Utah’s Legislature might kill ballot initiatives to fund schools and expand Medicaid

Lawmakers eye steps they can take in next 45 days — hoping to stave off related referendums<br>

Chris Detrick | The Salt Lake Tribune Members of the public and lobbyists walk and wait outside the House of Representatives at the Utah State Capitol Thursday March 9, 2017.

Utah technically has 104 legislators — 29 senators and 75 House members. But those elected officials are looking over their shoulders at ballot initiatives that may convert the state’s 1.5 million registered voters into the real lawmakers controlling this year’s agenda.

As the 2018 Legislature convenes Monday, leaders acknowledge they want to undercut two ballot initiatives: one that seeks to raise taxes for education by $715 million annually, and one to expand Medicaid fully for the poor.

They hope steps that would not go as far as the initiatives would will satisfy voters.

“I hope they see it and say, ‘Some good things are happening here,’” and that will dissuade them from passing the initiatives, said House Speaker Greg Hughes, R-Draper.

(Rick Egan | The Salt Lake Tribune) House Speaker Greg Hughes announces that he will not run for re-election next year, during a media conference in Midvale, Wednesday, January 10, 2018.

But House Democratic leader Brian King, who supports the ballot drives, says they result from legislators doing too little for too long.

“You have these initiatives crop up because people get so frustrated that the Legislature is not responding to their desires,” the Salt Lake City Democrat said. That’s important for us to take to heart at the Legislature” and may finally prod real action.

A raft of other topics high on this year’s agenda including fights over Utah’s new toughest-in-the-nation drunken driving law, tax reform, homelessness, air quality and restructuring the scandal-tainted Utah Transit Authority.

The session may also be spiced by a number of other debates: outlawing hand-held cellphone use while driving, cutting back on the number of days fireworks are allowed, maybe blocking state-paid health care for children of legal immigrants and even a bill to make the Utahraptor the official state dinosaur (and leave the Allosaurus as the state fossil).

Education/tax reform

Legislative leaders and Gov. Gary Herbert all say, as they do just about every year, that improving education is the state’s top priority. And extra pressure for that comes from the Our Schools Now initiative that would raise taxes for education by $715 million per year.

Herbert contends such a tax hike would hurt Utah’s economy, and essentially kill the golden goose of low taxes that attracts new industry, creates jobs and fuels what has been one of the nation’s strongest economies.

So Herbert and GOP leaders are planning to cobble together more education money through a mixture of state tax changes, use of a possible windfall from recent federal tax bill and taking advantage of extra revenue the state projects it will receive in next year’s budget.

With all that, “We can get close” to matching what the initiative would produce, Lt. Gov. Spencer Cox said last week.

Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune Scott Anderson, President and CEO of Zions Bank speaks in support of Our Schools Now as they formally launch its tax increase initiative during a press event at the Capitol on Tuesday, June 6, 2017.

For example, the state estimates it will receive $382 million more in the coming year than previously expected in ongoing tax revenue. Herbert proposes to use 72 percent, or about $275 million, of that for education. Legislative leaders support using much of it for schools, but warn current laws may mandate spending a lot of it elsewhere.

Herbert has been pushing to remove earmarks that funnel some taxes for specific purposes, such as highways, to give policymakers greater discretion to fund other priorities, including schools. He also is angling to eliminate scores of tax exemptions for various industries that have accumulated through the decades.

Cox, last week, also called for taxing more online sales. Some large online retailers such as Amazon recently voluntarily agreed to collect such tax in Utah, “but much more could be done,” Cox said.

Senate President Wayne Niederhauser seeks another interesting tax reform: forcing highway users to cover more of the state’s transportation costs so the $600 million now coming annually from the state general fund to subsidize highways could be transferred to schools. Hughes endorses the idea.

Niederhauser, R-Sandy, supports increasing the gasoline tax as one method to do that. Also, he notes that electric and alternative-fuel vehicles now escape the gas tax entirely, and he backs proposals to raise their registration fees or charge a per-mile-traveled tax on them.

In this Tuesday, May 2, 2017, photo, a motorist prepares to select regular gas at a pump at a Chevron station in Miami. Gas prices are still quite low, historically speaking, and were fairly steady in 2017. But 2018 may be a bit more rocky, according to Tom Kloza, global head of energy analysis at the Oil Price Information Service. (AP Photo/Alan Diaz)

At the same time, Niederhauser has introduced a bill to make collection of electronic tolls easier. He said that could lead to a toll road in Little Cottonwood Canyon and maybe elsewhere.

Leaders are also looking at the recent federal tax bill as a way to funnel money to schools.

