More charges expected in Pilot Flying J fraud case
Nashville, Tenn. • Sudden guilty pleas by a pair of mid-level executives show the investigation into the truck stop chain controlled by the family of Tennessee's governor and the Cleveland Browns' owner is picking up steam, with prosecutors likely setting their sights on higher-ups at the company, experts say.
The guilty pleas entered Wednesday were the first stemming from a two-year investigation of a rebate program at Pilot Flying J, the company controlled by the family of Gov. Bill Haslam and Browns owner Jimmy Haslam. The charges were filed weeks after a raid of the company's Knoxville headquarters and other locations. The fruits of that raid, along with secret recordings and at least three key cooperating witnesses, point to more charges to come.
"The government is not going to offer what appears to be attractive plea bargains to people unless they fully intend to prosecute perhaps the company or perhaps higher-ups in the company," said Nashville attorney David Raybin, who is not involved in the case. "These two people are not their ultimate targets. The targets are the company and the higher-ups at the company."
Court documents don't make clear exactly which executives or how high-ranking they were may have known about the alleged fraud. But the two who pleaded guilty appear to be key players in terms of knowledge and information and could prove valuable witnesses, Raybin said.
One former federal prosecutor said the government can offer powerful incentives to get employees in a corporate fraud case to implicate their co-workers.
"Usually people lower-level have information, and in my experience the government is going to want that information to see whether they can go up the chain," said Ty Howard, who is a former assistant U.S. attorney in Nashville who now defends people accused of white-collar crimes. He is not involved in the Pilot Flying J case.
Employees implicating their superiors is not unheard of. Earlier this year, a longtime subordinate implicated former Massey Energy CEO Don Blankenship in the case of a mine explosion that killed 29 miners in West Virginia. David C. Hughart, the former president of Massey's White Buck Coal Co., said Blankenship ordered his employees to warn miners of surprise federal inspections.
The subordinate pleaded guilty to two conspiracy charges, but an attorney for Blankenship has denied his client did anything wrong. Blankenship has not been charged.
Court documents say sales employees were trained on how to defraud trucking companies of discounts and rebates owed to them by being loyal customers of Pilot Flying J.
Court papers outlining the plea deals say regional sales director Arnold Ralenkotter and regional accounts representative Ashley Smith Judd the employees who pleaded guilty were part of the conspiracy to boost profits and pad commissions.
Pilot Flying J, the country's largest diesel retailer with annual revenues of $31 billion, was founded by the Haslams' father at Pilot Travel Centers. Pilot later acquired 250 travel centers from Utah-based rival Flying J, and took on the Pilot Flying J name. Forbes listed Pilot Flying J as the 6th-largest privately owned company in America.
Jimmy Haslam has denied any wrongdoing and has suspended several members of the sales team, but he has declined to identify exactly who has been suspended. An affidavit unsealed last month shows that a Pilot employee was secretly recorded saying Jimmy Haslam knew what sales people were doing.
The company has launched its own internal investigation, and Jimmy Haslam has said that the review suggested about 5 percent of the company's customers received less rebate money because of manual adjustments by Pilot employees.
A spokesman for the company said the guilty pleas were "disappointing" but not surprising given what Pilot's own internal investigation has revealed.
"We want to assure our customers that we are taking every step to correct any wrongdoing that has occurred and to make certain that it does not happen again," Pilot Flying J spokesman Tom Ingram said in a statement.
Jimmy Haslam's brother, Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam, has no role in running the company but has a significant financial stake in the business. He has insisted he has "faith and confidence" in his brother's ability to deal with the situation.
Court documents in Ralenkotter's and Judd's cases show that fraud was well-known among sales staff and that Pilot's national account sales director taught employees how to defraud trucking companies out of rebate money without getting caught.
Court records say it was often difficult for trucking companies to track how much money they were entitled to in Pilot rebates and discounts because there were so many variables in the company's diesel price discount program.
Documents indicate people both higher and lower than Ralenkotter were aware of the fraud. Ralenkotter even threatened to take a customer account away from a subordinate if the worker did not go along with the deception, court documents say.
Raybin, the outside attorney, said the general rule is that the first person to make a deal with the prosecutor is the first to get out of jail. By dividing and conquering, prosecutors can move up the chain by using information given by the two employees who pleaded guilty to get others, he said.
An affidavit released in April showed that the FBI and the Internal Revenue Service have been investigating the company for about two years, and that they had secret recordings of company officials discussing the rebate scheme.
However, Howard cautioned that bosses are not necessarily complicit in crimes committed by lower-level employees.
"Even in a corporate fraud context, you could certainly have a rogue employee who committed some crime but the higher-ups are not criminally culpable," he said.
See more about comments here.