The university maintains its policy over the years has remained constant.
Students with scarring or sensitive skin must get a note from a campus doctor. Non-LDS students who wear beards as part of their faith must secure approval from a chaplain. Student actors in film or theater roles requiring facial hair must get a note from the theater department.
After that, final permission comes from the honor code office.
In the past, the school made exceptions on a case-by-case basis and had no explicit protocol outlined, Jenkins said.
"Our dress and grooming standards outline that men are to be clean-shaven," Jenkins said Wednesday. "We have not changed those guidelines."
Hammad Javed, a sophomore in mechanical engineering, grew a beard at home in Pakistan months before coming to BYU, committing to keep it for life. But once he arrived on campus as one of about three dozen Muslims, the president of the university's Muslim student association was told he'd have to shave it.
"I had already signed the honor code and I knew I couldn't do anything about it," he said.
So he shaved.
Javed was featured in a New York Times article on Nov. 4.
Last fall, students wearing cardboard beards staged a protest about the university-wide rule. And national media poked into the controversy.
In recent weeks, school administrators decided to outline the conditions necessary for men to obtain the exemptions.
"We looked at where we were receiving legitimate requests," Jenkins said.
Javed's brother graduated in 2012, when the school was granting religious exemptions. But Javed says the school in subsequent semesters stopped giving students a pass based on their religion because some students misused the policy — asking a chaplain for a faith-based beard exemption simply because they wanted to sport trendy facial hair.