More than 300 residents attended the Jan. 7 town hall meeting in Kanab to express serious concerns about the proposed development known as Willow, being advanced by Philo Ventures with support from the state of Utah. The overwhelming message from the community was clear: this project is not appropriate for Kane County.
Residents are deeply troubled that state officials appear to be sidestepping local governance and professional oversight, allowing a private developer to exert outsized influence over a proposal that will permanently alter this rural high-desert region. Kane County is defined by limited water resources, fragile desert soils, and some of the darkest night skies remaining in the country. These realities demand careful, locally informed planning — not a one-size-fits-all development model better suited to urban areas.
While the community agrees that affordable housing is a real need, this proposal fails to deliver it. The projected home prices — around $450,000 — are far beyond the reach of most local workers earning $15–$17 per hour. Calling these units “affordable” ignores economic realities and risks displacing the very people this project claims to serve.
Equally concerning is the feasibility study used to justify the project. It relies on speculative assumptions while omitting critical infrastructure considerations, including water availability, sewage, fire protection, road capacity, light pollution and emergency access. Mountain View Drive, the primary access route, is a narrow rural road crossing multiple flood-prone washes. The significant cost and environmental impact required to upgrade this road were not meaningfully addressed.
My husband and I moved to Kane County two years ago after more than a decade of planning and saving to build our final home here. We chose this community for its open land, clean air and strong sense of connection. We did not come to recreate urban sprawl.
Willow is not wanted, not needed, and threatens the very qualities that make this area home. We urge state leaders to pause this process, listen to residents, and respect local governance before irreparable harm is done.
Sioux Sugden, Kanab
Donate to the newsroom now. The Salt Lake Tribune, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) public charity and contributions are tax deductible