facebook-pixel

Andy Larsen: Utah’s vaccine foolishness has spread and looks impossible to fix

The state has become the country’s measles epicenter as vaccine skepticism grows.

(Mary Conlon | AP) A nurse prepares a combination measles, mumps and rubella vaccine earlier this year. Utah has become the "new center" of U.S. measles cases.

(Mary Conlon | AP) A nurse prepares a combination measles, mumps and rubella vaccine earlier this year. Utah has become the "new center" of U.S. measles cases.

We don’t like seeing Utah in the headlines like this.

“Utah Becomes the New Center of U.S. Measles Cases” read the New York Times headline. NPR went with: “A measles outbreak that began in rural Utah continues to spread.” And the American Hospital Association just reported that the “Utah measles outbreak reaches more than 600 cases.”

What can we do to stop this?

First of all, the culprit is clear: Utah’s increased vaccine reluctance is allowing a once-eliminated disease to spread.

Here’s the current number of measles cases per 100,000 residents in Utah’s various health districts, as reported by the Utah Measles Dashboard run by the Utah Department of Health and Human Services.

Cases are at their highest in the TriCounty Health Department area (Daggett, Duchesne, and Uintah counties). Southwest Utah (Beaver, Garfield, Iron, Kane, and Washington counties) isn’t far behind. Central Utah’s health district comes in third.

Meanwhile, Salt Lake County has Utah’s third-lowest incidence rate at 5.1 confirmed cases per 100,000 residents. The case count only surpassed 60 last week.

How does that compare to the vaccination rate? Here’s the percentage of kindergarteners who were missing proof of measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccination as of the 2025-26 school year in each health district.

The same three health districts have the most unvaccinated 5-year-olds. This time, it’s southwest Utah, where a whopping 26% of students have not gotten the MMR shot, leading the pack. The Central Utah and TriCounty health districts are relatively close behind.

I’ll make the comparisons even easier. Here’s a slider you can use to compare and contrast the two images above. (I like interactive graphics.)

Simply put, 90% of the people with confirmed measles cases in Utah were not vaccinated.

Parents holding their kids out of acquiring vaccinations has become more common in recent years. The biggest jump came this last year.

Can we get back to herd immunity and eradication?

If you are one of the majority of Utahns who are in favor of vaccinations, you probably look upon all of this with an attitude between annoyance and anger. Even though the vaccinations clearly work, there have been roughly 60 breakthrough cases in Utah in the last two years. Compare that to the total number of measles cases from the previous four-year period: one.

All of a sudden, something in your life that was not a risk is now a risk, and it’s not your fault.

Remember R0 from the COVID-19 pandemic? That’s the term scientists use to describe the contagiousness of a given disease. It represents the number of people that a disease spreads to from the average carrier, given an unvaccinated population. For early COVID, the R0 was estimated to be somewhere between 2 and 3.

But measles is drastically more contagious than COVID: Its R0 is estimated to be between 12 and 18. That means that we need 90% to 95% of the population to be immune to the disease to achieve herd immunity and eradication — where we were previously.

Is this achievable?

In our current climate, I am pessimistic.

The academic community, with its infinite patience, has been studying how to increase vaccine uptake. There are numerous studies showing ways to increase vaccine uptake by increasing availability, working with local governments, and so on.

But the issues in Utah aren’t about availability. Instead, parents are actively choosing not to vaccinate their kids. What’s the solution to that? Education comes to mind as an obvious step — but what are the best ways to go about doing that? Public service announcements on TV stations? Billboards? Classes?

One popular idea is “motivational interviewing.” Trained motivational interviewers know how to listen to their subjects talk about something that might be best to change — whether that be addiction, a mental health behavior, dental hygiene, or vaccine reluctance. They learn why that behavior happens, and how to gently suggest changes that fit with the subject’s motivations. There are a variety of studies that show motivational interviewing as an effective tool in changing minds in other fields.

So we tried it here in Utah. In 2023, Utah State University launched the TriCounty Vaccine Improvement Program.

The program used flyers, social media campaigns, and in-person health fairs. Most notably, it provided training in vaccine-related motivational interviewing for healthcare professionals. Participants were positive about the education being useful in their future work. Cool!

Except … look at that TriCounty vaccine exemption rate above. It’s continued to climb. Maybe you can argue that TriCounty has seen vaccine exemptions rise by less than other similar areas, but it’s only a win in differences, not a win overall. And measles cases are still at their highest levels there.

Nor has Motivational Interviewing really worked with vaccination elsewhere. A meta-study of 118 smaller studies expected to find evidence that Motivational interviewing increased vaccine uptake, but the study authors found that “contrary to our expectations,” there was no “statistical superiority for [motivational interviewing] relative to the usual/standard of care.”

And yet, that still may be our most promising intervention. In the post-pandemic landscape, most health department methods to increase vaccination rates have proven relatively fruitless.

Other educational approaches were found to have a small uptick in vaccination uptake — but mostly among those who hadn’t formed an opinion on vaccines yet. For those who have formed a negative opinion, educational interventions seem to actually entrench their views and make it less likely that they get vaccinated. Those were the findings of a 2015 study on flu vaccination and a 2014 study on the MMR vaccine.

There are legal interventions that have proven more effective. The American Academy of Pediatrics advocates for the elimination of nonmedical exemptions altogether, saying they are “contrary to optimal individual and public health.”

There are, however, several levels of intervention in between.

Many states, including Arkansas, Georgia and New Mexico, require annual renewals of the exemption application. Massachusetts requires signatures from a physician as well as the child’s guardian.

I tend to believe these measures are unlikely in Utah given that the Legislature just considered removing one of the smallest barriers to exemption possible.

During this year’s legislative session, a bill sponsored by Rep. Trevor Lee, R-Layton, would have made it easier for parents to get these vaccination exemptions by removing a requirement to complete a roughly 15-minute online education module before getting one. The bill met a 50-50 deadlock in the committee, with six votes for and six against, and so it died there.

I have but one morsel of optimism to offer: under Utah law, if there is a measles exposure event, students with vaccine exemptions may be asked to stay home for 21 days or more. As the Utah Department of Health and Human Services explains, this “may include students who did not have direct contact with the person who developed measles, since measles is spread through the air.”

However, there is a way to avoid this three-week stay at home: getting vaccinated. Students with exemptions who then get vaccinated within 72 hours of their exposure will be able to return to school.

Perhaps the parents who opted not to vaccinate their kids will think twice if it means nearly a month at home and out of school, while their vaccinated neighbors move ahead with their lives.

But at this point, the endgame shared by David Heaton, public information officer for the Southwest Utah Public Health Department, looks most likely.

“Once everyone’s immunized that is going to be immunized, it may just need to run its course over this season, or maybe even a couple of years,” he said.

Good luck, Utah.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.