Tax cuts for business caught in tug-of-war
Washington • Senate leaders of both parties belittled each other's tax cutting plans Tuesday as Democrats tried advancing legislation that would lower levies for companies that hire new workers, give raises or buy major new equipment this year.
With neither party eager to let the other claim campaign-season victories, the ultimate fate of the legislation seemed dubious. Even so, Democrats viewed the measure which would cost $29 billion over the next decade as a way to show voters some of their ideas for pumping life into the economy.
"Their approach is completely different than ours," said Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev. "Congressional Republicans want to lavish huge across-the-board tax breaks on billionaire hedge fund managers and people like mega-rich celebrities like Donald Trump."
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., aimed his fire at President Barack Obama, who prodded Congress on Monday to extend wide-ranging tax cuts scheduled to expire in January for most taxpayers but let them expire for households making more than $250,000 annually. Democrats say the rich should contribute to deficit reduction, but Republicans say the higher taxes would affect many business owners and make it harder for them to create jobs.
"The president has a nightmarish economic record, a nightmarish economic record," McConnell said. "By demanding higher taxes on the few, he's trying to distract from it."
Debate began after the Senate voted 80-14 to start considering the legislation. Republicans who favor deeper, wider-ranging tax cuts considered blocking the measure with procedural moves but decided to let debate begin and broadcast their own views on tax cuts by offering amendments of their own.
Among those ready to offer amendments was Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, who was proposing to extend expiring tax cuts for a year for all taxpayers, including the wealthiest.
House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, plans a vote in his chamber in a few weeks on a similar measure, which Republicans argue would give Congress time to work on overhauling the tax code and avert deep automatic spending cuts that take effect in January unless lawmakers head them off.
Senate Democrats' legislation would grant tax credits which are subtracted from a company's tax bill equal to 10 percent of the amount its 2012 payroll exceeds the salaries it paid in 2011. The maximum credit would be $500,000, a figure that would disproportionately help smaller businesses.
It would also let companies that buy major new property in 2012, such as machinery, deduct the entire cost of the purchase this year under so-called bonus depreciation rules instead of being able to deduct only half the amount.
In a written statement, the White House said it strongly backs the legislation, which it contends would provide tax breaks to nearly 2 million companies that hire workers or boost wages. Obama had included tax credits for small businesses in the "to-do" list he proposed for Congress in May.
"By providing targeted tax relief to the businesses that are expanding their workforce and making new investments in capital, S. 2237 will help spur economic growth and job creation and strengthen the recovery," the statement said, using the measure's formal bill number.
In an election year in which the slumping economy gives Obama and the Senate's majority Democrats little to boast about, the proposal lets Democrats take the offensive on the tax issue, while asserting they are trying to encourage job creation. The bill was reaching the floor days after the latest gloomy Labor Department report that a scant 80,000 jobs were created last month, leaving the unemployment rate at a rugged 8.2 percent.
"This tax cut is by no means a cure-all, but it could be a difference-maker for small firms on the fence about adding payroll," said Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. "After last month's sluggish jobs numbers, we may be on the verge of a rare moment of agreement on how to help the economy."
Republicans want all the expiring tax cuts to be renewed and have opposed Democratic efforts to omit the highest earners, saying that would hurt businesses.
Reid is likely to hold a Senate vote in July on Obama's proposal to renew the expiring tax reductions for all but those earning more than $250,000.
The legislation contrasts with a $46 billion measure Republicans pushed through the House in April granting 20 percent tax deductions to all businesses with fewer than 500 employees more than 99 percent of the nation's companies. It drew a veto threat from Obama and has gone nowhere in the Senate.
McConnell praised such measures on Tuesday, saying, "Let's focus on the kind of pro-growth jobs proposals the Republican-led House has already passed."
Both measures were unpaid for, meaning that if enacted, their price tags would make federal deficits bigger.
Both parties support the tax breaks for equipment purchase, though critics have questioned their job-creation potential because they say they would cut taxes for companies that would have bought items anyway.
See more about comments here.