State income taxes are based on federal definitions. If the state makes no changes to its system, some estimate the federal reforms might generate an additional $75 million to $150 million, although most caution the state still is unsure of the amount.

“I think there is a windfall. We just don’t know how much yet,” Niederhauser said. It “will now allow [state] tax reform to move forward in some degree.

King, the House Democratic leader who says not enough has been done for education, agrees that legislative action on these fronts “would make it easier for the Legislature to go back to the people to say, ’Look don’t write us off so quickly … we are serious that when we get extra money, that [education] is where we are going to put it.”


GOP lawmakers are talking about some expansion of Medicaid, the federal-state program to provide health care for the poor, even though Republicans for years have voted down all but tiny expansions for the most vulnerable populations — such as homeless adults.

One reason is the initiative that calls for fully expanding Medicaid, which would cover up to 120,000 more Utahns who earn 138 percent of poverty level or less. Another reason is the Trump administration has signaled willingness to provide waivers for a less-than-full expansion that Utah lawmakers have long sought.

Hughes said the House had previously rejected expansion of Medicaid largely because it would need to be open-ended to cover anyone who qualified, making it hard to determine how much it would cost annually.

(Al Hartmann | The Salt Lake Tribune) Health care advocates Alan Ormsby, AARP, left, Karina Andelin Brown, a Logan resident, and Bishop Scott Hayashi, Episcopal diocese of Utah deliver a ballot initiative to fully expand Medicaid in Utah to the Lt. Governor's office Monday Oct. 2. Utah has been trying to fully expand Medicaid for many years to no avail. Many advocates say this is a chance to finally make some real change.

Also, House members wanted to offer Medicaid only for those at 100 percent of the poverty level, and the Obama administration wanted expansion for those up to 138 percent of that level. The Affordable Care Act offers subsidized insurance to those between 100 percent and 138 percent of poverty already, said Hughes.

Senate Democratic leader Gene Davis of Salt Lake City said he will introduce a bill to seek full Medicaid expansion, not a watered-down version. He doubts it will pass, but says it will draw attention to what the initiative could do if lawmakers don’t act.

Other initiatives

Groups are gathering signatures for several other initiatives — such as allowing medical marijuana, using an independent commission to draw political boundaries to reduce gerrymandering and cementing into law a signature-gathering route to the primary ballot.

“My guess is we will have bills that will address them,” or at least some of them, Niederhauser said. Lawmakers prefer dealing with them rather than through initiatives, he added, “because it’s easier in the future to deal with any changes we need to make.”

An exception may be medical marijuana. He said lawmakers feel strongly that drugs “ought to be distributed through a pharmacy,” and “we’re concerned the federal government now is going to potentially enforce their law [banning marijuana] instead of overlooking it.”

However, Rep. Brad Daw, R-Orem, and Sen. Evan Vickers, R-Cedar City, a pharmacist, have introduced HB195, a bill to create a “right to try” cannabis-based treatment for terminally ill patients.


Hughes, the House speaker, said continued support of Operation Rio Grande — cleaning up crime in the area around the homeless shelter in downtown Salt Lake City, and getting aid to the homeless — will be a continuing focus.

He said its current $67 million budget will likely need to be boosted by a few million dollars.

“We will have some additional requests that will come from additional jurisdictions” for help as the homeless and some problems with crime have dispersed from the Rio Grande area. That will include some help with law enforcement, and some for facilities elsewhere.

(Steve Griffin | The Salt Lake Tribune) UHP Troopers make an arrest on 500 west as law enforcement officers from several agencies increase their presence in the Rio Grand homeless area in Salt Lake City Monday August 14, 2017.

Hughes wants to guard against a bandwagon effect in which groups may try to gain money for loosely related projects by arguing they are needed for Operation Rio Grande.

Davis, the Senate Democratic leader, said, “Have we cured homelessness? No. Have we put frustration into drug dealers? Yes. They are still selling, but they are frustrated. We are helping people.”

Drunken driving

Last year, legislators passed a law that will lower the blood-alcohol level to be considered drunk while driving from 0.08 to 0.05. It goes into effect on Dec. 30 and when it does, Utah will have the toughest DUI law in the nation. Groups have pushed for a repeal, saying it will hurt Utah tourism or possibly allow police to arrest some who have as little as one drink.

“There will be some minor tweaks to that, but it looks like that will be here to stay,” predicts Niederhauser. Hughes, who had opposed the bill for unintended consequences, isn’t so sure. “I can’t predict its fate.”

