With American civil discord accelerating at alarming levels, public servants like Utah’s Gov. Cox are beseeching folks to learn to “disagree better.” Although Cox’s admonitions imply that our country will start functioning better once we start treating each other better, his heartfelt words just won’t cut it unless the laws that enable our division are abolished.
Ever since the end of the Civil War, effective management of disagreement has prevented America from descending into chaos. Indeed, human civilization provides myriad examples of governments that failed to manage civil discourse and paid the price. In this vein, winner-take-all elections — the Electoral College — lifetime tenure for Supreme Court judges and no term limits for Congress, are but a few pre- and post-Civil War anachronisms that are returning America to Civil War-levels of hostility.
Curiously, archaic laws and partisan practices like these have been both cause and effect of our current division. Simply put, it’s America’s “to the victor go all the spoils mentality” that creates multitudes of exceedingly ticked off people after every election.
More ominously, according to Princeton professor Timothy Snyder, democracies that fail to manage disagreement often succumb to authoritarian rule and the “incompetence and corruption” that inevitably follows. But academics like Snyder also agree that even though America’s polarized environment makes cooperation exceedingly difficult, it is no time to throw in the towel.
Unfortunately absent any legislative substance, Gov. Cox‘s admonitions amount to nothing more than those same old “thoughts and prayers” we often hear in times of crises.
Indeed, history teaches us that catastrophe awaits should those charged with governing fail to heed the warning signs of a government that’s sliding towards autocracy rather than bending towards justice.
Thomas Smith, Hurricane
