For much of Utah's 45-day legislative session, conservatives have risen to support states' rights legislation, united in fiery opposition to a perceived over-reach of the federal government.
But on Wednesday, when state-sovereignty resolution SCR3 came up for a House vote, Rep. Brian King, D-Salt Lake City, could not resist commenting on the Legislature's mixed message.
King reminded his House colleagues of their unanimous vote on HCR13, which ensures continued receipt of $500,000 in federal funds each year to defray the costs of services in Utah's Dutch John.
"This shows our inconsistency," King said, "railing on the federal government while still trying to get every federal dollar we can."
King pointed out that Utah takes more money from the federal government than it sends and has for many years.
"Put an end to this excessive posturing," King said.
Rep. Brad Daw, R-Orem, countered that Utah should be able to keep its tax dollars and administer programs on its own.
"I'm quite convinced we could do it better without the reckless deficit spending our federal government has," Daw said.
Rep. Carl Wimmer, R-Herriman, said he was off the House floor for the Dutch John vote.
"I would have voted against it," Wimmer said, an action in line with his personal decision to vote against all federal stimulus dollars.
In related action, the House voted 65-0 to set aside state funding in a restricted account for construction of two more veterans nursing homes in the state.
Budget Chairman Ron Bigelow called HB440 a "must-pass" bill and said it sets the stage for the state to receive federal reimbursement funds for that purpose.
Wimmer and Daw were among those who voted for HB440.
