Grantsville teenager charged with killing his mother and siblings

(Rick Egan | The Salt Lake Tribune) This home in Granstville was the scene of a quadruple homicide Friday night, Saturday, Jan. 18, 2020.

A 16-year-old from Grantsville was charged Wednesday with 10 felony counts in the shooting deaths of his mother and three siblings and for allegedly also trying to kill his father.

Charging documents allege Colin Jeffery Haynie first killed his mother, Alejandra Consuelo, and youngest sister, Milan, 12, on Jan. 17 after the pair came home from school. This was around 1 p.m.

Prosecutors say Colin Haynie killed his remaining siblings as they returned home.

Alexis, 17, was killed next. Then Matthew, 14, around 5:15 p.m.

Consuelo Haynie

Milan Haynie

Matthew Haynie

Alexis Haynie

All were shot in the head, chest or shoulder with a handgun, according to charging documents.

When Colin Haynie’s father, also named Colin, came home about an hour later, the teen allegedly shot him in the leg.

The father and son started fighting, and Colin Haynie allegedly hit his father in the head, causing a cut. Colin Haynie’s father told police that he told his son “that the defendant’s mother would be sad if the defendant killed him.”

That’s when Colin Haynie allegedly told his father that the rest of the family were already dead. His father said that Colin Haynie said he wanted to “kill everyone in the house except himself," charging documents state.

Colin Haynie’s father eventually got the gun away from the teen.

According to charging documents, a third person took the father and son to the hospital and called police while en route.

Colin Haynie was charged with four counts of aggravated murder, a count of attempted aggravated murder and five counts of discharging a firearm. All counts are first-degree felonies, and the teen will be tried in adult court.

The Salt Lake Tribune generally does not identify juvenile suspects unless they are charged as an adult.

Court documents do not indicate a motive in the killings, which are among the state’s worst mass shootings and Grantsville’s first homicide in at least 20 years. It appears to be one of the largest mass shooting in Utah since 2007, when a gunman killed five people and himself at Trolley Square mall in Salt Lake City.

In an obituary, Alejandra Haynie is remembered for her love for cooking and gardening, especially taking care of her fruit trees.

Milan Haynie, a seventh grader, wanted to be an engineer. She played soccer and volleyball and was known for leaving nice notes signed “from so and so.”

The obituary says Alexis Haynie, a freshman at Grantsville High School, was an accomplished artist who played the piano and loved “The Lord of The Rings."

Matthew Haynie, an eighth grader, enjoyed sports like soccer and wrestling, liked playing chess and loved "anything to do with ‘Star Wars.’”

A funeral for the victims will take place Friday.

Colin Haynie is scheduled to appear in court Jan. 27.

Return to Story