Obama, Ryan trade Medicare charges
THE VILLAGES, Fla. • President Barack Obama castigated the Republican presidential ticket Saturday for peddling "trickle-down snake oil" in the form of tax cuts for the rich, and both campaigns jockeyed for advantage over Medicare, a dicey subject for everyone in the game.
Speaking to seniors in Florida, GOP vice presidential hopeful Paul Ryan accused Obama of using Medicare as a "piggybank" for the president's health care law. A champion of changing Medicare, Ryan spoke passionately in defense of the program, introducing his mother to voters to drive home the point that the health program "was there for our family" and "we have to keep that guarantee."
Ryan tried to strike a careful balance on the subject in his speech at a sprawling retirement community. Mitt Romney and his running mate have come under withering criticism from Obama for Ryan's proposals in Congress to overhaul Medicare. Ryan says Medicare will be protected for people in and near retirement, and he wants to see younger generations offered alternatives to the entitlement.
Obama, campaigning in New Hampshire, cast the choice Election Day as one between two fundamentally different approaches to the government's responsibility to its citizens. His approach of casting Romney's plans as focused on a giveaway to the rich was familiar, but seemed to have a particularly sharp bite.
"They've been trying to sell this trickle-down snake oil before," he told an audience in Windham, N.H. "It did not work then. It will not work now. It will not reduce the deficit, it will not create jobs. It's the wrong direction for America."
Ryan took the stage in The Villages with his mother Betty Ryan Douglas, 78, while Romney scheduled a series of fundraisers in Massachusetts. The Wisconsin congressman said he saw Medicare's benefits firsthand as a young man when his grandmother, with Alzheimer's, moved in with his family. "My mom and I were her two primary caregivers," Ryan said before shifting to his mother and the promise of Medicare for her.
"She planned her retirement around this promise," Ryan said. "That's a promise we have to keep."
"It's not just a program," he added. "It's what my mom relies on."
He accused Obama of undermining Medicare by cutting billions from the program to devote to expanded coverage under his health care law, and asserted: "We want this debate. We need this debate. And we are going to win this debate.
Older Americans have often resisted changes in Medicare, the federal health care insurance program for people 65 and older, and for the disabled.
The Romney-Ryan ticket is betting that voters' worries about federal deficits and the Democrats' health care overhaul have opened the door for a robust debate on the solvency of Medicare, one of the government's most popular and costliest programs.
In the week since Romney announced Ryan as his running mate, Medicare and Social Security have appeared as a driving issue. Florida, Pennsylvania and Iowa are among the top five states in the percentage of people 65 and over, and all three are closely contested this election.
Polling generally finds that the public places more trust in Democrats' ability to handle Medicare. People also generally oppose plans to replace the current program with one in which future seniors receive a fixed amount of money from the government to be used to purchase health coverage, according to polls.
Ryan, a deficit hawk who has stood out in Washington for laying out tough spending choices that many lawmakers in both parties avoid, proposes to preserve the traditional Medicare program but only as one of many options for future retirees. His plan would encourage future retirees to consider private coverage that the government would help pay for through a voucher-like system.
Ryan's stop Saturday at the gated retirement cluster known as The Villages was familiar ground for presidential candidates. Florida has the highest concentration of voters over 65 in the country, with some 17 percent of Floridians fall into that group. Betty Ryan Douglas spends part of her year in Broward County's Lauderdale-by-the-Sea community and has been registered to vote in Florida since 1997.