The University of Utah is suing former tight ends coach Freddie Whittingham for breach of contract after he left Utah to join his brother, former Utah head coach Kyle Whittingham, at Michigan in January.
A Utah spokesperson declined to comment on the lawsuit, saying it was “pending litigation.” Michigan did not immediately reply to a request for comment from The Salt Lake Tribune.
In a lawsuit filed Aug. 3 in Utah’s 3rd District Court, Utah alleges Freddie Whittingham “abandoned” his position on or around Jan. 1, 2026. Freddie Whittingham was under contract through Jan. 31, 2027, with an annual base salary of $525,000.
Freddie Whittingham had been with the Utah football program since 2012 in various capacities.
According to the suit, Utah is seeking more than $300,000 for breach of contract and at least $1 million in general and special damages on the fiduciary-duty claim, plus punitive damages.
Utah’s lawsuit alleges:
- Freddie Whittingham failed to devote “full-time attention and energy” to being a coach for the Utah football program.
- He never received written consent from Utah before engaging with the Wolverines about an assistant coaching position in Ann Arbor in January, as required by his contract.
- Freddie Whittingham didn’t provide the Utes with written notice of his resignation before accepting his new position with the Wolverines.
- He did not pay the “liquidated damages” required by his contract after leaving for Michigan.
(Rick Egan | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah Tight Ends/Recruiting Coordinator Freddie Whittingham, on the field before Big-12 Football action between the Utah Utes and the Kansas State Wildcats at Rice-Eccles Stadium, on Saturday, Nov. 22, 2025.
Allegedly abandoned his job duties
According to the suit, Utah associate athletic director Jeff Rudy called Freddie Whittingham on Jan. 1 and informed him that he remained employed by Utah. That same day, media reports surfaced that Freddie Whittingham was part of a group of assistant coaches who were leaving Utah for Michigan.
That night, the suit says, Rudy found Freddie Whittingham and his family members cleaning out his office in the Spence and Cleone Eccles Football Facility. Rudy checked back an hour later and found the office “empty,” according to the suit.
The next day, the lawsuit says, Freddie Whittingham was seen with his brother Kyle Whittingham — along with other former Utah staff members — at a Michigan basketball game on Jan. 2, in which the now-Wolverines head coach addressed the crowd, saying, “First order of business was to assemble a great assistant coaching staff. They’re here.”
On Jan. 3, an unnamed Utah athletics employee received an email from Michigan associate athletic director Jerry Wood asking the program to transfer Freddie Whittingham’s phone line to Michigan’s account, according to the lawsuit.
Later that day, Rudy received a text from Freddie Whittingham, saying that the former tight ends coach believed Michigan athletic director Warde Manuel would be reaching out to discuss a buyout, the suit says.
(Chris Samuels | The Salt Lake Tribune) Utah football tight ends coach Freddie Whittingham speaks to media on the first day of fall camp in Salt Lake City, Monday, July 31, 2023.
Recruited former Utah players
In another claim, Utah alleges that Freddie Whittingham was actively recruiting Utah players to join Michigan while still employed by Utah.
Five Utah players who entered the NCAA transfer portal ultimately committed to Michigan, including tight end JJ Buchanan.
Buchanan was a major contributor for Utah in 2025, finishing the season with 26 catches for 426 yards and five touchdowns.
“On information and belief, [Freddie] Whittingham actively recruited Utah players and recruits to Michigan,” the lawsuit says.
Liquidated damages dispute
According to Freddie Whittingham’s contract, he was required to pay Utah liquidated damages equaling 75% of his annual salary for each full year remaining on the contract, plus a prorated amount for each partial year remaining, if he voluntarily terminated the agreement without cause to take another college or professional coaching position.
He still had over a year left on his contract.
On Jan. 16, Utah’s athletic department claims it sent Freddie Whittingham an email requesting “payment and written confirmation of payment terms” by Jan. 31, according to the lawsuit.
Freddie Whittingham, the lawsuit says, replied to the email five days later on Jan. 21, disputing that he had to pay damages.
In the lawsuit, Utah claims six coaches who left for Michigan had a liquidated damages provision in their contracts — and that Freddie Whittingham is the only one who hasn’t complied.

Jason Batacao