It's a career that compares closely to Hall of Famers Tiny Archibald and Isiah Thomas. But unlike Archibald and Thomas, after overlapping Michael Jordan's reign of the league, Hardaway lacks an NBA championship. There is also the matter of comments made 10 years ago this month during a radio interview when responding to a question about former NBA center John Amaechi's decision to publicly come out as a gay man.
"Well, you know, I hate gay people, so I let it be known," Hardaway said on the Miami show hosted by ESPN personality Dan Le Batard. "I don't like gay people, and I don't like to be around gay people. I am homophobic. I don't like it. It shouldn't be in the world or in the United States. So, yeah, I don't like it."
They are words that, Hardaway says now, will haunt him until the day he dies.
"When I said what I said . . . I still cringe at it when I think about it, and still hurts me deep inside that I said something like that because I gave people an opportunity to hurt people," Hardaway said in a recent phone interview. "That wasn't right . . . each and every day when I talk to kids today and they bring it up to me or somebody brings it up to me, I say that was a very big mistake on my part.
"It hurts me to this day, what I said, and you know what? It's going to hurt me for the rest of my life, because I'm not that type of person. I feel bad about it and I'm always going to feel bad about it."
The comments proved damaging both then and now. After the NBA's leadership heard the Le Batard interview, it banned him from its 2007 all-star festivities, where Hardaway was serving as an ambassador of the league. To this day, his words are what many people remember most about Hardaway's legacy. But it is a part of his story he has actively worked to change.
In the years following the radio interview, Hardaway has become an outspoken advocate for LGBTQ rights, including working with The Trevor Project, a nonprofit group that focuses on suicide prevention for LGBTQ youth. He was also became the first signer of a petition to legalize same-sex marriage in the state of Florida. In 2011, he attended a rally in El Paso - where Hardaway had been a college star at UTEP years earlier - to support the city's mayor, John Cook, who was facing an attempted recall vote (which later failed) after allowing domestic partnership rights for gay and unmarried couples.
"I was humbled to have him be there," Cook said. "It was something I never really expected. He basically didn't have a dog in the fight, and he was willing to step up and go out of his way to stand up for what was the right thing to do, which is what I was doing, I think. And I think it did make a difference to the people who were supporting me to see Tim come all the way down here just to show his support for what we were trying to do."
In April of 2013, Jason Collins penned an open letter in Sports Illustrated, coming out as openly gay and setting the stage for him to become the first openly gay, active player in one of the four major American sports the following spring when he signed with the Brooklyn Nets. After the letter's publication, he received a phone call from a number he didn't recognize bearing South Florida's 305 area code. It was Hardaway, calling to offer his support.
"I remember seeing or hearing what he said ⅛during the Le Batard interview⅜," Collins said in a phone interview Wednesday. "As a closeted athlete, that's your biggest fear, coming out and being met with rejection openly.
"I have to say, I get asked what was the most surprising ⅛call⅜ after making my announcement, and, yes, getting the call from the President ⅛Barack Obama⅜ and Oprah ⅛Winfrey⅜ and all of that was surprising. But getting a call from Tim Hardaway is right up there, because I didn't know he had changed as a human being, as far as being what happened with his comments when Jon came out, and now becoming an ally.
"It shows the power of the coming out story. It shows the power of John Amaechi's story. Tim obviously said what he said and was met with a lot of criticism and was forced to look at himself in the mirror and has changed a lot. . . . I'm glad I answered the call and heard his words."
Hardaway's change was also observed by Detroit Pistons Coach Stan Van Gundy -- an outspoken and progressive voice in the NBA who publicly decried the election of President Trump in November, noting his concern for minorities and women - who hired Hardaway to his staff as an assistant coach in 2014.
"I think what Tim had was a genuine change of heart," Van Gundy said. "That is what he meant when he said it and the incident made him stop and think about it and why he had the feelings he did.
"He had those feelings, he was forced to think about it, he changed his mind, he changed his heart, and there's been nothing like that since. As a matter of fact, he's gone out of his way to be supportive of the LGBTQ community. But the way he handled it to me speaks better of his character."
It is unclear how, or if, those comments will impact the discussion of his Hall of Fame status, but Collins hopes the upcoming decision will focus on Hardaway's distinguished career.