At the end of the week, Utah Valley University’s president will step down after nearly eight years on the job — and the state will continue to pay her for nearly a year into her retirement.
As part of her separation agreement, Astrid Tuminez is set to receive $304,789.50 in severance pay. That amounts to roughly 76% of her annual presidential salary, according to the eight-page agreement, obtained by The Salt Lake Tribune through a public records request.
Tuminez’s payout in particular is slightly unusual — and it’s prompting the Utah Board of Higher Education to reconsider its policy.
The board has a longstanding practice of paying out university presidents who plan to step down and resume a faculty role. It’s framed as “reorientation pay,” said Utah’s higher education commissioner, Geoff Landward
Traditionally, many presidents start as professors and work their way up, then return to teaching or another role after leading. The reorientation pay, Landward said, was designed to give a them about a year to catch up on new developments in their field and update their research before teaching students again.
But Tuminez was never part of the faculty at UVU — or any school — before she became president. She was a surprising and somewhat unconventional choice, coming instead from the private sector as Microsoft’s regional director for corporate, external and legal affairs over Southeast Asia.
“I had not gone through the ranks of academia,” she previously told The Tribune in 2024.
And she’s not expected to take up a faculty position now, either. Tuminez has not announced her next steps, but there is no contract for her to teach at UVU.
So why, then, is she technically getting reorientation pay?
Landward said the policy — launched in 1976 — uses the term “reorientation” but doesn’t actually spell out the faculty intent.
Instead, it vaguely says the board will provide “up to a year’s leave for reorientation to the appropriate discipline or field of service” if a president serves for at least three years and steps down in good standing.
A 2024 update specifically noted a president couldn’t get the pay if they stepped down while under investigation for misconduct, which happened when Richard “Biff” Williams left Utah Tech University in January 2024.
But nothing in the policy prevented Tuminez from receiving severance pay.
“We were just trying to be as fair as possible with her,” Landward said.
Tuminez’s agreement details that she will receive two payments of $152,394.75 each. The first will come on May 31. The second will be paid out on Jan. 31, 2027.
Tuminez, through a spokesperson for UVU, declined to comment. Her last year on the job has been particularly rocky, including the shooting death of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk on campus last fall.
Her tenure, which started in September 2018, ends with her address at UVU’s Thursday commencement ceremony, which has also been plagued by controversy.
There are no contingencies in the agreement should Tuminez take another job in that time, which has been a provision in other recent agreements for departing presidents.
“It’s been different for each president,” Landward noted.
A typical example of how the policy was assumed to work came when Noelle Cockett stepped down as president of Utah State University in July 2022.
Cockett had come to USU as a researcher and assistant professor in veterinary science, and she returned to a faculty position upon leaving her leadership role. She received a year of her presidential salary — which was then $452,016 before benefits — to reorient to teaching.
As a professor, she now makes a salary of $170,749.99, according to Utah’s latest public salary data, not counting additional benefits and allowances.
Landward said the gap in language in the policy that Tuminez’s situation revealed will now be part of an overhaul in how presidents are paid, including when they leave an institution.
Moving forward, Landward said, the Utah Board of Higher Education wants new presidents to sign a limited contract — set up more like the CEO of a company.
They could also be held in breach of that contract for not meeting certain performance requirements, he said.
(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah System of Higher Education Commissioner Geoff Landward speaks during a Utah Board of Higher Education meeting in Salt Lake City on Friday, March 28, 2025.
Landward said he doesn’t think severance pay will go away entirely — calling it an important part of recruiting in a challenging landscape with a lot of turnover.
“It’s getting harder and harder because no one wants these jobs,” he said.
But, he added, with state tax dollars paying presidential salaries, there should be more accountability and transparency.
Note to readers • This story is available to Salt Lake Tribune subscribers only. Thank you for supporting local journalism.
Courtney Tanner