facebook-pixel

Letter: Just eliminate vanity license plates

(Photo courtesy of Matt Pacenza) A Utah license plate that reads "DEPORTM" is under review by the Utah Tax Commission, which oversees the state Division of Motor Vehicles. The plate was approved in 2015, despite rules forbidding plates that may offend "good taste and decency" by showing “contempt, ridicule or superiority of a race, religion, deity, ethnic heritage or political affiliation.” The plate came to light when complaints surfaced this week on social media.

Regarding the controversy about the Utah Division of Motor Vehicles processing “vanity” license plates with potentially offensive messages, I have a modest proposal: Just eliminate vanity plates altogether.

Why should the state of Utah sponsor any personal messages, especially political ones? Eliminating vanity plates creates no First Amendment problem because the policy would be content neutral, indeed, more neutral than a system relying on the discretion of individual state officials.

Anyone who wants to use their vehicle to make a political statement can use that old favorite, the bumper sticker. State officials would be freed from the burden of vetting proposed language.

Does the $58 fee for vanity plates generate significant net revenues considering additional labor costs to DMV? Even if that’s an issue, based on my quick calculation, it could be offset by increasing all vehicle fees by less than $5 per vehicle.

Let’s get the state out of the business of facilitating personal political messages.

Bob Adler, Salt Lake City

Submit a letter to the editor