on grade-level by 2030. However, there hasn’t been any “sustained” improvement in K-3 reading scores over most of the last decade, according to the report.
Right now, about 70.5% of third graders are reading on grade level, according to a report released Monday from the University of Utah’s Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute. The study aligned with auditors’ findings, noting that there’s been “little sustained improvement over time.”
“The core issue for us that this audit pointed out was that we could not determine whether our investments were improving student outcomes,” State Superintendent Molly Hart said June 16, in response to the report.
“Our job is to ensure that expectations are clear, performance is visible and outcomes are consistently monitored across the state,” she continued. “So, that’s our focus.”
First grade failings can quickly cause students to fall behind
Along with the new third grade literacy goal, SB241 also introduced third grade retention, which involves holding students who struggle to read back a year.
That won’t happen until 2030, but if third grade reading rates continue to remain static, according to the report, 30% of Utah third graders could face being held back.
First grade is where schools especially struggle to improve reading scores, auditors found, which can cause students to fall behind in later grades.
“We believe the gap in performance on first grade reading tests contributes to the state’s lack of movement in third grade, due to more students entering second grade needing interventions,” the audit states.
State education experts have long acknowledged that interventions need to occur before third grade — the new law even requires them — but growth remains stagnant, according to the report.
“This gap suggests early literacy instruction may not be adequately supporting the development of foundational reading skills,” the audit states.
Training meant to help teachers is self-driven, with little oversight
Before Utah invested $18 million in 2022 to train more teachers in the “science of reading,” the state set aside $11.9 million of its federal COVID-19 relief funding — an amount that topped $1 billion — to implement Language Essentials for Teachers of Reading and Spelling (LETRS) training.
It was enough to cover approximately 8,000 educators, which in turn impacted 155,000 students, according to Utah State Board of Education documents.
Those funds expired in September 2023, but bridge funding the state allocated in 2022 helped continue some LETRS training. Since then, over 10,000 educators have enrolled, according to the audit.
However, auditors found no link between LETRS training and increased reading scores. That’s in part because USBE lacks sufficient “data infrastructure” to make that determination, the audit found
Auditors also cited poor training oversight as another potential factor, since LETRS is video-based and largely self-driven, according to the report. Educators are required to complete the material, but tests and assessments are “open book,” and at least one online resource offers answers to all the test questions, auditors noted.
The training also has no “passing score,” which means becoming LETRS certified simply indicates an educator completed the training.
Auditors called for more oversight.
“The lack of oversight on LETRS tests may have allowed some individuals to complete the training without improving their understanding of reading instruction,“ the report states.
Literacy coaches introduced — and removed
Part of the 2022 law involved funding new literacy coaches at 48 underperforming schools. But again, auditors identified mixed results.
Just four schools removed their coaches because reading scores had improved. Thirteen removed their coaches for other reasons, including school closures, though not every school specified why.
Auditors noted a 13 percentage-point difference between schools that kept their coaches on until they saw significant improvement vs. those that removed their coaches for any other reason.
Still, literacy outcomes across schools with literacy coaches were, overall, “uneven,” according to the audit.
Some bright spots
The report highlights a few areas that are helping to improve reading scores, particularly administrator involvement.
Auditors found that when principals and school leaders participate in “literacy-based professional development,” their schools see measurable improvement.
For instance, during the 2025 school year, schools where administrators underwent professional development saw a higher percentage of students reading at grade level than schools with principals who did not.

Carmen Nesbitt