Salt Lake City’s mega-theater: boon or boondoggle? | The Salt Lake Tribune
Salt Lake Tribune
Weekly Ad Specials
Get breaking news alerts via email

Click here to manage your alerts
image
(The Associated Press) file photo Andrew Rannells, center, performs with an ensemble cast in "The Book of Mormon." The musical will be opening in denver four months earlier than had previously been announced.
Salt Lake City’s mega-theater: boon or boondoggle?

Art imitates life, the saying goes. In rare cases, it also imitates politics.

Salt Lake Acting Company’s 2011 musical satire, “Saturday’s Voyeur,” turned inward — and onto the stage of the most contentious topic to hit Utah theater in years: Salt Lake City Mayor Ralph Becker’s proposed $100 million, 2,500-seat, “Broadway-style” theater.

The shot comes when Becker, wearing a bicycle helmet and played “smugly calm and slim” by Alexis Baigue, crunches numbers with the play’s calculator-wielding “Bimbo.”

“Do you really think it’s feasible for people to give 10 percent of their income to your pet project?” she asks.

“Hey, the [LDS] Church has been getting away with it for more than 150 years,” the mayor answers.

Those lines draw snorts galore. Behind the curtain, however, Utah’s theater community isn’t laughing. Nor are some taxpaying skeptics who wonder why Becker seems bent on tossing that kind of money at such a large, even lavish, project.

“It feels as though this is an attempt by well-meaning leaders to keep up with neighboring cities such as Phoenix or Denver,” says Royce Van Tassell, vice president of the Utah Taxpayers Association, who notes the price could swell by an additional $10 million in interest between the theater’s planned 2013 construction and 2015, when the city’s funding mechanisms would become available.

The proposal brings to the fore myriad questions, including whether other venues would survive the introduction of a Utah Performing Arts Center (UPAC) on Main Street, whether audiences here would embrace a wider array of traveling Broadway productions and whether such shows would drive up interest in the arts as a whole.

Story continues below

Those at the helm of established arts organizations worry that city officials have overplayed the power of the arts as an economic tool, especially during a time when funds for all arts organizations come at a premium.

“This may be inevitable and is something that should be considered,” says Melia Tourangeau, CEO of Utah Symphony | Utah Opera. “But regardless of what’s said about it being a self-sustaining venue, I’m highly skeptical of that being the case.”

“What is the need?” » It’s not the first time Becker has drawn controversy over a proposal to redraw downtown’s map. After public outcry, the mayor opted to place a planned $125 million Public Safety Building just east of his first choice, Library Square.

By contrast, he seems resolved to see a Broadway-style playhouse at or near 135 S. Main. If all goes as planned, the building would bear the imprint of Moshe Safdie, the same architect who designed downtown’s showcase library. Part of his motivation, Becker says, is driven by the desire to link a long-dormant part of Main with the LDS Church’s $2 billion City Creek Center to the north and Gallivan Center and office towers to the south.

“We do not have a catalyst for blocks in between,” Becker says. “This will pull parts of the city together and add to our proud tradition of supporting the arts.”

The effort is also something of a Becker family affair — with the 2008 enlistment of brother Bill Becker, a Tony-award-winning producer, to help guide the project.

“The last thing I want to see — and I’ve told this to my brother — is to go into a project that everyone’s going to call a white elephant five years later,” Bill Becker says. “That’s the last kind of legacy I want.”

Next Page »
Reader comments on sltrib.com are the opinions of the writer, not The Salt Lake Tribune. We will delete comments containing obscenities, personal attacks and inappropriate or offensive remarks. Flagrant or repeat violators will be banned. If you see an objectionable comment, click the red "Flag" link below it. See more about comments here. What are those badges some users have next to their names?

Stage » Becker sees it playing a vital role in a downtown revival, but critics fear an unhappy ending.

