Salt Lake Tribune
Weekly Ad Specials
Shake, rattle and roll: Quake could crumble SL County public works headquarters
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2008, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

If an earthquake strikes, Salt Lake County's cleanup crews could have to dig themselves out of their own building.

And even if the earth doesn't rumble, the rickety public-works headquarters in Midvale has reasons aplenty for employees to leave: overloaded electrical outlets, no fire-sprinkler system or alarms, a sagging roof that could collapse during a heavy snowstorm.

County Risk Manager Jeff Rowley even warned that staffers should vacate some sections immediately.

"It is just dangerous," Salt Lake County Public Works Director Linda Hamilton said Wednesday.

To dodge that threat, the County Council set aside $7.4 million this year to erect a new public-works complex - at the same site, 7125 S. 600 West - that will meet fire code and withstand a temblor.

The decision comes after an engineering analysis revealed "severe seismic deficiencies" that could cause the building to buckle during a tremor. The report warned of thin walls, overburdened rooftops and roofs with no visible connection to the cinder block beneath them.

"Even a not-very-sizable earthquake is likely to bring it down," Hamilton said.

County Mayor Peter Corroon called the building's replacement a matter of public safety. If the complex crumbled, it would threaten a critical nerve center for clearing the county's streets and removing rubble after a natural disaster.

"We want to make sure that public-works officials are ready to go and not dealing with a collapsed building of their own," he said.

The county's worries about the existing facility - first built in 1957 - range from the irritating (an inoperable women's restroom) to the life-threatening (a sagging roof that engineers describe as "600 percent overstressed").

The list goes on: an overtaxed electrical system, cramped storage space, no fire-suppression system and fire damage to roof supports.

"Continued occupancy and use of the building poses a significant threat to the occupants and the programs housed therein," wrote Rowley in an October risk assessment.

But while Rowley urged the county to vacate portions of the building, public-works officials have no plans to do so until the new facility goes up. And the mayor said he will rely on their judgment.

It's not that Hamilton doesn't want to move her staff - she does - but the public-works chief said she doesn't have the resources to do it.

"That is why we are trying to move forward so quickly on this," said April Townsend, the county's administrative-services director. "We all realize that this isn't a good situation."

Instead, the county will bide its time until August 2009, when officials plan to open the new complex.

jstettler@sltrib.com

On shaky ground

The county's public-works headquarters in Midvale is in shambles structurally. Engineers and risk managers cited the following deficiencies (to name a few):

* No fire-sprinkler system or alarms.

* Overloaded electrical circuits.

* Cramped storage space and dense occupancy.

* Inadequate supports to prevent walls from tipping or buckling during an earthquake.

* Walls that fail to meet minimum thickness requirements and do not properly connect to the roof in some locations.

* No visible connection between the roof supports and cinder-block walls in one of the complex's office additions. Engineers say the roof is sagging and "600 percent overstressed."

Source: Reaveley Engineers & Associates, Salt Lake County District Attorney's Office

Article Tools

 
Affiliates and Partners