Mobile edition | Switch to full site | 33°Partly Cloudy

NBA voters swing, miss on most All-Star Game starters

Steve Luhm

By Steve Luhm

The Salt Lake Tribune

First published Jan 25 2014 05:07PM
Updated Jan 25, 2014 11:41PM

Baseball players who hit .400 are Hall of Famers.

All-Star voters who hit .400 should go back and try it again.

The Eastern and Western Conference starters for the NBA All-Star game were announced Thursday night and the group of 10 players included six who I would not have backed with my vote.

All are worthy, of course. All are great players.

But I would have voted differently.

Let’s start with the players who were accurately selected by the voters: LeBron James and Paul George in the East and Kevin Durant and Stephen Curry in the West.


They are this year’s Fab Four.

The Beatles in sneakers.

Beyond James and George, the fans voted Carmelo Anthony, Dwyane Wade and Kyrie Irving into the Eastern Conference’s starting lineup.


Despite Wade’s outstanding play for the two-time defending champion Heat, Anthony’s brilliant 62-point performance Friday night at Madison Square Garden and Irving’s emergence as one of the game’s most dynamic young stars, I had it differently.

I would have voted for Indiana’s Roy Hibbert instead of Anthony and point guards John Wall and Kyle Lowry instead of Wade and Irving.

Hibbert is being penalized for the goofy new voting system that eliminates center as a single position and, instead, lumps everybody together as "frontcourt" players.

This is silly.

Do baseball fans vote for "infielders" instead of position players? Does the NFL pick "secondary" players instead of cornerbacks and safeties?

It was a bad idea — one incoming commissioner Adam Silver needs to correct next year — which also played a role in the Western Conference voting.

Whether you like the way he has operated the last couple of years or not, Houston center Dwight Howard is having an All-Star season with the Rockets. He deserves to start for the Western Conference instead of Griffin or Love.

Rockets general manager Daryl Morey thinks so, too.

On Twitter, he said, "NBA all-star voting process set up well for Iowa high school girls basketball. Offense only & only guards and forwards."

Later, Morey added, "It’s a house election right now w/centers gerrymandered out."

Nobody should argue with Morey, although my biggest problem with the voting in the West involves Bryant and Portland’s LaMarcus Aldridge.

Kobe, of course, has been injured for all but six games this season.

As a revered veteran and one of the game’s all-time great players, he received nearly 890,000 votes for what he’s done in the past. But that’s a disservice to guards like James Harden, Tony Parker, Damian Lillard and even the currently-injured Chris Paul.

Among "frontcourt" players in the West, Aldridge was super-snubbed.

He averages 24.7 points and 11.6 points for Portland, which is 32-11 after being picked to miss the playoffs by almost everyone in the preseason.

While voting Love and Griffin as starters isn’t nearly as egregious as picking role-player Laker A.C. Green over Karl Malone in 1990, it was a defeat for deserving, small-market player who should finish among the top-five in this year’s MVP voting.

Latest in Sports
blog comments powered by Disqus