Despite the order to halt construction Thursday morning, crews remained active at the site into the early afternoon.
In a statement sent to The Salt Lake Tribune at 5 p.m., American Preparatory Academy (APA) Chairman Brad Findlay said work was shut down at the site after the school board's order was verified.
"This is simply a misunderstanding, a communication glitch," Findlay said. "We will work to resolve it and are confident we will be back to work quickly and open on time this fall with our new high school."
Thursday's halt order was the second in a string of setbacks for the Draper charter school this week.
Third District Judge Su Chon ruled Tuesday that APA's property falls short of a nearby roadway. Its property is landlocked, relying on an easement to allow vehicle traffic to and from Lone Peak Parkway.
Since 2015, the school has been involved in a property dispute with its neighbor, Price Logistics Center Draper, with the aim of connecting the school's parking lot to a roadway on the property's south side.
APA's governing board, Utah Charter Academies, attempted to use eminent domain to condemn a 2.5-foot-wide strip blocking access to the roadway. Chon denied that action in an earlier ruling that found the unelected charter board does not qualify as a board of education with the statutory right to seize private property.
Since then, the school has purchased a home to the north and converted its driveway into an emergency access route. School representatives have said that unless the property dispute is resolved, the residential property may need to be fully converted into a point of egress and ingress for school traffic.
That plan frustrates residents such as Travis Lucero, who plans to sell his home of 11 years — likely at a loss — due to the ongoing issues over the school.
"I absolutely hate them," he said. "They're just jerks. They pushed it in there without consulting anybody."
Lucero said neighbors, around Draper's Inauguration Park, have repeatedly asked for concessions like traffic lights, fencing and speed bumps to mitigate road congestion from the school.
But APA has ignored those requests, he said, and state law exempts charter schools from many areas of municipal oversight.
"APA [traffic] blocks the entire neighborhood from getting in," he said. "They're just pretty much doing whatever they want."
Another resident, Nicoleen Richards, said she moved to the area from Seattle on Saturday. She said children are regularly dropped off in front of her home, and then walk to the school through the unfenced gap between Richards' and her neighbor's property.
"They're letting their kids go between the houses even though they're not allowed," she said. "It's a little bit annoying. But I don't know, we'll see how it goes."