Photos
(Boneau/Bryan-Brown  |  The Associated Press)  
"The Book of Mormon" at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre in New York. The show is coming to Denver in August.
(The Associated Press)   file photo

Andrew Rannells, center, performs with an ensemble cast in "The Book of Mormon." The musical will be opening in denver four months earlier than had previously been announced.
Les Misérables by Cameron Mackintosh, opening night November 28 2010, Paper Mill Playhouse, 22 Brookside Dr., Millburn New Jersey with LAWRENCE CLAYTON (Jean Valjean) ANDREW VARELA (Javert) MICHAEL KOSTROFF (Thénardier) SHAWNA M. HAMIC (Mme. Thénardier) BETSY MORGAN (Fantine) JEREMY HAYS (Enjolras) CHASTEN HARMON (Éponine) JUSTINE SCOTT BROWN (Marius) JENNY LATIMER (Cosette) RON SHARPE (Jean Valjean Alternate)The Company of the New 25th Anniversary of "Les Misérables" will be at Capitol Theatre May 25-June 5.
(File photo | The Salt Lake Tribune)  


Salt Lake City Mayor Ralph Becker has proposed a $100 million, 2,500-seat, “Broadway-style” theater.
Renovation of Capital Theatre on Jan. 29, 1979.
(File photo | The Salt Lake Tribune)  
Salt Lake Capitol Theatre.
A huge chandelier from "Phantom of the Opera" rests on the stage of the Capitol Theatre in Salt Lake City in this 2004 Tribune  photo.
(File photo | The Salt Lake Tribune)  
Salt Lake Capitol Theatre.
Hundreds wait in line outside the Capitol Theatre in Salt Lake City to buy tickets for the show "Wicked" in this 2008 Tribune  photo.
Hundreds wait in line outside the Capitol Theatre in Salt Lake City to buy tickets for the show "Wicked" in this 2008 Tribune  photo.
Crews set up the stage at the Capitol Theatre in Salt Lake City for the Broadway sensation "Wicked" in this 2009 Tribune  photo.
Kingsbury Hall is being remodeled this summer to stagger the seating and increase the slope so sightlines are better.
Courtesy image
The proposed Utah Performing Arts Center, which could resemble the Durham Performing Arts Center in North Carolina pictured here, isn't supported by a group of professional Utah playwrights. The president and co-founder of West Valley City's Hale Centre Theatre, meanwhile, has praised the prospect of a $100 million, 2,500-seat "Broadway-style" theater in downtown Salt Lake City.
Courtesy image
The proposed Utah Performing Arts Center, which could resemble the Durham Performing Arts Center in North Carolina pictured here, isn't supported by a group of prominent Utah playwrights. The president and co-founder of West Valley City's Hale Centre Theatre, meanwhile, has praised the prospect of a $100 million, 2,500-seat "Broadway-style" theater in downtown Salt Lake City.
Salt Lake Acting Company's "Saturday's Voyeur" 2011, which takes judicious stabs at Salt Lake City Mayor Ralph Becker's proposed downtown Broadway-style theater, adds an extra week to its run, through Sept. 11. 
Courtesy Thom Gourley
Salt Lake Acting Company takes on Mayor Becker and his proposed Utah Performing Arts Center: (from left) actors Kent Harrison Hayes as Paul Revere, Alexis Baigue as the mayor, Jacob Johnson as Donald Trump and Victoria Elena Nones as the calculator-wielding 'bimbo.'
Courtesy Thom Gourley
Salt Lake Acting Company takes on Mayor Becker and his proposed Utah Performing Arts Center: (from left) actors Kent Harrison Hayes as Paul Revere, Alexis Baigue as the mayor, Victoria Elena Nones as the calculator-wielding 'bimbo' and Jacob Johnson as Donald Trump.
Courtesy Thom Gourley
(Tribune file photo)  
"None of the arguments for this theater I’ve heard address the central question. That is, ‘Really, what is the need for this?’” asks Chris Lino, managing director, Pioneer Theatre Company.
Les Misérables by Cameron Mackintosh, opening night November 28 2010, Paper Mill Playhouse, 22 Brookside Dr., Millburn New Jersey with LAWRENCE CLAYTON (Jean Valjean) ANDREW VARELA (Javert) MICHAEL KOSTROFF (Thénardier) SHAWNA M. HAMIC (Mme. Thénardier) BETSY MORGAN (Fantine) JEREMY HAYS (Enjolras) CHASTEN HARMON (Éponine) JUSTINE SCOTT BROWN (Marius) JENNY LATIMER (Cosette) RON SHARPE (Jean Valjean Alternate)The Company of the New 25th Anniversary of "Les Misérables" will be at Capitol Theatre May 25-June 5.
Les Misérables by Cameron Mackintosh, opening night November 28 2010, Paper Mill Playhouse, 22 Brookside Dr., Millburn New Jersey with LAWRENCE CLAYTON (Jean Valjean) ANDREW VARELA (Javert) MICHAEL KOSTROFF (Thénardier) SHAWNA M. HAMIC (Mme. Thénardier) BETSY MORGAN (Fantine) JEREMY HAYS (Enjolras) CHASTEN HARMON (Éponine) JUSTINE SCOTT BROWN (Marius) JENNY LATIMER (Cosette) RON SHARPE (Jean Valjean Alternate)The Company of the New 25th Anniversary of "Les Misérables" will be at Capitol Theatre May 25-June 5.
Photo courtesy MagicSpace Entertainment
Orem native Jenny Latimer plays Cosette alongside Justin Scott Brown, who plays Marius, in the 25th-anniversary production of "Les Misérables." The epic musical runs until June 5 at Capitol Theatre.
(Chris Detrick  |  The Salt Lake Tribune)  
"We’ve done our own analysis and feel strongly that Kingsbury Hall could lose as much as $400,000 annually from competing rentals and lost ticket sales,” says Greg Geilmann, executive director, Kingsbury Hall.
( Matt Merton, and Bryan Loft,  work on the set of the Phantom of the Opera at the Hale Center Theatre,  Wednesday, February 18,  2009  Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune)
Actors Katie Rose Clarke as Glinda and Donna Vivino as Elphaba perform in Wicked, The Musical.
Actors Donna Vivino as Elphaba, Myra Lucretia Taylor as Madame Morrible and Katie Rose Clarke as Glinda perform in "Wicked, The Musical."
“We’ve been looking for common ground forever between the gentile, liberal community of Salt Lake City and the devout, Republican Mormons of south Salt Lake Valley, and we’ve found it. It’s musical comedy,” says Joe Hatch, former Salt Lake County councilman.
At a glance

