The Washington County Water Conservancy District, supplier for the rapidly growing population in and around St. George, has long been drooling over the prospect of building a 140-mile-long pipeline to carry some 28 billion gallons of water annually from Lake Powell in south-central Utah to the thirsty lawns and golf courses of Washington and Kane counties.
The Legislature kicked off the paper trail back in 2006. A major milestone will come as soon as Tuesday, when the district is expected to issue what's called a Preliminary Licensing Proposal. That's something federal officials need to sign off on before the construction can begin.
Critics of the plan rightly worry that one key thing the PLP is expected to lack is both an estimated cost — ballparked by others as $1.4 billion to $1.8 billion — and, even more importantly, a means for raising the money.
The pipeline, if it is built, would be a Utah Division of Water Resources project. The state would borrow the money, with the understanding that Washington and Kane county water customers would pay the debt, through a combination of water bills, impact fees and property taxes.
Fair enough. Except the economists warn that the districts would have to hike those rates, fees or taxes, or some combination of the three, by such exorbitant amounts that the resulting water would be practically unaffordable, stymieing the very population growth the pipeline is supposed to serve.
Well, that's one way to encourage conservation in an area that is known for its wasteful habits. But it would leave both the districts and the state on the hook for billions in debt. A debt that, between the high costs of construction and a Colorado River water supply that's likely to shrink due to climate change, could be an extremely heavy burden.
Word from the water district is that the rest of us need not worry our pretty little heads about the debt, as they've got some kind of secret plan for repaying it without more than doubling hook-up fees or raising water rates maybe 600 percent.
Now that's a trick a lot of us would like to know when we're out hunting for a mortgage or a car loan.
The Lake Powell Pipeline should not be allowed to take one more step toward reality until we see exactly what that repayment plan is.