facebook-pixel

Gordon Monson: A long-held complaint by crybabies about BYU football is utter nonsense

The Cougars aren’t among the oldest teams in college football this season

(Trent Nelson  |  The Salt Lake Tribune) BYU Cougars quarterback Bear Bachmeier (47) as BYU hosts TCU, NCAA football in Provo on Saturday, Nov. 15, 2025.

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) BYU Cougars quarterback Bear Bachmeier (47) as BYU hosts TCU, NCAA football in Provo on Saturday, Nov. 15, 2025.

It’s long been a tired, weak and lazy argument put forth by opposing fan bases and particularly egregiously by opposing coaches that BYU has some sort of competitive advantage based on the age of its players.

If I had five bucks for every time I’ve heard a coach bemoan the alleged fact that his “young kids” were going up against the Cougars’ “grown men,” and that somehow, some way, they’d have to overcome that disadvantage, I’d be able to buy an adult beverage for every thirsty, wayward soul reading this column.

I’ve written it before and I’ll likely write it again: It’s not true, not on the reg, and even if the age thing were true, it would not be an advantage.

We can tackle the latter first and the former second.

An online outfit known as the College Football Zone compiled a ranking of what it says is the 25 oldest college football teams based on average age of players heading into the 2026 season. BYU is nowhere in sight on the list Neither is Utah.

Utah State is third in the ranking. Among others, Navy and Oregon State and Oklahoma State are in there, as are Washington State, San Diego State, Cal, Air Force, UCF, Kansas, Virginia, Baylor and Stanford.

Not exactly a murderers row of college powers.

That’s assuming the College Football Zone did proper research in getting its ranking right. But the accuracy of that assumption doesn’t even matter because slightly older football teams do not make slightly better football teams. If they did, programs like Ohio State and Alabama and Georgia would be finding ways to delay the playing time of their talent through whatever means NCAA rules allow. Means not exclusive to, but certainly inclusive of church missions.

And in the case of BYU, that’s what its football team — OK, not its football team, but the school’s sponsoring religion — is known to do. Not in every individual player’s course, but, according to the school’s website, nearly half of its football team is made up of returned missionaries. It’s not a requirement. Serving a mission for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is completely voluntary, far from mandatory for any aspiring player — unless the two-deep chart is stocked so full of talent that getting off the bench to make an ascent to the starting lineup is darn near impossible. Then, leaving football behind as a part of commitment to serving the Almighty, to preaching the good word, is considerably more certain.

That’s a joke … as far as you know.

As for that temporary abandonment of football, playing and practicing it while aging for the customary two years, being any kind of advantage on the field, that is a myth, one that, as mentioned, some opposing coaches love to lean into.

Anyone who buys that knows little of what they’re either talking about or hearing.

LDS Church missions generally disrupt players’ athletic progress much more than they enhance them. In more than a few cases, missionaries are out working in third world countries, living in jungle huts, consuming local cuisine that approximates nothing close to a training table, spending 12 hours a day talking and teaching about Jesus or helping those in need to fix their fence or a leaky roof, or improve their living conditions in one way or another. Even those missionaries who live and do their work in more modern cities scattered across the globe, most of them are not heading down to a nearby 24 Hour Fitness to get in their daily conditioning. They’re busting their humps studying scripture, sharing their version of religious truth, drenched not in sweat but in charity, arising out of bed at 6 a.m. and collapsing back into it at 10 p.m.

I’ve interviewed hundreds of athletes who served missions, often asking them about the effect their service had on their football or basketball or baseball or fill-in-the-blank careers, and, from a physical aspect, almost all of them said the time away from their sport hurt them more than it helped.

One quarterback pointed to a leftover scar on his leg, evidence of a worm infestation he suffered in the far reaches of a village in a Panamanian rainforest. An offensive lineman said he lost 60 pounds. A linebacker admitted he could barely do 20 pushups. A receiver recalled an incident in which a bandit swiped his wallet and attempted to outrun him, crossing a six-lane highway in the process, the perp not knowing his victim had held onto his 4.5 speed.

There are some maturation benefits gained by heading out into the world to preach the word. A returned missionary center put it this way: “After knocking on doors in South Philadelphia for two years, you’re not afraid of anything anymore.” Certainly not a few swinging elbows on a basketball court.

Many BYU coaches I’ve asked about the mission thing are careful with their answers, not wanting to be seen as running down the idea of their athletes interrupting their college careers to serve the church. But a lot of them have whispered that if they had their preference done for their players’ sustained athletic success, they would privately encourage them to stay and play.

“We don’t come right out and say that,” one nervous coach told me. “But …”

That makes the mission sacrifice put in by college athletes all the more impressive.

One concern is that some athletes, upon finding a strong commitment in a different direction and then returning, no longer have the same burn to play football. They’d rather get on with other aspects of their lives. NIL bennies might have lessened that for those who have them available to them.

Either way, perhaps in time the notion that BYU has some unfair edge on account of age will fade away. But as the football program has gained momentum in recent years, that prospect is unlikely. Given that nobody brings up the Cougars’ supposed advantage when they lose more than they win, only when they are good, the complaining is bound to continue.

Support free news for Utah

sltrib.com is now free to access — no subscription required. We made this decision because we believe access to trustworthy, independent news shouldn’t depend on what you can afford — especially as misinformation and AI-generated content continue to rise.

Free to read doesn’t mean free to produce. Our reporters show up every day to ask hard questions and hold powerful institutions to account. That work takes resources. As a nonprofit newsroom, we rely on support from people who believe it matters. Make a donation today to fund local news that serves Utah communities.

You can help us bring more local news to more communities today.