Tale of two venues, Durham, N.C., and Salt Lake City

A key part of downtown sagged. You wouldn’t think its demographics, largely conservative with incomes nowhere near East or West Coast levels, would support touring Broadway productions. And yet, when the Durham Performing Arts Center cut its opening ribbon in 2008, the 2,712-seat venue went on to prove the naysayers wrong.

So is the idea of Salt Lake City embracing a similar project really so wild-eyed?

If the Durham theater is any indication, the answer could be a qualified “not at all.”

“A lot of people were skeptical,” says Aaron Greenwald, promoter for Duke Performances at nearby Duke University. “Now I think even those who run the venue would never have sanely projected the success they’ve had.”

Greenwald says promoters in North Carolina’s tri-city area of Raleigh, Durham and Chapel Hill were also surprised at how well people responded to the steep ticket prices, which climbed as high as $120.

“We learned the community would rather be in a 2,500-plus seat venue and pay $80 to $100,” he says, “than be in a hockey arena and pay less.”

Ted Conner, vice president of economic development for the Durham Chamber of Commerce, says maintaining a private operator and promoter for the venue was crucial to its success. Durham owns the $48 million center, contracting with New York City’s for-profit Nederlander Producing Company of America to book shows. The city shares in the profits, Conner says, and received a $400,000 check after the venue’s first year.

Not everyone ended up a winner. Raleigh’s Memorial Hall, Greenwald says, had to “seriously retrench” its own series of traveling Broadway productions.

“They’ve eaten into everyone’s ticket sales to some extent, some more than others,” he says. “But in some ways it’s foolish to complain about, because no one’s stealing anything from anyone. They [DPAC officials] are just doing their job of selling the best shows possible in the most seats possible at the best price possible.”

Ben Fulton

Latest in Utah News

 
Jobs
Shopping
 
Missing your paper? Need to place your paper on vacation hold? For this and any other subscription related needs, click here or call 801.204.6100.
Affiliates and Partners
Now Salt LakeHolmes HomesUtah Real EstateMovers
McDougal Funeral HomesLocal MoversWise Food StorageMoving Companies
MediaOne Real EstateClark PlanetariumLDS TravelUtah Rides
Hanks & Mortensen, P.C.Salt Lake Valley Buick GMCTeleperformanceReal Salt Lake
Wasatch WomanUtah Business MagazineBathroom VanitiesIn This Week
Discovery GatewayCustom Gaming ComputersUtahsRight.comUtah Utes
Willey HondaUtah CarsMediaOne of UtahCole Holland Training Center