No outcry against Corroon tax plan -- so far
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2009, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

He didn't even get two dozen e-mails.

Even after proposing the first property-tax increase of his administration during the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression.

Instead, Salt Lake County Mayor Peter Corroon logged fewer than 20 letters and e-mails about his push to raise $13.4 million in property taxes to balance the county's battered 2010 budget, according to correspondence obtained through an open-records request.

It's a surprisingly sparse amount of written feedback that Corroon believes reflects constituents' satisfaction with a spending plan that combines higher taxes -- about $20 annually on a $260,000 home -- and a dramatic $142 million downsizing of government expenses.

"People understand that we did what we thought was best for the citizens," Corroon said. "They recognize we are not going to tax our way to a better economy or cut our way to a better economy. We need a balanced approach to meet the needs of our citizens."

If Corroon is correct, that broad public acceptance of a tax increase could bode well for a future gubernatorial run. While the Democrat -- in his second and, he says, final term as mayor -- has not decided whether he will seek the state's highest political office, he is considered the party's front-runner.

Although the public outcry over the 2010 budget may appear muted now, the volume may rise Tuesday, when the County Council opens the microphone to constituents before approving the spending plan, according to Alan Dayton, the former deputy to Corroon's Republican predecessor, Nancy Workman.

Meeting attendance, he argued, is a better barometer of public sentiment than e-mails. However, the mayor "is probably on the right track."

"Let's wait for the hearing," Dayton said. "But he may be right. The public doesn't have the sense that Salt Lake County is coming back to the well again and again."

The last countywide property-tax increase, he noted, happened almost a decade ago.

It's true that Corroon hasn't gone through the kind of highly publicized Truth in Taxation hearing that will happen Tuesday. But the mayor has had an opportunity for a public bruising and escaped it. Corroon rolled out his spending plan -- and talked of the proposed tax increase --in several town-hall meetings last month that attracted fewer than 20 people per session. His final gathering in Herriman was empty.

Tim Chambless, a political science professor at the University of Utah who once worked in former Salt Lake City Mayor Ted Wilson's administration, suspects the public clamor would be louder if Corroon's proposal weren't palatable to most property owners.

"We can see by the few number of e-mails that most people are not terribly upset with the fact that their property taxes may go up," Chambless said. "The fact is that most people know that you don't get something for nothing."

That said, the mayor's "in" box wasn't free of outrage or outright desperation in the weeks after announcing the proposed tax hike.

"Please don't raise taxes on property owners," one constituent pleaded. "We are not the deep pockets you think we are. Some of us are barely making it. This really stinks because you know we would rather find a way to pay [than] lose our homes."

"Stop spending," typed another. "I have to cut my programs for my kids within my family budget when times are tough, so should the government."

The mayor received two e-mails applauding his fiscal approach.

"I am so pleased that, in this time of economic downturn, there is someone in government who is proactively looking for ways to spend less and keep taxes low," a constituent wrote. "I know it is a strange concept these days, but hurray for you and the county being fiscally responsible."

While the mayor has recommended higher taxes -- a proposal backed by the Democratic-led council -- his call for deeper cuts includes reducing employee wages and benefits, leaving more than 300 positions empty, ordering steep departmental trims (some exceeding 10 percent) and closing some recreation centers on Sundays.

Still, Corroon insists a tax increase is needed to avoid crippling critical services. It's a turnabout from last summer, when the mayor went toe to toe with council Democrats and vetoed a similar, but more modest, uptick in taxes. Corroon argued for more cuts, which he says government has made.

In the correspondence to Corroon, 14 people protested his proposed tax hike. Five others argued against imposing a law-enforcement fee of $100 or more a year in unincorporated burbs such as Magna, Kearns and Millcreek to plug a shortfall in the county's municipal services fund (an account that pays for citylike services such as police patrols in those areas).

"Isn't it about time you stopped hammering us with taxes," a constituent complained.

The council largely has accepted the mayor's proposed ledger and will decide after Tuesday's hearing whether to adopt it.

Will the public prove understanding -- or even supportive -- of Corroon's strategy for surviving the economic slump? That's a question that may be answered in the empty seats, if there are any, at next week's hearing.

jstettler@sltrib.com

Talking taxes for 2010

You probably have seen the wide-lined legal ads in the paper: Salt Lake County wants to raise your taxes. Here's a look at what tax changes to expect in Utah's most-populous county:

Countywide property tax » With Salt Lake County straining under the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression, officials want to tap taxpayers for an extra $13.4 million next year to help balance the books. Property-tax bills would bounce $21 a year on a $260,000 home and $171 on a $1 million business. The tax wouldn't last forever. Unlike a traditional property tax, this one would be dedicated to paying down debts no longer covered by the county's sagging sales-tax revenues. As those debts drop off -- as $5 million will in 2011 -- so would the tax.

Judgment levy » The county has imposed a property tax every year to recoup the costs of legal settlements and tax appeals. Those taxes last for one year, then expire, generating enough money to cover judgments incurred by the county. But the County Council has grown weary of approving a new levy every year. Policymakers want a more permanent tax stream to pay off expenses that run about $2.5 million, on average, every year. The tax would cost residents of unincorporated burbs such as Magna and Millcreek about $13 annually and city dwellers about $4 a year on a $260,000 home.

Police district tax » The patrol division of the Salt Lake County Sheriff's Office will splinter from the county next year, making it a stand-alone police department with a handful of other cities. As part of the transition, the county must take the taxes it once collected for law-enforcement services and give the taxes to the new police force. The change wouldn't cost residents a dime. The county simply would move an existing property tax -- which costs residents of the unincorporated county about $6 annually on an average $242,000 home -- to the newly formed department. What's not reflected in this week's tax discussion, however, is a proposed law-enforcement fee, which could cost homeowners $100 or more a year.

Source » Salt Lake County

What people are saying

The Salt Lake Tribune obtained the following e-mails to Mayor Peter Corroon about his proposed property-tax increase.

"Now is not the time to 'pile on' considering the tough economic times we are experiencing. ... I know politicians always want to spend more money than they have available, but it's not their money.

"Cutting back is exactly what we all have to do whether we are private individuals or government (especially government). My hat is off to you. Keep up the great work and setting such a great example for the rest of our state."

"Government never has a revenue problem; it always has a spending problem. Stop spending."

"The only reasonable solution to the problem is to cut services and not raise taxes anymore. No one has to go to a recreation center on Sunday -- close them. There are many other cost-saving measures you can take rather than taxing us any more."

"I used to complain about my high taxes. Now that I know about all of the county programs, I feel the taxes are actually paying the community back. ... I really believe that if more people knew about what is offered, the more positive feelings about a raise in taxes would arise."

"Pete, I agree with you. I think you should tax, tax, tax those stupid, brain-dead taxpayers. I think you should raise taxes 10 percent, no 50 percent, no 100 percent, no 10,000 percent."

Source » Salt Lake County Mayor's Office

What's next

The Salt Lake County Council will hear from constituents Tuesday about the proposed 2010 budget and property-tax increase. The meeting begins at 6 p.m. at the Salt Lake County Government Center, 2001 S. State St.

Budget » Not many e-mails against the proposal, but a hearing looms Tuesday.
Article Tools

Enter a search phrase.

Specify a Range

From  to

 

 
Missing your paper? Need to place your paper on vacation hold? For this and any other subscription related needs, click here or call 801.204.6100.