AP investigation: Utah jail inmate’s suicide not an isolated case

The last time Tanna Jo Fillmore talked with her mother, she was in a Utah jail, angry and desperate. She’d called every day that week, begging for help.

I need my medicine, she demanded.

At 25, Fillmore had long struggled with mental illness, but Xanax and hyperactivity medication had stabilized her. Now, she was locked up on a probation violation, and she told her mother the jail nurse was refusing to provide her pills. In their final conversation, Fillmore threatened to kill herself.

Melany Zoumadakis was so alarmed she immediately called her daughter’s probation officer, who assured her Fillmore was being closely monitored. But on Thanksgiving 2016, a day after that threat, Fillmore hanged herself in the Duchesne County Jail.

Her case is not isolated. Increasingly, troubling questions are being raised about the treatment of mentally ill inmates in the nation's 3,100 local jails, possible patterns of neglect — and whether better care could have saved lives.

A joint investigation by The Associated Press and the University of Maryland's Capital News Service finds many jails have been sued or investigated in recent years for allegedly refusing inmates medication to help manage mental illness, ignoring cries for help, failing to properly monitor them, or imposing excessively harsh conditions.

A review of 165 lawsuits that specifically involved suicides or attempts in local jails found:

These lawsuits represent a tiny fraction of the problem. Suicide, long the leading cause of death in U.S. jails, hit a high of 50 deaths for every 100,000 inmates in 2014, the latest government data available. That’s 2½ times the rate of suicides in state prisons and about 3½ times that of the general population.

The total number of suicides in 2014 was 372, according to federal statistics.

An exclusive 50-state reporting effort to collect recent statistics found more than 300 suicides in local jails from 2015 to 2017 — in just nine states. The others did not provide numbers or offered incomplete data, an issue prompting some legislatures to consider bills that would require jails to provide better information about those dying behind bars.

It's a problem commonly blamed on the fact more mentally ill people are being jailed, a trend that started after state psychiatric hospitals began closing in the 1970s. More recently, jails have been overwhelmed with opioid or meth users, many of whom also wrestle with depression.

Lori Rifkin, a California prisoners' rights attorney, argues the vast majority of these suicides "are foreseeable and preventable."

"I think there is a cultural dismissiveness toward both the signs that help us predict suicide — and toward the steps necessary to prevent them," she adds.

Jonathan Thompson, head of the National Sheriffs' Association, calls that absurd and says while jail officials must safeguard inmates, "we're not the nation's psychologists. We have decided that as a society let's just warehouse the mentally ill in a jail ... which is neither equipped for, trained to handle or able to be most efficient and effective at solving the problem."

Some cases have resulted in substantial settlements over faulty policies or neglect.

In Lake County, Calif., Elizabeth Gaunt, a 56-year-old former social worker with a psychiatric history, was jailed after acting erratically but never charged. Over 25 hours, she begged for a doctor, repeatedly screamed “help me,” tore a blanket into strips and then killed herself. A guard didn’t enter her cell during a check but noted in an observation log all was OK. The county settled a wrongful death lawsuit for $2 million.

Dane Shikman, Gaunt’s son, says his mother belonged in a mental health center, not jail, and believes guards were negligent. “When they see someone who looks like they’re struggling,” he says, “they don’t say, ‘Let me step in. This is someone’s mom.’ ... They think this is a woman on drugs doing whatever she’s going to do, she’ll shut up.”

Sheriff Brian Martin implemented reforms that included installing a larger surveillance monitor, replacing blankets with tear-resistant ones and giving staff more suicide-prevention training.

In Fillmore's case, a lawsuit is pending against Duchesne County, the former sheriff and others, including the jail nurse.

Fillmore had been diagnosed years earlier with post-traumatic stress, anxiety, panic disorder and depression. She also had a history of drug use, but attorney Tyler Ayres says she wasn't suicidal and just needed her medication. "They have an obligation to provide adequate medical care," he says.

Fillmore was jailed, Ayres adds, for failing to provide a change of address to a probation officer.

Sheriff Travis Tucker, who took office in January, declined comment on the case but noted a jail wing is being built to serve mentally ill and addicted inmates.

When she died, Fillmore was waiting to enter a residential drug program. Five days later, on what would have been check-in day, her mother got a call asking why Fillmore hadn't shown up.

She relayed the news. Then she prepared to bury her daughter.

Cohen, an AP national writer, reported from Chicago. Eckert is a reporter with the University of Maryland’s Capital News Service. Also contributing to the data analysis were Capital News Service reporters Riin Aljas, James Crabtree-Hannigan, Elliott Davis, Theresa Diffendal, Jessica Feldman, Hannah Gaskill, Samantha Hawkins and Roxanne Ready.