This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2012, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.
The manhunt for a couple suspected in a violent carjacking linked to a double murder in Mount Pleasant swept from central Utah to the Nevada desert Monday with federal marshals, scores of police agencies and air patrols employed in the chase.
Back in sleepy Mount Pleasant, residents remain gripped by fear and disbelief after a couple who worked in the LDS Temple in Manti were discovered on New Year's Eve gunned down in their own home.
"It's just devastating," said neighbor Coleen Oltrogge, who described the victims Leroy and Dorotha Fullwood, 70 and 69 as wonderful people "who seemed young in their thoughts and actions."
"For all of us who are retired it could have been anybody," added Oltrogge, who also serves on the City Council. "We have such a neat, loving town. You just can't expect something like that to happen."
Police say there is no evidence the two killers are in Utah and that the Fullwood home backed against sagebrush and mountains on the east edge of town seemed to be a random target.
The pursuit is focused outside West Wendover, where police say an early carjacking Saturday in a casino parking lot escalated after the attackers shot a 35-year-old West Wendover woman in the head as she tried to escape. The woman, who is in a Salt Lake City hospital, was upgraded from critical condition Monday and is expected to make a full recovery, according to West Wendover police Sgt. David Wiskerchen.
Police found the car abandoned in Wells, Nev., where the couple allegedly stole a Volkswagen Jetta, then eluded troopers using dirt roads. A credit card receipt that belonged to the Fullwoods which was found in the first car brought police to the Mount Pleasant home at 399 S. 600 East.
"It is kind of on the outskirts of town and probably just an opportunity that came up," said Mount Pleasant Police Chief Jim Wilberg. "No real reason that they chose that home."
Wilberg says the quiet community's first murder in four years has rattled residents. "It's unsettling," he said, noting no details of the crime will be released until the investigation is wrapped. "We're getting a lot of calls now that people are hearing a noise in their house. People are nervous here."
One resident, who has lived in the town of 3,200 for 45 years, was too fearful to give her name.
"People are in shock," she said, "and wondering who would do something like that."
The woman said the couple have three adult children, including a daughter who lives in Mount Pleasant. "She's in shock," the woman said. "In a small area like this, you just never expect it."
Contacted Monday, many neighbors declined to talk about the double murder.
Oltrogge says she and her husband thought they heard a gunshot in the area about 4:30 p.m. on Thursday.
"There's so many deer here," she said, "you just think it's somebody shooting."
She noted the Fullwoods regularly left their garage door open, but given the "trusting" town, that didn't seem unusual.
"They were pretty tough people," Oltrogge said. "I can't imagine either one of them just sitting there letting people do anything."
Residents say the victims moved from West Jordan to Mount Pleasant roughly seven years ago to retire. Dorotha Fullwood is a former teacher, neighbors say, who taught relief society. Leroy was a retired hair stylist. Both volunteered at the Manti Temple and were regular churchgoers.
"We would see them every week at the ward," Oltrogge added. "It's just unbelievable. They lived in a modest home in a quiet neighborhood. They were friendly and warm."
A surveillance video from a Nevada convenience store captured the only image police have of the male gunman. He is Caucasian, young to-middle-aged, wearing dark clothes and a white baseball cap.
After the carjacking early Saturday, police say the Jetta in Wells was idling in a Super 8 motel parking lot when it was stolen. A high-speed chase raced west then east on Interstate 80 reaching speeds of 100 mph. According to the Nevada Highway Patrol, the couple drove around a spike strip planted by troopers, then turned south into a ranch near Oasis, Nev. On winding dirt roads, the assailants were able to elude troopers and two police airplanes.
"We have not given up the hunt for these people," said Wiskerchen. "The hunt still continues."
And in Mount Pleasant, so does the fear.
"There's so many retired people here who have moved here in the last couple years," Oltrogge said, her voice quavering. "It's scary for all of us."
Elizabeth Neff contributed to this report.
Utah slayings total slightly higher in 2011
The grisly discovery on New Year's eve of the double killing in Mount Pleasant brought the total number of homicides in 2011 to 53 a slight uptick from previous years' totals. View an interactive map of homicide locations at http://tinyurl.com/88e7lo6