Utah’s top exports are gold and computer chips, but the state’s sought-after concealed-weapons permit is climbing up that list.
However, with hundreds of out-of-state instructors issuing tens of thousands of permits every year, some Utah instructors and state legislators are concerned the volume is straining the ability of Utah regulators to ensure the rigor of the courses.
"By and large the classes are being taught by dedicated professionals," said Clark Aposhian, a concealed-weapons instructor and chairman of the Utah Shooting Sports Council. "But as we know by sad experience, it just takes a few unscrupulous instructors to affect the perception in a poor way for everyone else. And as such, the integrity of the Utah permit suffers, and we watch the dominoes: As the integrity suffers, so does the reciprocity and so does the value [of the permit]."
One proposed solution, requiring licensed instructors to be Utah residents, is steadfastly opposed by the National Rifle Association and so polarizing that it has caused a rift in Utah’s shooting community.
Brian Judy, a Utah lobbyist for the NRA, did not respond to a request for comment.
A simple Web search shows the popularity of Utah’s permit, with scores of instructors across the country touting the benefits — it’s relatively inexpensive, fairly easy to get and is honored in 34 states.
It’s those reciprocity agreements, however, that may be in jeopardy as states begin to question if instructors are rubber-stamping permits and Utah regulators are unable to monitor the quality of the courses.
Currently, there are 1,622 instructors licensed to teach Utah’s concealed-weapons courses — 1,124 of them live outside of Utah.
There are just three investigators at Utah’s Bureau of Criminal Identification (BCI)responsible for keeping tabs on those instructors. Last year, the program had out-of-state travel expenses of less than $7,000.
"[BCI] gets calls all the time from people who say instructors are rubber-stamping out-of-state," said Crystal Perry, a licensed instructor in Utah. "There’s no way for them to regulate that."
Out of state » In 2011, the Utah BCI, which operates the concealed-weapons permit program, received 64,440 permit applications from out-of-state residents and 13,872 from Utahns. Likewise, through the first half of this year, BCI received 32,205 out-of-state applications, compared with 10,324 in-state.
Typically, more than 97 percent of the applicants are approved.
All told, nearly 60 percent of the more than 380,000 concealed weapons permits in circulation are held by people in other states.
A report by the Government Accountability Office last month showed that no other state comes close to that rate. A third of Maine permits are issued to out-of-state residents, but there are only 6,000 in circulation. And about one in nine Florida permits is held by a non-resident.
Jason Chapman, who heads the program, said anyone who takes a course is asked to fill out a survey at the end and, in instances where instructors get bad reviews, the investigators have gone in and audited the classes.
"We do covert inspections," he said. "We go in and sign up with a person’s course and go through their course and if it’s not up to the standards" a license can be revoked, Chapman said.
Since 2009, BCI has revoked the licenses of five out-of-state instructors for "rubber-stamping" weapons permits, including two this year. Five others were issued warnings in 2012.
"They don’t have the manpower to enforce in all 50 states, to enforce all these thousands of classes that are going on," said Aposhian, who added that the problem is not even actual rubber-stamping of permits.
"It’s the perception, the perception from out-of-state legislators, out-of-state bureaucrats, that the Utah permits that their [residents] receive are not being administered or the classes for it are not being taught appropriately."
Once a state cancels its reciprocity agreement, it’s very difficult to win it back.Next Page >
Copyright 2014 The Salt Lake Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.