Rep. Norm Thurston, R-Provo, sponsor of the new law, introduced HB98 to make a minor change. His original bill banned “novice drivers” from having even a drop of alcohol before driving, which would affect older adults who obtain licenses later in life or immigrants who obtain licenses here. He wants to remove that provision.

FILE - In this Dec. 29, 2011 file photo, a car approaches a sobriety checkpoint set up along a busy street in Albuquerque, N.M. A prestigious scientific panel is recommending that states significantly lower their drunken driving thresholds as part of a blueprint to eliminate the “entirely preventable” 10,000 alcohol-impaired driving deaths in the United States each year. (AP Photo/Susan Montoya Bryan)

Just last week, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine called for all states to adopt a 0.05 level.

Still King, the House Democratic leader, said he expects to see bills to delay or repeal the law, or perhaps offer different penalties for driving at 0.05 or 0.08.


Legislative leaders expect debate and possible action on restructuring the Utah Transit Authority.

A legislative task force has recommended replacing its current board and CEO with a three-member commission appointed by the governor, similar to the State Tax Commission.

Hughes, a former UTA chairman, said the proposed change would install full-time commissioners who would “really have their eyes on what’s going on there, and be a little bit more directly accountable.”

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) People go about their day as the Salt Lake City Council, Salt Lake County, and the Utah Transit Authority gather on the North Temple Bridge/Guadalupe TRAX station in Salt Lake to announce Free Fare Friday to encourage greater use of transit during periods of poor air quality. On Friday, Dec. 22, no cash fares will be required on trains or buses in an effort to get infrequent or first-time riders to try out transit and use it more frequently.

He said that could restore enough trust that voters in Salt Lake and Utah counties may reconsider their 2015 defeat of Proposition 1 to raise sales taxes for transit and local roads. “We need to make sure that everyone is a good partner and can go to the public and win their confidence,” Hughes said. “We hope that change will help that.”

King also seems to be on board for a change at UTA.

“For 10 to 15 years, we’ve heard about scandals, self-dealing, compensation that is really quite high,” King said. “The facts suggest that something is wrong. I want to see something done there because UTA’s image suffers.”

The legislative task force also recommended a change to allow state highway funds to be shared with transit. Leaders say restructuring UTA would need to happen first to win support for that — but that highway funds going to some transit could help reduce congestion and pollution.

Air quality

Pollution always is a big issue early in legislative sessions when inversions hang in the Salt Lake Valley. The governor is proposing more money for better monitoring and research, which Democratic leader King praises.

“It sounds like a ‘nothingburger,’ but it really isn’t,” he said. “If we can get more money to study more effectively where the clean air problems exist and which neighborhoods they affect disproportionately, we can do a better job of directing solutions.”

He notes a few bills are coming, including possibly requiring emissions testing for diesel vehicles in Utah County and one to increase penalties for “rolling coal” vehicles that intentionally emit dark emissions.

Other legislation

Among proposals that have sparked early interest is HB64 by Rep. Carol Moss, D-Holladay, that seeks to fully outlaw using hand-held electronic devices while driving, but would permit using hands-free technology.

She notes that University of Utah studies have said cellphone use while driving is as dangerous as drunken driving. The expected debate on tougher drunken-driving laws might improve chances to finally pass the talking-while-driving ban, Moss said.

After fireworks-ignited blazes last year destroyed some homes, Rep. Jim Dunnigan, R-Taylorsville, is introducing HB38 to make it easier for cities to ban or control them — and cut back the number of days fireworks are allowed statewide.

Leah Hogsten | The Salt Lake Tribune Fireworks named Thrill Seeker, Bring It, Large and in Charge and You 'Da Man can be purchased at the TNT Fireworks stand at 2700 S. State. Fireworks went on sale Wednesday, July 1, 2015.

Fireworks now can legally be set off for seven days around Independence and Pioneer days. The bill would cut that back to July 2 to July 5 and July 22 to July 25. It would also continue to allow fireworks around New Year’s Day.

Sen. Allen Christensen, R-North Ogden, created controversy with SB48 to require new legal immigrants to wait five years before they could receive Medicaid or Children’s Health Insurance Program coverage. It would strip coverage from about 475 immigrant children.

Christensen says he is proposing the measure to promote self-reliance and combat creeping socialism. Critics said it is a mean-spirited attack on immigrants, mostly Latinos.

And a literally big fight may have been avoided between whether the Utahraptor should replace Allosaurus as the state fossil. Sen. Curt Bramble, R-Provo, has rewritten SB43 to keep Allosaurus the official state fossil, but add Utahraptor as the official dinosaur to allow honoring both.