What Utah childhood vaccination rates can, and can’t, reveal about demand for COVID-19 vaccine

Experts say the concerns some people have about coronavirus vaccines are not identical to those around childhood immunizations.

( Al Hartmann | The Salt Lake Tribune file photo ) Alexis Herrera, 11, cracks a smile after getting an immunization for school at the 2017 Junior League CARE Fair in the Horizonte Center in Salt Lake City. Data on childhood vaccination rates provide hints about whether enough people in a city or community will get COVID-19 vaccine to help build "herd immunity."

Polls show Americans are increasingly interested in getting vaccinated against COVID-19, but such surveys are largely national, leaving a big question: When the vaccines become available to the general public, will enough people get it in your county, city or neighborhood to keep your community safe?

Data on childhood vaccines, such as the one that protects against measles, mumps and rubella, provide hints. They show that the collective protection known as herd immunity can break down in pockets where not enough people choose to be immunized. Experts say at least 92% of the population must be vaccinated against measles to prevent it from spreading.

In Utah in the 2018-2019 school year, for example, fewer than 5% of kindergarten and elementary school students had an exemption from the MMR vaccine, a KHN analysis found. But the exemptions were not evenly distributed in the state: In kindergartens and elementary schools with complete data, at least 12% had enough students with nonmedical exemptions — religious or personal — to leave them vulnerable to measles outbreaks.

Similarly, in Colorado, fewer than 5% of kindergartners had an exemption from the MMR vaccine in the 2019-20 school year, KHN found. But again, in schools with complete data, at least 15% had enough kindergartners with nonmedical exemptions to leave them vulnerable.

Does childhood immunization data show us which communities will shun the COVID-19 vaccines, as Utah this week opened vaccine eligibility to all residents age 16 and older? Maybe yes, maybe no. Vaccine hesitancy experts say the concerns some people have about the coronavirus vaccines are not identical to those around childhood vaccines. So pockets of childhood vaccine refusal may not correspond to COVID-19 vaccine-hesitant pockets.

“The Venn diagram will have some overlap, but it wouldn’t tell us the whole story,” said Saad Omer, a vaccine researcher and infectious disease epidemiologist who directs the Yale Institute for Global Health. “It’s not the same circle.”

Vaccine hesitancy is not monolithic

Experts like Omer are worried, however, that the political divisions that arose during the pandemic, and are evident in attitudes toward the coronavirus vaccines, could spread to other vaccination campaigns.

Some of the same coalitions that, in recent years, fought expansion of childhood vaccination requirements in state legislatures around the country joined to fight COVID-19 lockdowns.

School immunization rates can shed light on how pockets of vaccine uncertainty work. Utah, Colorado and Idaho are among 15 states, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, where parents can opt their children out of vaccines required for school entry for philosophical reasons. It stands to reason that, in those states, school immunization rates may provide a more unfiltered look at vaccine refusal than in others.

Research shows childhood immunization exemption rates tend to remain relatively stable within schools over time, according to Daniel Salmon, who directs the Institute for Vaccine Safety at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.

In Utah and Idaho, which have a decade of school-level MMR data, most schools with complete data had the same herd immunity status in 2018 as in 2009, a KHN analysis found.

Such trends might be somewhat predictive of how COVID-19 vaccines will be accepted, because once a community resists vaccination it’s hard to undo.

But this measles immunization data doesn’t measure vaccine hesitancy — it measures “actual refusal,” said Salmon. He also noted that childhood vaccines are much more easily accessible than COVID-19 vaccines, so school immunization patterns won’t reflect the potentially large number of people who forgo the coronavirus vaccines because of the effort or logistics involved in getting them.

[Read more: Gov. Spencer Cox says all Utahns 16 and older can start making COVID-19 vaccine appointments]

Also, school immunization exemption figures capture the opinion only of parents of school-age kids, who may not be representative of the general population.

And there’s another, more basic issue: Vaccine hesitancy is not monolithic, regardless of which vaccine or population you’re talking about.

“I saw families that give certain vaccines to one child and other vaccines to a different child based on their perceptions of necessity,” said Jennifer Reich, a sociologist with the University of Colorado-Denver who studied vaccine acceptance. “I could see a family deciding that they want to delay childhood vaccines, but they think the COVID vaccine is really important for their grandmother.”

