The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in April filed a lawsuit against John Dehlin’s “Mormon Stories” podcast for use of the term Mormon. It raises a surprisingly simple question: What, exactly, qualifies as a “Mormon” story? Can a term of its nature be justly owned?
The undersigned guests below, who have appeared on the “Mormon Stories” podcast, did not share “anti-Mormon” narratives. We shared accounts of lived experience within Mormonism, both good and bad — the kinds of experiences that, for decades, defined, or still define, our identities.
Being sealed in the temple is a Mormon story, as is whatever happened to the people entering into it after.
Teaching primary is a Mormon story.
Serving in bishoprics, stake presidencies, high councils, Relief Societies, and Elders Quorums — these are Mormon stories.
Serving missions, raising families in the faith, shaping one’s moral framework through LDS doctrine — these are Mormon stories.
A story does not cease to be a Mormon one simply because its narrator’s beliefs evolve.
Mormon Stories functions, at its core, as an archive of Mormon lived experiences — good and bad. It documents the cultural, theological, emotional, and institutional realities of life inside this tradition and to our people. To retroactively classify these narratives as something else — “ex-Mormon,” “anti-Mormon,” or worse — is to engage in a kind of definitional and dismissive revisionism.
One need not agree with every perspective shared on the podcast to recognize the stories originate within Mormonism because the lives originate within Mormonism.
Institutions and intellectual property law do not own personal history. They do not control memory. And they certainly do not possess the authority to declare which life experiences count as legitimate expressions of a shared religious culture.
Whatever one thinks of “Mormon Stories,” the individuals who appear there are telling Mormon stories — by definition.
And those stories deserve space to exist free from the threat of strategically targeted litigation.
Kolby and Cami Reddish, Nampa, Idaho
Stuart and Martine Smith, Salt Lake City
