When author and educator Sharon McMahon was initially named this year’s Utah Valley University commencement speaker, there was no official vote or debate where members of the public could weigh in.
Instead, a campus committee quietly selected her, and shortly after her name was announced, outcry erupted from the political right. That led to threats, McMahon said, which the university said led to safety concerns. Her speech was ultimately canceled.
Utah’s Board of Higher Education hopes to prevent that kind of controversy in the future.
Moving forward, they will now require Utah’s eight public colleges and universities to make the commencement-speaker approval process more formal and open.
The idea is that any concerns could be raised earlier — so a speaker isn’t shouted down or forced to pull out.
Last week, the board approved the new policy, which will require a school’s board of trustees to publicly review a proposed commencement speaker in an open meeting.
Before a formal vote, there will be opportunity for public comment. That’s meant to offer more accountability and transparency.
“The policy direction we went to was informed by the experience we had at UVU,” said Geoff Landward, Utah’s commissioner over higher education. “We certainly took that into consideration, among other factors.”
(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah System of Higher Education Commissioner Geoff Landward speaks about higher education and the Legislature at the University of Utah in Salt Lake City on Thursday, Jan. 16, 2025.
Landward said the board had started looking at the policy before McMahon’s canceled speech, but the changes were updated and accelerated in response to it.
McMahon, who is often referred to as “America’s Government Teacher,” is known for her online videos explaining current political events. UVU had announced in late March that she would be its 2026 commencement keynote speaker and would receive an honorary doctorate.
That announcement was quickly met with pushback from conservative student groups and politicians, who said it was insensitive to have her speak at UVU because of comments McMahon posted on social media shortly after conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was shot and killed on the school’s campus on Sept. 10.
The post that attracted the most criticism was from Sept. 12; McMahon posted several partial quotes from Kirk, including comments he made about Black people and Muslims.
She wrote, “Millions of people feel they were harmed, and the murder that was horrific and should never have happened does not magically erase what was said or done. … But if you were a Charlie Kirk fan, you might not realize why there is so much backlash to posts eulogizing his death.”
Several politicians expressed frustration and disappointment online over McMahon’s planned speech, which McMahon later called a “coercive pressure campaign.”
Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, was the most vocal among them. He posted seven times on his X account @BasedMikeLee, urging the school to choose a new speaker. Utah House Speaker Mike Schultz and Utah Senate President Stuart Adams also joined in.
In the fallout since the cancellation of her April 29 address, McMahon has defended her selection and her comments on Kirk.
(Bethany Baker | The Salt Lake Tribune) Students navigate Utah Valley University's Orem campus on Wednesday, Dec. 11, 2024.
Landward said the situation was unfortunate, and he wants to avoid that in the future.
University trustees already vote on who to award honorary degrees to each year. Now, that process will need to include the commencement speaker. Some schools were already doing that; others were not, he said.
The updated rule now reads, “Commencement ceremonies are intended to be celebratory and focused on honoring student achievement.” Speakers, it adds, should inspire graduates and offer wisdom.
It also states: “The institution may not proceed with a commencement speaker absent trustee approval.”
State policy was also updated, generally, around other guest speakers on campus. That came in response to SB295, passed during this year’s legislative session.
That measure aimed to ensure that guest speakers are not censored on campus based on the state’s restrictions on diversity, equity and inclusion. Guest speakers, according to the bill’s sponsor Sen. John Johnson, R-North Ogden, should still be free to talk about what they want. And schools should be encouraged to represent diverse viewpoints on campus.
Accordingly, the updated policy also adds: “Institutions shall avoid rescinding invitations to speakers or canceling events solely on the basis that groups oppose the viewpoints being expressed.”

Courtney Tanner