Omer said only a tiny fraction of very vocal people oppose all vaccines.

“There’s a group of people who are gonna refuse the vaccine no matter what,” he said. “Even if you put mom and apple pie in a shot, they would refuse the vaccine.”

A somewhat larger segment of parents will refuse one or more — but not all — vaccines for their children. And then there’s a much larger group that expresses hesitation about vaccination but ultimately accepts it.

The political reaction to COVID-19 vaccines

Outright refusers are likely to make up a small part of the very broad group of adults who hesitate to get coronavirus vaccine, too, Omer said. Many people are sitting on the fence and may still opt to be vaccinated.

Polls from KFF and the Pew Research Center show Americans’ opinions have shifted over the past few months, with a growing share saying either that they want to get a vaccine “as soon as possible” or that they’ve already gotten one. (KHN is an editorially independent program of KFF.)

Interestingly, despite lots of coverage about vaccine concerns among racial and ethnic minorities, the latest KFF numbers show a nearly equal share of white and Black respondents — 15% and 14%, respectively — said they would “definitely not” get the vaccine.

[Read more: White Utahns get vaccinated at twice the rate of other communities. Will new access change that?]

Such polls also highlight another difference between childhood vaccines and the coronavirus vaccines: how political COVID-19 vaccines have become.

“So far, childhood vaccines have been a bipartisan issue, more or less,” said Omer. “Every few months, there’s a debate on Twitter about whether it’s a conservative issue or a liberal issue, or if it’s the crunchy granola crowd or the libertarian crowd that is driving it. It’s all of the above.”

Indeed, Utah schools that lacked herd immunity against the measles in 2018 because of high rates of nonmedical exemptions are a motley crew, spanning everything from a private religious school in Sandy to charter schools in Moab and Enoch and elementary schools in Lehi, Mona and Hildale.

The pattern was similar in Colorado, where such schools in 2019 ranged from a private religious school in the state’s rural southwest to a private Waldorf school in affluent Boulder and a public high school in the Rockies.

Still, vaccination skepticism has trended Republican in recent years as mistrust of scientific authority has grown in the party. Following the measles outbreaks that sprang up across the United States in 2019, GOP legislators in several states opposed Democrat-led efforts to tighten vaccine exemption laws — a harbinger of GOP-led protests against lockdowns during the pandemic.

And attitudes toward COVID-19 vaccination largely fall along party lines. As the KFF survey shows, the percentage of Democrats who said they wanted to get the shots as soon as possible (or had already gotten them) rose 28 points between December and February. The percentage rose 13 points among Republican respondents.

An increasingly politicized COVID-19 vaccine landscape could threaten acceptance of other vaccines. Kristin Lunz Trujillo, a political scientist at Carleton College in Minnesota, said the pandemic teed up a situation in which vaccines could become a partisan issue.

“We’ve seen with the COVID vaccine, more so than any vaccine previously, the politicization that’s occurring,” she said.

And as Omer put it, when something leaves the realm of opinion and enters partisan identity, it calcifies.

“You become less persuadable — even in the face of a lot of evidence,” he said. “With masks and the current debates around lockdowns, etc., if vaccines get folded in as part of that level of political identity, or a sense of yourself or your ideological brand, then we are in deep trouble.”

Dr. Peter Hotez, a professor at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, has watched the anti-vaccine campaign grow from a fringe movement in the early 2000s. It accelerated in 2015, when it linked to the political extreme on the right under a banner of “health freedom,” he said.

“COVID-19, actually, somewhat paradoxically made things worse in terms of energizing the anti-vaccine movement,” he said. “It’s now a full-on anti-science empire.”

On the other hand, said Reich, coronavirus vaccines may create opportunities to improve the conversation around vaccines in general. Previously, she said, vaccine messaging tended to be one way: billboards, brochures, public service announcements. Now, state and local governments are engaging much more with stakeholders and community leaders.

“This moment is creating an awareness that communication that is successful has to be two-directional,” she said. “That’s an overdue change.”

People have questions about what are, as Reich pointed out, vaccines that remain unlicensed. Engaging them in conversations, rather than dismissing them as victims of misinformation or conspiracy theories, could increase childhood vaccine use, too, she said.

This article was produced as a project for the USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalism’s Data Fellowship.


Return to Story