In 2004, lawmaker LaVar Christensen — a Republican who currently represents Draper in the Utah Legislature — sponsored the "joint resolution on marriage," which put Amendment 3 on that November’s ballot. Voters subsequently approved the amendment, which banned same-sex marriage and is currently the subject of a lawsuit in Utah’s federal court.
In a note included with the proposal, the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel made this prescient observation:
"In Zablocki v. Redhail, 434 U.S. 374 (1978), the United States Supreme Court concluded that the right to marry ‘is of fundamental importance,’ requiring ‘critical examination’ of the state’s interest in creating a classification that interferes with that right."
"The Court has not specifically decided whether a state’s interest is sufficiently compelling to justify restricting the right to marry to a man and a woman. Other cases could be argued by analogy to suggest that restricting the right to marry to a man and a woman violates federal due process or equal protection provisions."
"If the amendment to the Utah Constitution proposed by this joint resolution is approved by voters and becomes part of the Utah Constitution, it may be susceptible to challenge under the federal due process or equal protection grounds. Relevant case law is inconclusive, and how a court would ultimately decide the constitutionality of the provision under the United States Constitution in the context of a specific lawsuit is difficult to predict."
|1.||Waterless subdivision in Saratoga Springs spurs criminal charges|
|2.||BYU football: Cougars blow lead in 42-35 loss to Nevada (with video)|
|3.||Utah Jazz: Lakers beat Jazz as fringe players fight for roster spots|
|4.||BYU football: Plenty of blame to go around for Cougars’ collapse (with video)|
|5.||Federal sage-grouse workshop’s access criticized|
|6.||Kirby: Meet the Mormons: The prequel|
|7.||BYU football: Coaches say Cougars most deserving of power conference admission|
|8.||New Utah report cards: Too complex to hand to parents|
|9.||Utah football: Utes rise to No. 19 in AP, coaches polls|
|10.||Market turmoil: A gift for mortgage refinancers?|