"He believed that because he did not hold her down while she was fighting … it wasn’t rape."
These words appeared in a forcible sodomy charge this week in Cedar City.
If not for the suspect’s alleged confession to not knowing what rape is, this would seem an unlikely case for charges. The vast majority of rape cases never get prosecuted, and that truth extends to Utah. As prosecutors have said again and again, the burden of proof in rape is hard to meet.
Looking at the details in the police statement, that burden might have been especially heavy in this Iron County case. It’s is a husband-wife case. Wife says she was abusing drugs, and husband would rape her while she was unconscious. Five years ago.
Proof beyond a reasonable doubt could be considered a long shot in front of a jury in a typical he-said-she-said scenario.
Instead, police claim, the suspect turned it into a he-and-she-both-said scenario. According to charges, the husband told police about a time when "she lost consciousness … he continued having sex with her and at one point she regained consciousness and began screaming." He also "described multiple incidents where [his wife] was ‘in and out’ of consciousness and did not recall having sex with him the next day," police wrote.
But, he allegedly pointed out, he didn’t hold her down when she fought, so he didn’t think it was rape.
|1.||Fall TV preview: The best and worst of fall TV|
|2.||Movie review: ‘Maze Runner’ sends viewers going in circles|
|3.||Lawmaker: All Utah restaurants should have a ‘Zion Curtain’|
|4.||Ordain Women will take its message local to Mormon congregations|
|5.||MLS says Chivas USA might not play in 2015|
|6.||Utah rally: Same-sex marriage would hurt children|
|7.||Darrien Hunt : A life cut short mourned by family, friends|
|8.||Feds charge five Utahns in Recapture Canyon protest ride|
|9.||BYU football: QB Taysom Hill in no rush to change his game|
|10.||Prep phenom Frank Jackson's commitment to BYU basketball still strong, father says|