An advantage of a dictatorship: It’s much more efficient than a democratic republic in cutting through regulatory bureaucracy so that urgently needed public projects can get done quickly. The Stratos data center project in Box Elder County, for example, was, I thought, more dropped like a bomb on us than like a proposal. It was a done deal right out of the chute on the day that the Box Elder County Commission held a “public hearing” for the proposed project. They announced their democratically arrived at answer: Yes, we the people of Box Elder County approve of this project.
Problem is, a sizable number of people of Box Elder County have shown that they do not approve of this project. They might accept it if it were explained in full detail to them so that we understand what the project costs, who benefits and how, who pays for what and if it all makes sense.
Now, all of a sudden, public opinion is considered a public nuisance. Environmental concerns are deemed heretical. Oversight is likened to terrorism originating out of China. The spontaneous invention of the Military Installation Development Authority is already in place to justify zero accountability for the project.
A disadvantage of a dictatorship: Sometimes, brilliant projects that are so urgent that they just cannot wait for oversight, actually urgently need some oversight. Exhibit A: The Stratos project.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m all for more intelligence in the world. The second we get Stratos up and running, I want to ask it, “Hey Stratos, how intelligent is it for humans dwelling on planet Earth to emit vastly more atmospheric carbon for AI projects?” And: “How intelligent is it to hasten the drying up of the Great Salt Lake, already well on its way to becoming a toxic dust bowl?”
Charles Ashurst, Logan
