Defenders of Christmas should consider that generic holiday phrases not only acknowledge the multicultural nature of America but respect the sacredness of the names of religious celebrations. The proposal of Sen. Chris Buttars, R-West Jordan, to encourage broader use of "Christmas" by retail outlets ("Buttars vs. 'war on Christmas,'" Tribune, Dec. 2) would only further cheapen Christmas with more commercialism and stronger associations with "Blowout sale," "50% off, while they last" and "Ho, ho, ho! Everything must go." Would Buttars also recommend that stores use pictures of baby Jesus for product endorsements?

If Buttars wishes to protect Christmas, he should reserve phrases like "Merry Christmas" for reverent, sincere sharing among Christians, rather than converting them into general secular greetings for mall advertisements.

Supporters of superficial proposals like this need to focus on more pressing issues and reflect on the wider, long-term consequences of legislation.

Shane Guillory

Salt Lake City