For Alfonso Moya-Breton, the federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) may be his ticket to getting out of prison sooner.
As The Salt Lake Tribune’s Brooke Adams reported, the U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that U.S. District Judge Tena Campbell was wrong when she refused to consider Moya-Breton’s contention that his attorney didn’t tell him about a plea deal that could have shaved six years off his sentences for drug offenses.
Moya-Breton was able to find the evidence using FOIA as part of his effort to appeal his 30-year prison sentence.
Moya-Breton said his attorney, Ed Brass, had told him that there was no offer of a plea agreement, but the letter from Assistant U.S. Attorney Adam Elggren to Brass stated that Moya-Breton’s sentence would be reduced if he would "accept responsibility."
Campbell had ruled the letter was irrelevant because the issue had already been addressed in previous appeals, but the appellate court reversed her ruling.
"Unfortunately, the district court did not distinguish the motion’s fraud allegation … from its other assertions," the appeals court said. "That is a problem."
|1.||Secret recording: Mark Shurtleff offers $2 million to silence critic|
|2.||Blood found on teen arrested in deaths of 2 adopted brothers|
|3.||Alleged cop-killer Matthew Stewart hangs self in jail cell|
|4.||First time ever, University of Utah student president impeached|
|5.||Utah painter McNaughton’s latest work, ‘Liberalism is a Disease’|
|6.||Planes, trains and orangutans: 12 distinctly Utah things to do this summer|
|7.||Movie review: ‘Hangover Part III’ more violent, less funny|
|8.||Police raid live sex show in Syracuse, arrest six|
|9.||Movie review: Tough times on the farm in ‘At Any Price’|
|10.||Movie review: ‘Fast & Furious 6’ throws coherence out window|