Louisiana recently made Utah’s restriction on access to concealed-carry permit information look benign by comparison.
The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press reported that Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal signed two bills into law that make it a crime to disclose the name or address of a concealed gun permit holder. Those who do face six months in jail and or a fine of up to $1,000.
In contrast, Utah’s Government Records Access and Management Act labels concealed-carry permit information as protected information, meaning the state Bureau of Criminal Identification cannot release the information, nor even confirm if someone has a permit or has lost one.
The only penalty it prescribes is for state workers who disclose such information, and it is a class A misdemeanor. But there is no penalty if, for example, one were to point out, through other sources, that Sens. Howard A. Stephenson, R-Draper, and Mark Madsen, R-Eagle Mountain, and Rep. Curt Oda, R-Clearfield, all carry concealed weapons.
But Louisiana’s laws, passed in response to a New York newspaper’s publication of a list of handgun-permit holders, only carves out an exemption for reporting that a permit was revoked after its holder was convicted of a gun-related felony.
"There are limitations on First Amendment rights," said Republican state Rep. Jeff Thompson, the bills’ sponsor. "You have to balance those."
But media advocates say the move amounts to censorship by punishing journalists for publishing information they obtained from other sources.
"The Second Amendment relates to your right to own firearms," Louisiana media lawyer Loretta Mince said. "It doesn’t have anything to do with whether other people are permitted to know that you own firearms."
|1.||Convicted killer Martin MacNeill survives jail suicide attempt|
|2.||Kragthorpe: Goalpost gets in way of RSL’s bid for MLS Cup (with video)|
|3.||Aron Ralston, who cut off arm to escape Utah canyon, jailed in Denver|
|4.||MLS Cup: Real Salt Lake falls on PKs (with video)|
|5.||Witness to guide Idaho search for plane|
|6.||Guilt, pain, help and hope — when Mormon missionaries come home early|
|7.||Permits for concealed guns: Utah hits 500K|
|8.||I-15 reopens for motorists stranded near St. George|
|9.||Utah State football: Aggies fall bitterly short against Fresno State|
|10.||Huntsman jokes about his ‘secret’ run for president|